Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT: Running BX cable?

Posts

OT: Running BX cable?

#1

OT: Running BX cable?

wilbur

>So I managed to hang fluorescent lights in my workshop and do some electrical repairs in my basement without killing myself this weekend. Now I'm on to the next phase, which is to permanently wire in my fluorescent lights. I'm using BX cable. How tightly can I bend BX cable to make a 90 degree turn without worrying about cracking the armor or causing a short?

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#2

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>http://books.google.com/books?id=hoKRpBF-5TEC&pg=PA52&lpg=PA52&dq=ac+cable+bend+radius&source=web&ots=fV2Cn4BqoD&sig=_zLlU5khpnx6qgD7HrQkPVMA4As

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#3

Why BX cable?

Ray - SW Ohio

>Does building codes require it? Just curious.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#4

Curve radius for type AC (amored cable)...

John in New Mexico

>is taken to be not less than 5 times the diameter of the type AC cable. Not sure if that will help or not, I'm no expert in reading the NEC, but bx is not listed in the index, though I do know what you're refering to. Maybe someone with more specific knowledge will speak up, or maybe the type AC guideline is enough to give you a target.

John

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#5

Re: Why BX cable?

wilbur

>Al, thanks -- that was just what I needed.

Ray, the ceiling in my shop isn't finished. It's just floor rafters. I got nervous about flying bits of wood cutting Romex in half.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#6

Re: Why BX cable?

Bill Howatt

>Nothing is impossible but I'd say it is very improbable. My disasters tend to fly horizontal rather than vertical. I also doubt that you would ever seriously damage a romex cable with a piece of flying wood. My shop is the same as yours; I have no concerns about wire damage.

Bill

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#7

Re: Why BX cable?

wilbur

>Forgot to mention -- most of the wiring in my house, especially in the workshop area, is old BX cable, so I also figured I'd try to match.

Geez. I must be the only one to consider the aesthetics of wiring in planning out the electrical system of a workshop. :@)

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#8

Re: Why BX cable?

Ray SW Ohio

>I would use romex, main reason, the cost. You can still make it look nice either way. My 2�.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#9

Re: Why BX cable?

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>The way the price of Romex has gone crazy (last time I looked it was still over sixty bucks a box) I hate to think what BX is going for now.

In addition, you need connectors for the BX which is an added expense and although you can cut it with dikes, the best way is with a special tool that you might never use again.

I guess anything is possible, but in over thirty-five years of doing electrical work off and on and talking to others doing it I have never heard of Romex being damaged in the manner mentioned here. Romex ain't cheap anymore but it is still a lot cheaper and easier to work with than BX. Use Romex.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#10

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

DB

>You are correct in using BX cable (now called AC or amored cable). The inside radius should not be less than 5 times the diameter of the cable. IE: 1/2" cable shal be bent no less than a 2-1/2" radius.

NM and NMC cable (also improperly called Romex which is a brand name) is not permited in exposed location except when protected with something like conduit. There are other places that NM and NMC are not allowed and other ways to protect the cable But I will let you check the code for your self.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#11

Or rubber sheathed cord?

John in New Mexico

>Isn't this allowed above a certain height? 8' sounds familiar. Agree that NM/NMC is a no-no, but seen it done often enough, along with lots of other winning errors.

Sounds like Wilbur's got his plan figured out though.

John

not a professional electrician

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#12

Re: Curve radius for type AC (amored cable)...

Phil Joines Krum, TX

>BX is no longer approved. As I recall, about 15 years it was disallowed because there was no actual ground conductor. The armor was supposed to act as the ground but there were fires caused by the armor heating from current flow. It was replaced by AC (armored cable) which does have a ground conductor.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#13

Get 90 degree connectors.

Phil Joines Krum, TX

>

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#14

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>NM and NMC cable (also improperly called Romex which is a brand name) is not permited in exposed location except when protected with something like conduit.

So you are saying that all the houses with a panel in the basement and the homeruns of NM or Romex or whatever you want to call it running through holes in the floor joists are wired against code? I have wired around thirty houses, I have worked in hundreds more, and about the only place I've seen RESIDENTIAL use of BX is in old two conductor installations. There must be a lot of contractors out there who pay no attention to code. Commercial is another matter. I have used BX cable on commercial jobs in conjuction with conduit.

As far as calling it Romex being improper is concerned....come on!

That's how everybody I know refers to it and I know folks who are in their sixties and have done the work their entire lives. Every trade has its slang and terminology. I have know in conjuction with electrical work to use words like football and Kerney. That may not be the "proper" name but the guy at the counter at Kirby Risk knows what I'm asking for.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#15

Clarification

wilbur

>Sorry for the confusion.

The wire that I'm currently using that I originally referred to as BX actually is 14/2 armored cable with hot, neutral, and ground wires in the cable. The older wiring in my basement is BX with just hot and neutral wires, with the armor carrying the ground.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#16

Cost

wilbur

>For my application, the cost wasn't that big of a factor. I'll be using about 60' of cable altogether. The price difference between a 100' length of 14/2 BX was only about $20 more than the same length of Romex at the local big box store. I would have to use clamps where the cable met the junction boxes and fixtures either way, and it seemed that the price difference there would be minimal.

So I figured that spending $25 on insurance against flying objects, or more likely in my case, snagging an overhead electrical cable with a long board (my "ceiling" height is less than 7 feet, and all of the wiring is exposed) was not a bad idea.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#17

I agree with you

Ray SW Ohio

>

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#18

Re: Cost

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>The next thing I would ask is why #14 and not #12. With 14 anywhere in the circuit you limited to a 15 amp breaker.

As far as the BX is concerned, it is hard to use box clamps designed for romex and retain the plastic bushings that MUST be present in the cut ends of the BX. Without those bushing you are in much greater danger than any that might exist from accidental collision with romex. The connectors made for BX on the other hand serve two purposes. The first is allow connection to the cable without crushing it as might happen with straps made for romex (C-500s). The second is to retain the bushing. As I said in a post below, the only place I've ever used BX - and I've run quite a bit of it - is on commercial jobs, and I have always connected it to conduit boxes.

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#19

Re: Cost

wilbur

>Hi Randy,

I'm tying my shop lights into a preexisting 15 amp circuit that also feeds the lights in my kitchen, which is upstairs from my workshop area. By my calculations, I'm still well within the capacity of the circuit with the addition of my fluorescents:

120V x 15 amps x 75% = 1350 safe watts total on circuit.

Workshop: 7 fluorescent fixtures with 2 T8 32 watt bulbs = 448 watts

Kitchen: 6 75 watt halogens and 3 15 watt compact fluorescents = 495 watts

Total: 943 watts, which gives me an additional 400 watts of headroom for this circuit.

Also, I am using proper BX clamps -- I'm not trying to use Romex clamps on BX wire. THe difference in price was negligible. I also am using the plastic bushings. They came with the wire.

My workshop outlets for tools and machines are all 20 amp circuits, and run off of a separate subpanel. I decided to put the lights on a completely different circuit so that even if the main subpanel breaker trips, I will still have light.

I agree that BX is used far more often in commercial settings than in a residential setting, and may be overkill. But in my case, I figured for an additional $25, and for piece of mind, why not?

Wilbur

Re: OT: Running BX cable?

#20

All comes down to the AHJ...

John in New Mexico

>and how they choose to define "exposed". I'd be amazed though if an inspector didn't ding you on romex running from a ceiling box into a hanging fixutre. Sure it works, and bailing wire wrapped in masking tape will work too, but clearly romex would be the better choice of the two. Add a third choice- trying to follow the NEC even if its not going to get inspected- and its the best choice of the three.

John