Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

Posts

Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#1

Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We've all lamented recently about how bad things are at Home Depot. Apparently we're not the only ones complaining. Here's a very interesting article on MSN today.

Happy Woodworking!


http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/Ext

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#2

hmmmm........28% ?

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>...try 210 million %

That former CEO is reading this story and laughing his backside off.

What they were thinking to pay him off that much is beyond me.

Course paying ANY professional sports player several jillion per year is ludacris as well.

If the event pricing escalates to keep up with the over-inflated salaries we keep seeing then few of us will be able to enjoy "the game" in person anymore.

Scott

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#3

Whoo Hweee ! Here We Go.

Robert Hutchins

>Or as the host on the GOO (Grand Ole Opry for you whippersnappers) used to say, "Let 'er go, boys!"

RANT WARNING:

The borg model goes bust! Maybe that's what they will say about these retailing monstrosities. And I don't mean just those in the home improvement product business like the orange and blue borgs. I'd like to see the Bentonville bandits go belly flop, too.

Now I'm old enough to remember corner grocery stores about every 5 or 6 blocks and grocery delivery boys on bikes. Those proprietors new the names addresses and phone numbers of every household they served. You could phone in an order - if the party line wasn't busy - and have it delivered to your door. Most of the women in our neighborhood worked at home and ordered groceries daily or every 2-3 days and paid in cash with a nickel or a dime for the grocery boy. Then A&P came to town. Customer service and convenience have all been downhill since then.

We used to have neighborhood hardware stores too. I mean the real, rolling ladder, oiled floors, old guys chewing the fat on slow mornings kind of hardware stores where they were rarely out of the widget you needed - and that widget generally didn't cost much more a few cents either. And the knowledge of the proprietors and clerks about their wares was astounding. I can close my eyes and still smell that magical aroma that wafted up every time I entered S. M Young & Son. Took me about 10 years to figure out which one was the '& Son'.

Add to that list of lost havens the corner drug store where the pharmacist remembered the last time you were sick and the soda fountain and magazine rack were nirvana for kids with 50 cents in their pockets. And the neighborhood five and dime, and the Greek restaurant, and the corner filling station, and the clothing stores and 'downtown' merchants who ran their small businesses and lived, worked and worshipped in the same places you did!

We consumers have been had for decades. The MBA lie that the efficiencies saved us countless dollars is just that - a lie. Sure we might have save a few pennies on the receipt, but how much has it cost us in time, service and information? The only efficiency in the equation has been that which made corporations ever more powerful economically ergo politically. How much of the Bentonville bandits' profits benefit your local economy? How fast do you think the money our your pockets gets sucked back to international money markets instead of going into your local bank (another oxymoron) where its recirculated to benefit your community?

May I live long enough to see the pendulum swing back.

OK, the drugs are kicking in now. I'll leave the soap box for someone else.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#4

So, True, Mark

Don Henthorn

>It is really amazing that all these really smart MBA's coming our of our so called universities haven't learned the most basic thing that any successful business man knows and that is "the customer is your business." Without him/her there is no business. But these really smart guys are so busy figuring out how they can squeeze the last tiny penny out of a customer that they forget that the first order of business is to keep the customer coming back. I know so many people who no longer go to Home Depot for that reason.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#5

Gave Up a year ago

Kevin Rabenaldt

>All that is said has been true for me too. I never could understand what management was thinking when they have so few to check you out. I do not have time to wait. Cheaper to buy elsewhere at a higher price than to wait. I know they know this because I have seen people complain to them. It never changes anything.

That is why I rarely set foot in HD anymore. I do use Lowe's thought.

Kevin

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#6

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers?

Winnemucca Lynn

>Was at HD this morning, looking for a heat gun. After first looking in the paint department and not finding it, I went to the wood tools department and still no luck. back to the paint department. I was getting ready to leave, when I saw the first employee I had seen so far. He told me, "Sure. They're over by the garden sprayers." Silly me not to have looked there first.

Lynn

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#7

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers?

Falberg saw Co

>Why would anyone in their right mind get dressed and go out burning gas in traffic to buy stuff when you can have it delivered to your door in a couple days for the same price, and often less, without even putting on a pair of shoes? Big Boxes don't have anything you can't get cheaper on-line, where there is no line. It appears to me that Mom and Pop are still here, but they're not on First and Main anymore, they're on the internet. The service is still great, too.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#8

Re: Whoo Hweee ! Here We Go. Again.

RK in Milwaukee

>Consumers in this country love to be had. We are a nation addicted to junk and we are a nation addicted to "deals". Savings in this country are in the negative numbers right now. Why? Because we love to max out our credit cards on cheap crap and manufactured collectables we don't need when we are depressed.

Look around these boards for two minutes. Everyone wants a deal on a tool. So, we shop at Amazon.Com instead of supporting a local store that carries inventory. Then we complain when the local store goes belly up. Everyone wants a free lunch and everyone believes there is a free lunch. But there isn't. Used to be you would buy a motor that cost $400 and lasted 20 years. Now we buy a $50 motor that lasts two years. Is that a deal?

I used to shoot catalog photos for many hardware companies here in Milwaukee. Milwaukee Electric Tool, Briggs and Stratton, Design House, Gardner Bender and other national names were my clients. I learned from Milwaukee Electric Tool that you don't get the same drill at Home Depot that you get from a professional trade supplier. Every year Briggs and Stratton would put new casings and stickers on their engines and claim a bigger horsepower rating when the engine itself hadn't changed. I saw professional salesmen leave these businesses because they could no longer put up with the abuse they had to endure when calling on Walmart, Home Depot or Menards. Those companies don't ask these companies what they charge. They tell them in no uncertain terms what they are going to charge and they aren't polite when they do it.

The MBO's are just giving us what we want. Customers want cheaper products and Shareholders want bigger profits. Do you have a pension or investment in a mutual fund? Then you are the Shareholder these folks are playing to. Every time you shop at a discounter, you are part of the problem. You really shouldn't complain about losing your health benefits or pension if you support these business models. We as a country have to wake up and understand that we can't have it both ways. Everytime you demand a "deal" on something, quality gets cut in factory somewhere.

I have always wanted to ask the CEO's of some of these companies who is going to buy their crap after they have outsourced all of our jobs to China. It's going to be a contest to see who is the last man standing.

And do you know who is holding all of the debt we have created? Communist China and a bunch of countries we don't like in the Middle East.

Wanna get rich quick? Find something to sell to stupid people. There's more of them.

Thanks for listening.

Ron Nelson

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#9

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers?

Edward in Vancouver

>About a year ago here in Vancouver they yanked out half of the cash registers (not that they were staffed...) and stuck in those new do-it yerself jobbies instead. I was dumb enough to give them a try- with a plastic sack full of t-nuts and other assorted hardware. Left the bag on the counter and walked away, haven't been back since. We still have the CDN version of it, called Rona, virtually indistinguisable from THEM-except that they have REAL (albeit un-stafffed...) registers.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#10

Re: Gave Up a year ago

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I gave up on Sears at least 20 years ago for pretty much the same reasons and have not been in a Sears store since. I am very close to that again with Home Depot. I live within a mile of a HD and right next door to it is a Wally World Super Store. I hate both places.In both places if you need assistance, you are lucky if you can find someone who is knowledgeable and if you do you better be bi lingual. English seems to be a second language in both places.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#11

Small town hardware.

Basil

>For me it was Harper Hardware, they had everything from tumb tacks to dynamite in their store. Well, the dynamite was stored outside of town but everything else was in the store. Leather goods for making harness to belts for machines and the lacing tools to fix you right up. Rivets by the thousands and welding supplies, from doorbell wire and drycell batteries to giant reels of steel cable(even no-spin). Nuts, bolts, taps & dies, screws You just name it they had it.

Now-a-days it takes half a day to figure where to go to get what you need. Then 2 days to visit all the places that are supposed to have it. Then 2 more days waiting for UPS to deliver it. A one hour or less trip to Harper Hardware used to do the trick.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#12

Re: Whoo Hweee ! Here We Go.

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>When I was a kid back in the fifties and sixties the town I live in had at least four lumber/ hardware stores. By the time I came back from my stint in the military it was down to two. Not long after that it was down to one.

The one that was left is what many envision when they think of the �local hardware store�. Wood floors, stuff piled all over the place, a big rotating bin with scales for buying nails, and if anything was in stock in 1955 and it wasn�t sold it�s still there somewhere.

The big difference from the nostalgic hardware store is the owner. He is about as rude as any individual I have ever had the displeasure to know. I have worked for places that required me to buy there, but when it was my own money I long ago adopted a policy of driving to another town to do business before doing it there. I simply will not do business with the man regardless of the price.

About four or five years ago competition arrived. The new store is one of several owned by the same person but it is a far cry from HD or Lowe�s. Most of the people who were there the day it opened are still there and the newest one has been there for over a year. If you can�t find something they can tell you EXACTLY where it is, as opposed to the uninterested point and reply of �over there somewhere� that the other store offers.

Before the arrival of competition the parking lot of the older store was always full. Now, it is unusual to see even one car there. All the cars are at the new store. The guy that owns the older store also owns about half the county. The doors could close tomorrow and it wouldn�t affect him a bit. (Sort of like the guys at the top of any major business) But hopefully, he has started to wake up to the fact that you can only treat people like dirt when they have no other choice because you are the only game in town.

I could go to any BORG and get better treatment than I got from the old hardware store. Smaller doesn't always mean better.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#13

It is easy to complain until you live without one

Mike in Paradise

>in your area. When I lived in Ontario and had tons of depots available I had lots of complaints.

When I moved to Paradise and had no access to a home depot I could not believe the poor stock quality and quantity and the outrageous prices at the local building stores. Plus they all closed on Sunday.

I missed being able to pick up lumber stored inside as opposed to outside with all the frost in it in the winter.

Then we get a depot in and all of sudden the local stores have to become price competitive. They had to start opening on Sunday. Plus I love it when a depot is new as it is fully stocked.

I will agree about the staff as mentioned in the article as they really don't know anything and are are to find.

My biggest complaint is trying to force you through the self checkout lines. Here there will be 6 self check-out that no one, including me is using and a big lineup at the one lone check-out that is manned by a person.

Still I would suggest that you go and live in a place without access to a big box chain within 1000 km's and 8 hr ferry ride away and see what your thoughts are then!

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#14

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers?

Glenn Clabo - RI

>After the Challenger tragedy there was a phrased use to explain these kinds of things. It's called "Normalization of Deviance". It happens in many industries these days...and mine(DOD)is not excluded.

It happens when over a long term individuals or teams (and then customers?) repeatedly accept a lower standard of performance until that lower standard becomes the �norm�. It begins when the acceptance of the lower standard because the individual/team is under pressure (budget, schedule, etc.) perceives it will be too difficult to hold to the expected standard. Their intention may be to revert back to the higher standard later but because they get away with it they then fail to see their actions as deviant.

We see this in many areas of our lives...like customer service...but mostly...like HD...it's just an aggravation. Think about what's happening behind the scenes in important areas. Was that bridge you're about to cross designed based on cost and schedule? Is that plane maintained based on need or schedule? Scary isn't it...

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#15

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers?

albertabob

>My experiences are similar to many that you folks are expressing.

I shop at HD now only out of necessity.

On Sunday I needed a short length of 1-1/4" pipe for a project and went to one closest to me. Only one clerk in the area and he was dragging himself up ,and down the aisle as if he was a little boy in detention.

I found a piece of conduit at the pipe cut off station and followed this unhappy little man until I could swing by him and make eye contact.

"How much is this pipe?" I asked.

He replied "That's not for sale- go get a full length of it from electical" He then waddled off leaving me standing.

The fast of the matter was that I would have accepted apices of black iron 1-1/4" and a stantion if they had any but the they don't stock it!

I left and got the hardware I needed at another supplier.

The point is that in a good store I could leave a customer note to management. I had tried this a few years agowith HD and was stone walled. (your call is important to us - please go away)

Now, as I said, I shop elsewhere when ever possible.

Bob

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#16

The flip side of the story...

Dave Morris

>While I HATE going to our Home Depot (it's a "little" version of the box store's chain-- at least, that's the excuse I get when I ask for any one of many normally available items, and they don't have room to carry *those*. That is, after a LONG search for any employee who can answer why I can't locate said item.), their influence is huge.

We've had in our town for decades that one guy you could always go to for answers at our local Mom and Pop hardware store. Practical experience, lots of knowledge in many fields, and a no-BS opinion of what the various pros and cons were of all the tools and widgets you could ever need in any situation... the guy is a gold mine, and his store's biggest asset. He and some other old timers are losing their jobs because the new "corporate" bosses (they have three, count 'em, THREE stores!) have deemed it more cost effective to hire young kids who will work for a pittance. These new kids will have none of his knowledge or ability to actually help their customers. It makes me very sad to see the heads of retail outlets seem to have forgotten that sometimes, a certain type of employee is the very reason their customers choose to shop in their stores, and the extra cost of such an employee is more than offset by increased (and continued) sales. While small stores can't hope to compete with the big box chains in price, I'm more than willing to support such local stores by paying a couple extra bucks, and having someone there who can answer my questions is the reason why. Sadly, most consumers do not seem to share this opinion.

Home Depot not only drives prices down, it's presence is also forcing many stores to shortcut customer service as well in order to compete.

Dave--- who once had a small tool store owner actually pull a part off a display tool so I could finish a project (because that replacement part would have to be ordered and would take at least a week to arrive), and never forgot that favor in a time of need. Try finding THAT kind of service at a box store...

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#17

A Study in Contrast

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Firstly I'll observe that locally the problem spoken of in that article seems to apply to any of the big box stores here. It's amazing that when you are offered help it's when you don't need it. But then when you are hopelessly searching for something you can't find assistance to save your life. And yes...I know about the "panic buttons". But there is something emasculating about pressing the button and satnding there looking like a dope hoping to be rescued....especially when help never arrives!

In contrast there is our local True Value Hardware store. First, let me make it perfectly clear....I love and support mom and pop hardware stores. But there is occassionally an annoying dichotomy that exists there. At the mom and pop they hire guys that are often retired. These guys live to offer help. How could that possibly be a bad thing? It's not, unless I am there for the "thrill of the hunt". Sometimes I actually enjoy hunting for things in hardware stores. But at our True Value I often find myself with "shadows" asking me "can I help you find something"? As soon as I shoo away one old guy I'll turn the corner and another one will pounce.

It's those times when I don't really know what I want that the old guys can be a bit annoying. Do you ever go to the hardware store with a problem that you solve by hunting and finding parts to create a solution? I love to do that! The old guys take all the fun out of that. ;-)

Seriously though, I'll take a mom and pop hardware places...annoyingly helpful old guys and all, over the big boxes any day.

Tommy

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#18

The Scary Thing is this Goes on Everywhere

Robert Hutchins

>Hospitals are notorious for it. Most surgeries are done on an outpatient basis despite total anesthesia requirements. Because government and insurance payment schedules compensate cardiology claims at a higher rate, cardiology departments get preference for all resources - frequently at the expense of other treatment modalities. If you require a cardiology hospitalist, expect him to have the latest and best equipment (and to be somewhat arrogant, IME); whereas if you require a pulmonary hospitalist, expect him to be overworked, and given far fewer resources even though he is usually a better diagnostician and treats patients with equally or more dire prognoses who are frequently in worse physical condition. And the difference in their pay approaches 2:1.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#19

Re: A Study in Contrast

Ernie Miller

>My local real old one is 2 blocks away they know me pretty well and leave me alone If I need somthing and cannot find it I will ask but with rows and drawers of old hardware and stuff from as far back as the 20's I spend alot of time just looking at what they have. I found a drawer full of push drill bits at 5� ea a month or so ago and bought all 86 of them the old fluted type only one old man even knew what they were. said he didn't even remember selling any in the last ten years or so. Lots of treasure in them drawers just gotta look for it.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#20

WATCHIT, TOMMY!

Robert Hutchins

>Or we 'old guys' will start watching you all the time - and sending reports to those who need to know how your are spending your time. We'll even have you put in the database.

Never 'diss' us old guys. Age and deviousness will defeat youth and idealism every time!

heh heh heh

BobH

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#21

Re: hmmmm........28% ?

Ernie Miller

>Wait a minute! I can't even afford to watch the fight on TV! I just have basic cable not the suped up one with the sports channels. At least books and movies are still free at the Library.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#22

Correcting Myself

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>My faux pas! Truth be told that yes there are some retired fellows working there but there are also some guys younger than me working there too. And I'm just old enough to be too lazy to differentiate them so I call the young guys "old guys" too!! ;-)

Tommy

Old enough to remember trick or treat without a parental escort, $.25 gas and pet rocks. :-)

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#23

Re: Correcting Myself

Ernie Miller

>bottel rocket fights, streaking, and dime bags.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#24

Re: A Study in Contrast

Ted Wong

>The old timers at my local store know by now to leave me alone when I come in (usually at least once a day). But I know what you mean about the annoyance factor.

Even more annoying to me is when my students go out to get supplies for their projects and they come back with all manner of useless stuff and bad advice that the "wise" old help at the store has given them. But I'm with you for the most part, I'll take the local Ace store over a trip to HD any day.

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers? *LINK*

#25

Re: Is Home Depot shafting shoppers?

Ted Wong

>I posted on this topic a couple of weeks ago. That article pretty much summed up my most recent experience at the HD. Must of trashed at least 30 minutes getting absolutly nothing from the help or the store.