Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - Digital Camera Question

Posts

OT - Digital Camera Question

#1

OT - Digital Camera Question

Howard In Toronto

>Hi all -

How big of an enlargement would you go if you shot some good photos using a digital camera on 4.1 mega-pixel setting?

The camera in question is a Kodak-brand digital camera.

It's got a fairly good (integral) lens on it - reasonable sharpness and contrast - but it sure ain't one of my late-70's Nikon lenses or my 1950's Zeiss lenses....

Any advice you can offer would be appreciated.

Thank you.

Howard

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#2

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

ScottS

>As with many questions, the answer is "it depends".

You could blow it up to 20'x30' and it'll look great... as long as you're standing at least a quarter-mile away when viewing. At more normal viewing distances, you could probably go to 8x10 or maybe 11x14. If you need a larger print, you could use something like Genuine Fractals to resample the image at a higher resolution. It won't be as good as the "real thing", but I've seen some very nice results... especially if the image is viewed at arms length.

The easiest way to answer your question is to make a couple of prints at various sizes and see how they look. You'll spend a few extra bucks the first time around, but from then on you should know what your camera, and preferences, will tolerate.

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#3

What he said

Tony - Memphis

>I have a Canon S300 that is only 2 Mp I think. I have made 8x10's that look great to me. I also have a nice Nikon with 6 and have had the same result. And that's just off of my Hp inkjet.

Tony

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#4

Scott - thank you - that was the type.....

Howard In Toronto

>..... of info I was after.

But, I was hoping to go 16x20.

Looks like I'll have to try one to see how well it'll work.

Howard

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#5

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

john lucas

>Howard As the others have said it depends on a lot on what your used to seeing. We've made 8x10's at work from 2 meg cameras and it didn't look bad. Kind of like grainy 4x5 prints shot on 800 speed film. At arms length not very good but sitting on a desk or on the wall not bad. I think if it's done by a good printer a 16x20 won't be bad. It won't be great either.

I'm used to making 16x20's from 4x5 transparencies and I haven't seen anything digital that matches that. I'm building a special bracket today that will hold 3 Nikon D200's. we are going to use them to shoot group photos where we need an enlargment. We'll use the photoshop merge function to combine the 3 images. Hopefully that will be the equivalent of 27 to 30 megs and make a pretty nice 4x6foot print. We have to do those for the various team photos and we have used 120 and 4x5 film in the past.

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#6

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Howard,

16x20 might be pushing your luck a bit with a 4MP camera. Then again it never hurts to try. To go that large, you will have to resample your image to roughly 100 ppi (pixels per inch) assuming a 2000 x 2000 ppi original image. That 100 ppi puts you at about newspaper quality. Normal printing is done around 300-360 ppi (depending on the native resolution of the printer). But as others have said, viewing distance (up close and personal or from the next room), the type of paper (matte or glossy), the type of printing (inkjet vs other), the brand of printer (Epson vs HP for example), and the image software being used, all play a role.

Or you can set your resolution to something like 200 ppi and upsample (interpolate) to your final size. Both Genuine Fractals and Qimage are thought highly of for getting bigger pics using interpolation algorithms. There are also good freebie multi-step image resizers out there - if you have Photoshop.

Having said all this, I would try some matte paper (hides the loss in resolution better), adjust your resolution (using either method) and go for it. You should be able to get a reasonable 8x10 and luck might be with you for getting a larger one. I think Qimage (www.ddisoftware.com) has a free demo that might be useful. Below is one link (of many) that discusses resizing. Good luck.

Jim


Image Resizing

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#7

Re: Not all pixels are created...........

Jamie Donaldson

>.....equal when it comes to enlargements, and not all viewers are as critical as we photographers might be. I would probably say that an uncropped 8x10 would be the absolute max for that file size, and subject matter can also figure into this formula.

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#8

Re: Scott - thank you - that was the type.....

ScottS

>16x20 sounds pretty large for a 4MP digital camera.

You might look around and see if you can find info on how much resolution you need in the source image in order for a printed photo to look good. The number 150 dots-per-inch sticks in my memory, but that may or may not not mean anything. If it does, it would suggest that you'd need something like 2400x3000 pixels for a 16x20 print... though I don't think the rule is hard-and-fast by any means.

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#9

Ohhhh - Now I Get It

Howard In Toronto

>Nope, I wasn't gonna PRINT the photo - I was gonna bring it to a photo lab.

BTW - does THAT make a difference?

Thank you.

Howard

Re: OT - Digital Camera Question

#10

Re: The only real answer to that is....

Jamie Donaldson

>...yes and no!!