I've started on a table. It's going to have cherry legs and cherry aprons. It'll have a walnut top (because I have a lot of left over walnut...).
The table will be (roughly) 36L X 23W - the size my MIL wants it to be.
The legs are going to be turned a Shaker style (at least I'm gonna try for that). They will be ~29" long. I milled up the leg stock today and they are 1-5/8" square.
The apron will be 3" wide.
Questions:
How long, wide, and thick would you make the tenon on the aprons?
Would you bother with a hunched tenon?
Where would you start the turning on the legs (the pommel?). 5" down from the top? Looks good on a test I did. That may be a tad long though.
>How long, wide, and thick would you make the tenon on the aprons?
First, Joe, I think you might want to consider a taller (wider) apron; 3" is pretty narrow. Most Shaker tables -- even the more delicate ones (ones with thinner legs, like yours (not your legs, your table's legs :-) -- had aprons in the 4 1/2" & up range. You can certainly take liberties with the style to suit your taste, but when a design harks after a well known style such as Shaker, your eye senses those liberties. If you haven't already, I'd draw your table to scale and see if it looks or compares to what you envision.
That little caveat aside, most Shaker tables had their aprons recessed slightly from the faces of the legs. The aprons were usually an inch or more thick. The tenons themselves were typically either 3/8" or 1/2" thick, with a 5/8" or 3/4" shoulder at the top (no haunch) and a smaller (say, 1/8") shoulder at the bottom, regardless of the apron height.
In a 1 5/8" leg, you will have to lay out the plan view carefully to be sure you don't end up with tenons that are too short. In other words, let's say you are using 7/8" material for the aprons with 3/8" thick tenons... If you space the aprons 1/8" in from the surface of the legs, that puts the tenon from 3/8" to 3/4" in from the face of the leg. If you miter the ends of the tenons, you'll end up with a length of just under 1 1/4", which should be fine for this project.
Now, the reality check: Because of material availability, you will probably want to make the aprons out of 3/4" thick stock, right? In this case I'd go for 5/16" thick tenons, centered on the rail, with the same kind of top and bottom shoulders I mentioned above.
Typically, the turning started somewhere south of the apron. I don't think there is a formula -- whatever works.
>I'd start your pommel aabout 1.5 inches below the apron. There are a few reasons. You want the full dimension of the leg for maintaining the strength of the mortise and secondly, any closer and the pommel starts competing aesthetically.