Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Bandsaw Tension Gauge

Posts

Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#1

Bandsaw Tension Gauge

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I busted a bandsaw blade while home at lunch for no good reason. I was cross cutting a little 1/2"x1/4"x6" piece of Holly, and Bang....those things happen I suppose.

I necessitated installation of a new blade of course, and while doing it, I got to thinking about bandsaw tensioning, and tension gauges. I have a new Rikon Ultimate 14" bansaw, and it has a "Gauge", but because a got a boatload of some blades that are just a hair too small, I had to adjust stuff on the saw to accomodate them, and whatever functionallity and accuracy it had is gone. So, I mostly do the "Tension it until it will not move more than 1/4" when pushed on from the side" thing. But I always thought that was pretty much a swag, and a function of the thickness of the blade, how far apart the wheels of the saw were, etc, I go to thinking again about a Tension Gauge. Iturra has their's for around $150, but I recall seeing something so simple as a couple pieces of wood clamped to the blade and a feeler gauge used to determine when they were 0.xx" apart, but do not remember the details.

Recommendations? I will gladly accept help from all over the spectrum - from the just push on it crowd, to the buy a tuning fork and tension until you get an exact C Sharp crowd.

Appreciate it.

Mark

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#2

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Mark,

The shopmade tension you might be remembering was in FWW Jan/Feb 2001 by John White called Shopmade Tension Gauge.

Jim


Shopmade Tension Gauge

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#3

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

Charles R. Smith

>Mark, I think the article to which you made reference was one by John White, entitled "Shopmade Tension Gauge". It was in the 2001 January/February Fine Woodworking (issue 147). There was an omission in the article, as it forgot to mention the spacing between the clamps -- they should be 5 inches apart.

Another woodworking publication recently rated bandsaw tensioning gauges. I recall that the Carter electronic device was top rated. Unfortunately, I cannot find my reference to that article, so some one else will have to help you.

Charles in Victoria (where the plum trees' blossoms are being blown off by the winds)

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#4

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

bill tindal, E.TN

>I have a 14" saw and blades bust from fatigue after a while. I was told by a band saw mfg . that 14" is about the minimum one could make a band saw wheel and have blades last a reasonable time-the smaller the wheel the more the flex going around it.

Anyway, I used to fret over tension and now I don't. A wide blade has a vastly more positive effect on straight resawing than how tight it was. I never could resaw with a 1/4" and it seems any tension that holds the blade on the wheel works with the 3/4".

Bottom line is that I run at what ever minimum tension keeps the blade on the wheel. As was discussed in a post a few weeks ago adequate set in the blade is the main factor that leads to success.

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#5

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I agree with Bill. And keep in mind that Duginske has said that keepiong the blade centered on the tires is more important than tension, etc. Having done just that for a bit now I can see it is true.

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#6

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

john lucas

>Mark There is an excellent article on bandsaw tension and the myths that go along with it in the February 2007 Woodworkers Journal Written by Mark Duginske and Aaron Gesicki. It's long and envolved and they tested a bunch of tension gauges.

What they found was the tension settings on your saw are probably accurate. I found that interesting because I tested my saw using the method you were looking for where you use a feeler guage and set the saw for 15,000 PSI. I tested a 3/8" blade and a 1/4" blade and the marked settings on my Delta 14" were extremely close.

It's worth reading that article if you can find it.

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#7

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

wilbur

>The Woodworker's Journal article was good in its methods and data, but fell down on when it came to the conclusion. It is clear from the testing that (1) aftermarket tension gauges may not be as accurate as one would like, and (2) if your goal is 15,000 PSI, the onboard bandsaw gauges are accurate enough.

Unfortunately, for some reason they decided to conclude that this meant that tensioning a bandsaw to greater than 15,000 PSI was not useful, which is the "myth" that is supposed to be busted that the cover of that issue of Woodworker's Journal refers to. This may be a true statement, but it's not supported by this data.

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#8

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

arw01

>Centered on the wheel means what exactly? The teeth centered? The middle of the back of the blade? The whole width of the blade centered?

I've got an unusual bandsaw that is small and takes up to a 2" wide blade.

Alan

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#9

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge (Long)

Ken Garlock, Collin County TX

>Hello John. I respect your opinion, but the tension test in WJ was so superficial that it was nearly useless. The main problem was that the Editors did not allow sufficient space to really address the subject.

First off the gauges were compared against each other and not to a known standard that is traceable to the NIST. What you ended up with one gauge displaying a number and the other agreeing or not. They all could have been reading 15,000 psi, but who knows what the real values were. The article did not list the actual values obtained but did side with the Carter gauge because it always returned to a zero reading when tension was removed.

Because of the lengthy discussion over at SMC, Mark is going do do a new set of tests based up information and requirements gleaned from the SMC thread. Since I was one of the major antagonists, Mark bought my Ittura gauge to use in his testing. I believe Mark wrote his first article in good faith and did not intentionally try to miss lead the reader. I also believe that Mark is a lot wiser in the ways of tension testing because of the inputs from multiple people posting to the SMC WJ article thread.

Mark will be releasing a new bandsaw book this summer; I plan on buying it. In the meantime I think I will buy a Starrett tension gauge.

Happy saw dust,

Ken

PS. It is not my intention to bad mouth Mark. We had multiple Emails back and forth, and I find him to be a gentleman. Maybe someday we will be able to set down over a cup of coffee and discuss band saws....

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

#10

Re: Bandsaw Tension Gauge

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Thanks to everyone for their contributions here. All were informative.

I got a copy of the FWW article on how to make a gauge, and a cost of $6 for a set of feeler gauges, and about 30 minutes of my time.

I called Rikon Support and Rod told me that their built in gauge produces blade tension in the 15K PSI range, so I was able to use the gauge I made, to re-calibrate the on machine gauge.

thanks all

Mark