Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Posts

OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#1

OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Joe Pack

>My 20+ year old cast aluminum gas grill has given up the ghost, or at least I think it is time for a new one. The vast majority of gas grills are now stainless steel, but when I have looked at them casually over the past couple of years, I have noticed that more than a few that have been sitting outside on display have signs of corrosion, and even minor rust on the "stainless" steel. Is there a relatively easy way to tell "good" stainless from the bad stuff?

On the same vein, I saw one grill advertised as using 304 stainless instead of "inferior" grade. Is this a good thing? What type of stainless would they be comparing to?

Finally, the grill I am looking at is a Vermont Castings clearance model at HD...last year's price was $629. They have 2 left at $409. The stainless on this one is warranteed for 10 years compared to a typical 3 year warranty on most of the other brands/models.

Any input will be appreciated.

Joe

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#2

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Joe,

I am no expert, but I do work for the company that owns CharBroil Grills (70% of the gas grill market). The good mid-range grills now have a good deal of porcelin coated steel, especially the grates over the burners.

For the sake of my bonus check ;>)) Check out our grills in the same price range.

Feel free to email.

Mark


http://www.grilllovers.com/shopItemDetail.aspx?itemid=7791868

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#3

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Garrett in Victoria BC

>Hi Joe

Unless you really, really "need" one of the kitchen-size grills, consider a marine BBQ. In fact, you could buy 3 marine stainless steel BBQ's for the same price as the clearance item you have in mind. My roll-around BBQ is on its last legs, and when I finally trash it,this is its replacement. (I already have one on my boat.) West Marine has it on sale for about $150, and an adapter hose enables it to be used with a large tank. It coks well and evenly and uses very little gas.

"Convenient portable marine grill offers 13,000BTUs and 145sq.in. cooking space yet stows compactly with foldaway legs. Features a locking lid and grease tray. Constructed of corrosion resistant 304 stainless steel. Mounts and storage bag sold separately. Folded dimensions: 24"W x 12.5"H x 10.5"D.

* Form Factor: Rectangular

* Burners: Stainless steel

* Heat Output: 13,000BTU

* Cooking Area: 145sq.in.

* Case/Kettle Material: 22-gauge 304 stainless steel

* Fuel Options: Propane or onboard tank

* Temperature Controls: Variable gas regulator

* Overall Size: 24"W x 12.5"H x 10.5"D

* Convenience Features: Grease tray, folding legs for easy storage

* Mount: Pedestal mount (sold separately)

* Warranty: One Year"

Cheers, Garrett


img

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#4

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Scott Whiting - Glendale, AZ

>Mark and I will forever disagree on this :-) but being on my second Weber gas grill and having cooked on many others the Weber is the only one in the price range I would own.

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#5

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

John McGaw

>Last June's edition of Consumer Reports rated the Vermont Castings VM400XBP as a "best buy" and as the top-rated midsized gas grill in their review. The VM450SSP by the same company came in at fourth place and cost $230 more so mere name seems to have little to do with it. But looking more closely at the codes it appears that the latter model differs from the first by being "all or mostly stainless steel" and by having side burners. The actual performance ratings seem to be the same. Of course, this is a new year and the old model numbers may not be applicable.

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#6

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Dennis Yoder

>A magnet will stick to inferior stainless steel. The less the attraction the better the stainless.

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#7

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Grant Smith(remove 1 for email)

>Joe,

Look for these quality grill features:

Cast Brass burners benath the grates. Second best would probably be cast iron, followed by stamped stainless. Also look for a large diameter side burner casting. Like the grill burners, look for Cast Brass, cast iron, and stainless in that order. Also see if you can get replacement burners if you must buy a non cast brass burner. Check the store where it is sold and online.

Look for stainless, cast iron, or enameled grill assemblies. Same goes for warming racks. RUST will quickly eat uncoated steel in the firebox, especially if the grill is kept outdoors.

Look at how the heat is dissipated and held between the burners and the grates. I prefer lava rocks, though steel diffusers can be effective as long as replacements are available (they won't last long, in my experience)

Look for a good temperature guage, and thicker castings and sheet materials for overall build quality.

Are the parts bolted together, or are they just quickly assembled with clips and snap-locks?

All of the above is based on my experience and observations only... YMMV.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#8

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Bill Earl

>We have a 45,000 BTU Vermont Castings unit that is about 5 years old. It is made from a combination of stainless steel and porcelain coated steel. We use it quite a bit year-round. No problems. No complaints.

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#9

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Chicago Bob

>I believe that a couple of years ago, Consumer Reports list Vermont Castings as their "pick".

Additionally, if a magnet sticks to any brand - it's probably 400 series stainless which is not typically as corrosion resistant (and is cheaper) as the 300 series which will not "atrack" a magnet. 306 or 316 stainless is a much better choice to survive long term outdoors.

With that said, I don't remember what alloy the Vermont Castings uses, but I have also had my eye on the VC version at the Borg.

Chicago Bob

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#10

Apostate!!!

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>A Pox on you and your house!! ;>}}}

Weber is the king in Charcoal grilling.

Mark

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#11

combating corrosion........

SanMan

>......easy, go to Walmart and get a heavy duty fabric cover.

About 30 bucks and will cover 70% of the grill and limit exposure to the elements.

SM

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

#12

Re: OT-Stainless Steel Gas Grills

Ernie Miller

>What the heck can go wrong with a cast aluminum grill? the stand? I have a 25 yr old one that is permintaly mounted in the patio. natural gas 1on bottles 1 I have rebuilt it a couple times and it will need to be done again this year a couple bolts that hold it to the pedistal need replaced it will also get a new coat of high temp paint made for wood stoves. I bought new grills a couple weeks ago when West Lake had there bag sale. a new burner every 4-5 years and Bob's your uncle. Oh yes the do need ney rock every 3-4 years. I'm betting that I can rebuild my old one to look new for about $25 this year. But if you want a new one listen to the other guys. I would save the money for some other project on the patio.