Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Posts

14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#1

14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Charles Jackson III

>I am wondering could the 14'' Grizzly GO580 Bandsaw that I am going to get replace my cheap benchtop table saw? a bandsaw can crosscut, rip, cut curves, and resaw. Since I am mostly coverting to a hand tool shop I think a bandsaw will be useful, I am also going to add a miter saw for crosscutting and angle cuts.

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#2

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>While a band saw can do all the things you mentioned (cross cut, rip, etc), it leaves a fairly rough cut surface as compared to a table saw. It also does not do a good job of cutting perfectly straight lines or perfect angled cuts. If you are comfortable in over coming the rough surface finish and non-straight surfaces with your hand tools then go for it.

Lee

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#3

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Charles Jackson III

>Ok I can overcome that.

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#4

Find some of the articles by Michael Fortune

Craig Daymon

>Michael Fortune is one of the top woodworkers out there and he has written several articles in the past 2 years on getting the most from a 14" bandsaw. One was in Fine Woodworking and I think the other was in Popular Woodworking. He uses the bandsaw for the bulk of his cutting and I think the Fine Woodworking article details tuning up a 14" saw to get the most out of it. No blade drift, accurate cuts. Find his articles and I think you'll find your answers. The Fine Woodworking article might even be available from Taunton Press as a downloadable article by itself, though you'll probably get more for your money by ordering the back issue. Either that, or hit the local library to read their copies.

Sorry I don't remember the specific issues.

-Craig

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#5

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Jesse in New Mexico

>I find myself using the bandsaw more and more and the tablesaw less. I can get a good straight cut on my 14 inch delta. I cut 1/32 proud and then take one pass with the jointer to clean up, could certainly use a plane instead of a jointer.

Don't see how you could make grooves with the bandsaw though, and they are a lot of work with hand tools. Of course, a router can solve that.

And a bandsaw can't do kickback, but that's fine with me. ;^)

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#6

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Charles Jackson III

>I have a Hitachi Fixed Base Router that I can use for groves.

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#7

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Dale Warder

>Charles, I have done what you propose replacing the tablesaw with a bandsaw. The critical step you mention is changing to a hand tool shop. In this situation, most cuts will be shot with a plane so smoothness of cut is less important. Also, hand tool workers tend to develop joinery techniques different from power tool techniques. If you wish to become a hand tool shop, the neanderbuddy is a well recognized apprentice to handle the labor intensive cutting resawing etc.

Good luck!

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#8

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Charles Jackson III

>Ok thanks!

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#9

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Barry Irby

>I have both a TS and A bandsaw.

What the bandsaw won't do is any cut where the blade does not come all the way through the stock, like grooves and dados. If you work around that with a router and hand tools I think you would be OK. But where would I pile my stuff when I'm using the bandsaw and what would I use for an assembly table?

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

#10

Re: 14'' bandsaw vs benchtop table saw!

Charles Jackson III

>Ok, now will benchtop table saw rip hardwoods? or I would use the bandsaw for that? I might get a 6'' dado blade. to use in my table saw.