Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Pricing your Work

Posts

Pricing your Work

#1

Bart Goldberg

Pricing your Work

Bart Goldberg

>I have a friend that has asked for a price to build a writing desk for her daughter. I'm kinda new at pricing my work, so I was hoping to get some advice.

How do you determine the price for a piece?

I was assuming the following: Cost of material plus my time at some reasonable labor rate?

I was figuring on around 30-40 hours to build the desk. I gave a round figure of about 900 dollars for my time/labor plus materials. Does this seem high?

Thanks

Bart

Re: Pricing your Work

#2

Re: Pricing your Work

Jesse in New Mexico

>Hey Bart,

There are a few ways to approach an answer.

1)Is this a fair/competitive price for a writing desk? Friends and family often think that we can build furniture cheaper than they can buy it at the store. Just ain't so. So don't be offended if your friend balks. On the other hand, you will probably work with him to find out exactly what he wants and thats what he will get (try to find that in a store). If customization is important to him, then the price is almost inarguably fair.

2)Are you going to loose your shirt on this? I suggest making a detailed plan and cutlist to get a good estimate of the materials. Include a generous allowance for lumber waste. Don't forget finishing materials, etc. Use a similar process for your time. Think about how many joints in the project, how many machine set-ups, are you going to have to chase around town to get all the materials, etc. Pick a fair rate - not minimum wage, and do the math.

3)Since this is a friend, do you owe him a discount? Only you can decide that. Just remember that if you give him a bargain, he will probably be back and always expect that same rate.

One other thing I have learned the hard way, communication is vital. Work up a detailed drawing and get his ok before you buy materials. Use some scrap material to test various finish options and get his ok early in the project. Communication errors are the most costly ones.

Good luck and take lots of pics!

Jess

Re: Pricing your Work

#3

I don't intend to be " flip " . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>but selling to friends and / or family is like playing pool with them for money. Bad, bad, bad. Never do business with either. Charge for the materials, the rest is a favor. Them telling thier friends where they got it is enough. Just my outlook on the cosmos though.

Re: Pricing your Work

#4

Re: I don't intend to be " flip " . . .

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I agree. That way, however the estimates come out, you're square with the world.

This is, however, a hobbyist woodworker talking, at least from here. I have no interest in doing this for a living.

My neighbor spent most of his weekend working on some casework for a friend from his place of employment. It was a beautiful weekend here, but Brad spent almost the entire weekend in his driveway, building a simple case for someone else. His complaint? That the fellow was already talking about some more cabinets.

What we _can_ do, and what we _want to_ do often differ greatly.

Re: Pricing your Work

#5

Re: Pricing your Work

Johanna

>Bart, the price of a desk can vary enormously. I just finished a built-in desk for our home office. It is a large, U-shaped affair that wraps around 3 sides of a small room. It has five lower cabinets and four upper cabinets. It is made of red oak plywood and red oak. The cost of materials alone was over $1300. Had I made it of maple or walnut or if it was more elaborate, it would have cost more in both time and materials. Unfortunately, I did not keep track of the time involved, but it was easily over 150 hours.

My point in this is that you need to get a firm idea of what is wanted before quoting a price. At the very least, do a couple of rough drawings.

Re: Pricing your Work

#6

Bart Goldberg

Re: I don't intend to be " flip " . . .

Bart Goldberg

>Oh I agree that making things for friends gets to be a slippery slope with regards to charging. In my specific situation, I have already built a really nice Deacon bench for this friend, and only charged her for my material cost. But I can't always be that altruistic. Especially when I've been out of work for 5 months and counting and she's offering to pay.

On a separate thought, I don't think most people have an appreciation for how long it takes to make really beautiful things from wood. Even simple stuff I make takes 10-12 hours to complete (usually spread over several days). Their sense of furniture value is being set by places like IKEA, where you can get a desk for $150.00.

Just a rant

Bart

Re: Pricing your Work

#7

Re: I don't intend to be " flip " . . .

dwr

>I did a writing desk a year ago for my SIL. Comparable retail version by other woodworking professionals were in the $950-$1200 range. My material was kiln dried direct from the mill... all solid QSWO. I had at least 40 man-hours into it. She was a single parent and I agreed to $300 to cover mostly materials. I though it would bring other business and asked her not to tell what I charged her. However, I now keep getting champagne taste and beer budget requests from people that can afford the very best... even from well off family members. They have a habit of comparing handmade solid hardwood to Ikea... nice, huh?

So, after a lot of deliberating, I no longer do freebies for family or friends as it sends a message that my time, effort, and quality of work is no better than KD furniture from overseas.

My SIL was so pleased with the desk that she will not let anyone near it for love nor money... so in that regard, it was rewarding.

Only you know your situation and each one is different.

Good luck.

Re: Pricing your Work

#8

Re: Pricing your Work

RK in Milwaukee

>Hi Bart,

No one knows what your work is worth until you tell them. Time and materials is the most reliable way to come up with a price. To me there are only two ways to do this. Either give it as a gift with no mental strings attached, or charge full price.

People rarely appreciate what they get for free. It's human nature. But it also makes sense since free comes with no frame of reference. Now if you do it free, and make them stand and watch every minute you are working, then they would have a reference point.

If make a really terrific desk, then the price you quoted is reasonable. If your work is crappy, then your price is too high regardless of what you charge.

Hope this helps in some small way.

Ron Nelson

Re: Pricing your Work

#9

JL

Re: I don't intend to be " flip " . . .

JL

>$900 for 30 hours work, with her paying the materials cost is a generous price on your part. Figure in something for overhead charges also. How much is up to you.

Re: Pricing your Work

#10

Re: Pricing your Work

Sgian Dubh

>Bart, if you can get hold of a copy of the December 2006 issue of Woodwork out of California (issue 102) my article on estimating for furniture makers might give you some pointers.

It details such things as the time required to do jobs as well as how to charge for materials, all from a professionals point of view. It doesn't tell you how much to charge per hour, but it does discuss such factors as allowing for overhead.

If you can get a handle on these elements, and more, it's then up to you how much or how little you charge. It depends on whether or not you actually want to make a profit. Not everyone does want to make a profit, and some people are willing to work for less money than their real outgoings. From my point of view that's anathema, but many amateurs are willing to take a thumping loss on every one of their charged jobs just for the fun of the making.

Usually they don't even realise how much of a loss they're making because they've got a little extra cash jingling in their pocket. But that's not the same as covering your real costs or overhead, e.g., heating, lighting, wear and tear, maintenance, replacement tooling, etc..

Anyway, the article is out there if you have a real desire to know how to price your work. Slainte.

Re: Pricing your Work

#11

Re: Pricing your Work

HC Sakman

>That was a very well detailed and helpful article! I really enjoyed it & found it very useful.

Thanks,

Chico...

Re: Pricing your Work

#12

Re: Pricing your Work

Sgian Dubh

>I'm glad you enjoyed it Chico. I've had a lot of favourable feedback about that article. It's even been said by a few that have contacted that they've never seen that subject covered in woodworking magazines before.

I don't know if that's true or not, but there certainly has been a lot of reaction to it. At one point I was getting between four and six emails a day about it. That lasted for about six weeks just after publication. It was hard work keeping up with all that lot, ha, ha.

I still get one or two emails a week about it. Amazing really. Slainte.

Re: Pricing your Work

#13

Alan Young

Ditto to Chico's comments!

Alan Young

>

Re: Pricing your Work

#14

Re: Pricing your Work

Mark McC

>Not had a ton of experience selling my work, but whenever I have been approached by friends, I always try to position the price in two ways.

First if my skills allow, that they will get a solid, better made, custom piece, and second,that I will save them SOME money versus what they would pay for virtually the same thing at a store.

Not save 65%+ or get it free, just that they'll save "some" money.

Hey what are friends for? But it still needs to be balanced.

Generally, I have found I can build something of quality,save my friends a few bucks,and be compensated for materials, tool wear,and labour without taking a "hardcore" pricing approach.

Those "friends" who have really been looking for a "steal" know that I responded positively by offerring them a quality custom made piece, at a MUCH better price then they could get anywhere else.

If they still pass after that ....it's not my bad!

Re: Pricing your Work

#15

Re: Pricing your Work

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If furniture making is to be your livlihood, follow Richard's advice. If it's a hobby, then $35/hour plus materials x 1.2.

Clint

Re: Pricing your Work

#16

Re: Pricing your Work

David Mathias - Central OH

>I don't know how you pros do it. A guy I work with asked me about making a mission style coffee table. I gave him a ballpark figure of $500-$600 which I thought was low for a custom piece. A few days later he came back with a picture of a piece from a local Amish store. Solid cherry mission style table, 22x48x17 for $330 (I verified the price). The design is a little lacking in my opinion but not objectionable. Anyway, I told him it wasn't worth it to me to compete with that.

I just do this for fun. I can't imagine trying to make a living at this while competing with that. I respect you guys who are able to make a go of it.

David

Re: Pricing your Work

#17

Re: Pricing your Work

r payne

>Of course the Amish don't spend on a lot of the expenses that those in the modern world think are necessary. You could charge that as well if you lived as they did.

ron