Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Yet another gimmick......

Posts

Yet another gimmick......

#1

Yet another gimmick......

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Yet another gimmick for woodworkers seeking instant gratification. I just received a Woodcraft flier touting the latest contraption for putting a razor edge on plane blades and chisels. For less than $120 (plus applicable tax and shipping) this thing relieves the user of any responsibility for knowing anything about how to use a stone or sandpaper to sharpen a tool. It seems to me that investing the time to acquire the skill to manually sharpen is more rewarding, less expensive , and probably faster in the long run than managing the storage, maintenance, setup, and use of a complicated jig, especially during a session of chopping a bunch of mortises or planing a table top.

Clint

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#2

Alan Young

Just wait till I get my sandpaper sharpener patent

Alan Young

>

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#3

Since You mention THAT . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>I look at these sanding belt "cleaning blocks ". For some reason ( #1 is the price ) I'm just not beliveing it. But do they work / worth the price ? I get my belts at HF 5 for $7.00 and consider them disposable. These blocks look to be the same price as, about, four belts. Opinions ?

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#4

JL

Re: "Snot blocks"...

JL

>I have a "snot block" that I use to clean off sanding disks and belts. It works quite well. I find that I can clean the disks off quite easily. Belts are more "problematic" in that you don't really have a table to press the block against, but it works for them as well. I can usually clean a disk or belt a lot faster than I can change them :).

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#5

Re: "Snot blocks"...

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>Yeah, I find those "snot blocks" pretty indespensible, actually.

They really do a great job of maximizing the life of sanding belts.

I run a 37" dual drum Performax, and you really can't run the tool without them. A box of belts for each grit is in the range of $100, so trust me, you definitely want those to last and not burn.

Then when they get so small that it's kind of a risk to clean the Performax without sanding my hand, I then throw them into my Festool Rotex box, and use them to clean those disks. Those disks aren't cheap, and by cleaning them, you definitely make them last longer.

There are certainly some gadgets and whirlygigs that are worthless, but not the 'snot blocks' (...I like that name. that's what I'll call them from now on....)

My 2 cents.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#6

Re: Yet another gimmick......

Lee Ohmart

>Instant gratification is the key phrase here. It seems that the pride with learning a skill has gone the way of so many other human values we were brought up with. On the other hand, how many of us who can sharpen without a jig operate a cell phone or computer game as well as a teenager?

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#7

Re: "Snot blocks"...

Neal in San Jose

>Yep, I use one frequently. I have a Delta 18/36 wide drum sander, and I use it when I notice any tendency for the sander to burn the stock, or if it sounds like it is beginning to labor. The "snot block" knocks off things like pitch and glue that I wouldn't have thought they would touch. It isn't a new piece of sand paper, but it's pretty close and if you use it before you "need" it, the paper will last several times as long. Just make sure the dust collector is ON when you use it, tho. You'll only do that once!!!

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#8

Yes! The Gum Blocks Work! They ARE Worth It!

Robert Hutchins

>

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#9

Re: Yet another gimmick......

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>But, can you chop a mortise with a cell phone?

Clint

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#10

Re: Yet another gimmick......

Lee Ohmart

>I have no idea as I refuse to purchase a cell phone. In my area of Maine, the service provided by these companies is terrible and we pay far more than the more populated areas south of us. Besides, I like my peace and quiet. This is something I notice that my friends who have cell phones no longer enjoy. Is it realy necessary to be available to everyone else in the world 24/7/365? I don't think so.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#11

I've heard old boot soles

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Tend to work pretty well too. Long as it's the yellow-ish kind of boot. I haven't tried it myself - I don't have an old pair of boots like that.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#12

I've wanted a new cell phone ...

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>So maybe I should give it a try. After the first wack it should break and reveal some nice plastic shards - maybe they could cut wood. But then I'd need the fancy jig to sharpen the shards.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#13

Re: Yet another gimmick......

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I think a lot of people are worried about failing - even on a first attempt. I remember I was afraid of sharpening when I got started. Now, I just started freehanding a microbevel with decent results. I have a Mark I jig, sandpaper on glass and a 2 sided waterstone. I've started using the jig less and less as I learned to just touch up a blade quick during use. With the fear of failure comes the need to buy foolproof tools and jigs. Once you get over the fear sharpening by hand gets pretty easy.

The biggest thing I found in sharpening is that a perfectly sharp edge is usually not necessary. Mortising will take a scary sharp edge off real fast, and then your down to mostly sharp. Also, chisels and plane blades don't have to be exactly 25 deg, 24, 26 1/2, they'll all cut pretty much the same. I think much of the literature about super sharp, perfectly flat and square edges scares people away - makes it sound like a mystical art. I sure thought it was at one time.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#14

Well Said, Stephen. I Agree.

Robert Hutchins

>

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#15

ROTFL . . . Why, what happens ? ? ?

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#16

AMEN ! ! !

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#17

Re: "Snot blocks"... *LINK*

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>I have one of those big crepe-rubber booggers screwed to the distaff end of my bench. It's relatively cheap and using it is a lot faster than changing pads, belts or even the paper on a hand-sanding block. These things really work.

regards

Angus Barclay


Lee Valley booger blocks

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#18

We Want Pics, Angus!

Robert Hutchins

>Show us how you attached it. Sounds a good deal better arrangement than my trying to hold sander in one hand - running - and booger block in the other.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#19

I've never bought a block as I usually

Don Henthorn

>have a worn out pair of crepe soled shoes that work just fine. I have even picked up a piece of truck tire off the highway at times and found many of those work well also. Of course, I'm cheap and poor.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#20

Re: We Want Pics, Angus! *LINK*

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Hello Robert,

I can't get to my shop for another couple of days to take pix but the link below may help explain it better than the one I provided previously.

The block I've got came from Lee Valley already attached to an orange plastic base that had two pre-drilled screw holes in it. In typical Lee Valley think-of-everything style, the holes were even countersunk just to make the installation a bit tidier.

Unfortunately though, it looks like Lee Valley doesn't sell this particular booger block any more.

regards

Angus Barclay


Lee Valles screw-mount booger block

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#21

Wonder What Kind of Adhesive

Robert Hutchins

>they used to get the booger to stay on the plastic? Wonder if I could find something that would glue one to a piece of plywood? Wouldn't want to put a nail or a screw through it as it is bound to ruin the sandpaper.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#22

They absolutely work!

Mike in Paradise

>I find them invaluable. If you get a dual drum sander gummed up and start replacing the velcro rolls just cause they gum up the $$$$$ add up fast.

When I was younger and not into woodworking a fellow I worked with that was a woodworker used to scrounge everyones old shoes that had that type sole to use to clean his belts.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#23

They absolutely work!

Mike in Paradise

>I find them invaluable. If you get a dual drum sander gummed up and start replacing the velcro rolls just cause they gum up the $$$$$ add up fast.

When I was younger and not into woodworking a fellow I worked with that was a woodworker used to scrounge everyones old shoes that had that type sole to use to clean his belts.

Re: Yet another gimmick......

#24

Opps that is what happens when you get

Mike in Paradise

>visitors in the middle of a post...Sorry about the double post...