Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Whiteside Router Bits

Posts

Whiteside Router Bits

#1

Whiteside Router Bits

Dave Winters

>Has anyone heard of this:

Our sharpening service says that Whiteside router bits get shipped dull from the factory because of some lawsuit and must be sharpened before use.

Sounds like a lot of horsepuckey to me, but a brand new bit we just got was very dull after 6 passes...???

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#2

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

Jesse in New Mexico

>Sounds straight from the horse's other end to me too.

I just bought a couple of whiteside bits, they were sharp out of the box and are still sharp after some pretty heavy use.

Wouldn't make sense to sell router bits that need to be sharpened as a bit part of the quality of a bit is how precise the dimensions are, e.g. is that 1/2 straight bit really 0.50 or 0.55 or 0.45?

BTW, when my sharpening guy told me that Forrest WWII blades weren't worth the $$, he conveniently had some other blades that "he was willing to part with for a fair price". ROFL!!

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#3

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

Marc Rosen

>That would really startle me if it were true. I have been buying and using Whiteside for over a year now and have not noticed any initially dull cutters or cutters going dull quickly. I'm using dovetail, straight- without and with guide bearings - and roundover bits. Whitesides are nicely priced at my local Woodcraft and I'll continue to buy them. Can't imagine why your sharpening service would say that.

Marc

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#4

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

DickL

>>Whitesides are nicely priced at my local Woodcraft

It's good of you to support your local sources. If they can't supply what you need, try www.holbren.com for good prices and free shipping on Whitesides. (Just a satisfied customer - no affiliation.)

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#5

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

Jim Dillon

>Dave,

Sounds like horsepuckey to me as well. While I have a stable of CMT bits (and like them a lot), I have bought a few Whiteside bits during the past several years bits and find them to be great as well and, for sure, sharp right out of the package. FWIW, FWW did a test several years ago comparing a number of brand-name bits and I seem to remember that Whiteside did very, very well. And I don't remember any mention of having to resharpen their bits before testing.

Jim

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#6

Counter-intuitive

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>That would be counter-intuitive. A dull bit is more dangerous than a sharp one. Few would think to check or make the effort to sharpen a brand new bit. A dull bit out of the box would be an invitation for greater risk.

Tom

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#7

Re: Please support the WoodCentral sponsors

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>IMHO, I disagree with providing information or recommending purchasing from sites of non-sponsors of the WoodCentral website for items that are sold by these sponsors. I value this site highly, and want to financially support Ellis in maintaining the site. The sponsors are helping support the site and deserve to be the first source of items purchased by us. Therefore I try to purchase all my supplies and tools from the sponsors' listed on the MARKETPLACE (column to the left). RouterBits.com and WoodCraft both sells the Whiteside bits and are Major sponsors' of the site. I do price compare and have purchased from non-sponsor's only when there is a huge difference in cost (usually due to a special sale). For your information, I have found RouterBits.com sell the bits cheaper (regular prices) than anyone else I have seen on the web. Their shipping has been very fast and prices great. I have bought one set of bits and several singles and recommend them highly. Woodcraft has many sales of the Whiteside bits and also are a great supplier. Please try to support this site as Ellis has to make it profitable or it could disappear.

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#8

Have you no sympathy?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>What would happen to all those UPS and FEDEX delivery guys?

After dropping the box with the bits, and the bits falling out inside the truck or the loading dock, they might cut themselves as they picked them up and put them back into the broken box if the bits were fully sharp ;)

This is also true of Gilette shaving rasors now. They come dull to protect the store workers who have to stock the shelves.

;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#9

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

Ted Wong

>Can you say B--s---? I've used Whiteside for years and have bought through Routerbits.com All I can say is that each time I've used a Whiteside I've never been dissatisfied. All bits go dull with use eventually. Getting a dull bit after six passes can be attributed to many things like dirty material, too slow of router speed or feed, very dense and abrasive material, trying to take off too much material in a single pass, using a bit for purposes that were not intended for the bit, etc. Whether it's worth sharpening depends on who you talk to. If it were me I'd start shopping around for another sharpening service. Anyone that disseminates B.S. like that seems kind of dishonest or ill-informed to me and is not woth dealing with.

Re: Whiteside Router Bits

#10

FYI - Woodcraft has all Whiteside @ 20% off.

Art Silva

>