Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

Posts

OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

#1

OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

Barry Irby

>My experiences with replacement windows has not been exactly excellent. FYI

About six or eight years ago I replaced three window in my family's Farmhouse. The first ones came in to Lowes and they called to say come get them. Then they said they didn't have them. Two more times. On the third time I got hostile and demanded a thorough search. They found them, broken. We were desperate for the windows so I put them in anyway. (Only one side of the insulated glass was broken). They sent replacement sashes. They did not fit. They sent a new set. They fit, but did not match, because the design of the dividers had been changed. I made them send me an entire new matching set. Four trips to install three windows.

This time I decided to put replacements in a rental house. They were Pella brand, what could possible go wrong? This time, they only had three of five in stock. I took them, being assured the other two would match. One of the three had a defective spring balance. Went to a different Lowes and got the other two, and a replacement of the damaged one. Put the three in and took the damaged one back. Went to install the kitchen window and it was missing a part. Temporarily installed it to fill up the hole and secure the house. Went back to Lowes and explained that the sill extension was missing. Mysteriously, they had a bunch of spares. Wonder how often this happens if they have spares? So this time it took three trips to two separate stores to get seven windows installed.

So my advice would be not to do replacement windows unless you have the patience of a stone.

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

#2

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

Terence Rice

>I am a professional builder and do both remodel and new construction. I would never even consider going to Lowes or any other big box store for my windows. Your local lumber yard will be able to supply your needs, have it right the first time and often at a price that is equal or lower for the same item. Do, however, keep in mind that some companies will make items that are lower quality and cheaper for the big boxes. (I don't know whether this is the case with Pella or not)

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

#3

We once picked up six doors at Lowes...

John in New Mexico

>They were the result of the same sort of botched special ordering. Supposed to be a set of french doors with custom deviders in the light (just the horizontals to match the 40's - 60's casement windows common in Tucson). They got the deviders right, but it was two left doors. Their customer was replacing a sliding glass door, so they ordered the doors w/o a jamb, and the first set had been cut shorter with a skill saw. There were two right doors too, obviously intended to fix the first mistake, though why there were two is perplexing. Trouble was, the deviders were the standard 4 horizontal + 1 vertical. Next there were two more left's with the deviders correct. I can just imagine the level of frustration their poor customer got to before giving up and demanding a refund. We bought the whole mess for $1200 - Aluminum clad wood doors, straight grain fir veneer inside, and replaced both sliding glass doors in our house, and added another french door in the dining room. All after swapping the glass panels and adding some kickplates to fix the weird heights.

Though we got a really good deal out of it, I think I'd be hesitent to custom order doors or windows through a borg.

John

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

#4

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

David Yoho

>The big box stores would be last on my list for something like that. I'd have to check places like Roper Brothers first.

David

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

#5

Re: OT Thinking of Replacement windows?

Barry Irby

>David, A little over twenty years ago I was builder in the Richmond Va area. Don't get me going on Roper Brothers.

You are in the area and probably are familiar with Ruffin and Payne. Called all over looking for 5/8 Underlayment Grade plywood. They were the only place that claimed they had it. (Plywood and Plastics had something made out of some rain forest wood I never heard of, but it was not Underlayment Grade, but they thought it would be "OK".) Drove from Chester to Ruffin and Payne after borrowing my son's truck. Paid over $32 a sheet for the plywood. Turns out it is 19/32 in spite of their insistence it was 5/8. Got to figure how to make up the 1/32.