Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Laminating Press Idea Question

Posts

Laminating Press Idea Question

#1

Laminating Press Idea Question

Barry Irby

>I know some of you are into Vacuum Pressing laminates. My question is why couldn't you reverse the process and use air pressure instead? Seems to me you could have a bladder of some type that you could pressurize. You could put your materials to be pressed between the cauls and then inflate the bladder (old inner tube) and wait a while for the glue to set. You would need something to confine the bladder, but that could be a fifty five gallon drum or even a very strong bag.

My point is that most of have an air compressor. If your bladder held air, you could just inflate it and walk away. You would not need vacuum pressure switches that maintain a constant vacuum, etc. All this would add to a typical shop would be the bladder and some confinement system which would be pretty low tech. Vacuum presses generate up to "one atmosphere" of pressure, about fourteen psi. An air compressor could generate several times that. What do you think?

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#2

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

Carol from AZ

>Interesting question, Barry. I once developed a class on vacuum technology for woodworking. Everyone built their own system and generally the cost was less that $200 and that was for every bell and whistle we could dream up. Including pumps, bags, jigs, switches, fittings, bleeders, carts, wheels, etc. On some hard drive somewhere I have an Acad schematic that includes the vacuum pressure systems and the electrical system. In a box somewhere I have pictures of the myriads of things my students built.

The vacuum system has the advantage of exerting pressure inward on the project from every direction. Air pressure exerts its force in every direction, including unnecessary directions. Thus its enclosure is more problematic. Larger, more expensive, and the real kicker, where the h... do I store the thing when not needed! The vacuum bag simply rolls up. The platens are flat and fit in the lumber rack.

The enclosure is key for both systems. If they leak, the force needs to be replenished. So that's a push.

The issue of more pressure than 14 PSI is mute. I've seen jigs that were insufficiently built, implode under that pressure. An advantage of vacuum is that even air bubbles are dissipated. That's one of the reasons it works so well for veneers.

One fun project was making a leak-proof enclosure, mixing up epoxy with bubbles in it, placing that container into the enclosure, applying the vacuum and watch the air bubbles pop out of the mixture in seconds. Worked for paint, too! One person tried to use the paint can as the enclosure. It collapsed! The reason is that there was no opposing pressure on the opposite side of the paint can wall.

Vacuum technology is fun to think about and play with. Darn useful too.

So what precipitated this question? New project at hand? Or mind idling? (I do a lot of that!)

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#3

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

Earl Kelly

>Barry,

Using air pressure will work. The problem comes with trying to contain the pressure. At 90 psi and just a 10" x10" bag you'd have 9,000 lbs. of pressure. That's enough to lift a couple of cars or take the roof off a building. I've seen a laminating press made with a fire hose, cauls and clamps. I think they could only use around 20psi.

The drum idea would work because of the shape, but it might have to be sealed tight on the ends also. That would depend on your inflatable apparatus.

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#4

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

Barry Irby

>I'm just brain storming. I would like to do some laminating or veneering and I see the vacuum technology as fascinating. It just introduces a whole new set of variables. Filters, vacuum switches, hoses that might collapse, Vinyl bag vs. poly bag, sealing the bag, fittings for the bag, cauls, etc.

I am of the mind set that I would rather build it than buy it ready made, because I am a pack rat and cheap. And there would be a better innate understanding of what was going on land a sense of accomplishment.

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#5

14 psi x 144" in 1sq.ft. = 2016 psf

Keith Newton

>If you laid up a sheet of plywood, the frame would need to withstand 64512, and would be limited to flat work, and need to be as big as a SUV,

If you leave the form out of the bag, it only needs to be strong enough to hold the parts to the shape before the vacuum is drawn, after that, the pressure on the bag will hold it to the shape.

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#6

Re: 14 psi x 144" in 1sq.ft. = 2016 psf

Walnutty

>My .02 worth.....

I used air pressure to assist in clamping jigs I'd made (about 100 years ago now), one was for columns (1' X 4'), the other was a flat panel press. In each case I used bicycle inner-tubes, cut just past the stem and a fold seam at each cut. The eight sided cylinders after glue would get a tape band at each end, a helical tube wrap, and then a bump of air. The other was a large (and adjustable) box frame with an internal caul. I'd slip the veneer (on panel) into the contraption, adjust for width, and bump the fixed horizontal "snakes". Both worked for me very well, fit perfectly into both my "cheap and sleazy" and "crazy but it works" categories.

Since that time, they have been long retired in strong favor of vacuum

pressing for so many applications. The first time you watch the air evacuate out of the bag and the GLUE, you're gonna want to go have a cigarette. OK, maybe not, but you know what I'm talking about.

Walnutty-

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#7

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Barry, the barrel would not hold the amount of force normally used to laminate. If you have a 1 foot square flat laminate in a vacuum bag, you will exert about 2000 lb of clamping force on the entire surface. I feel quite sure if you had a large bag and put a steel oil drum in the bag it would crumple it like a smashed beer can with vacuum applied. A bladder in a 22" diameter barrel at low air pressure - say 15 psi - would put over 5,000 lb of pressure against the lid. Pretty certain it would launch through the shop ceiling. Might show up on radar. Not saying it can't be done, but the effort required to build something that would hold the equivalent pressure of a vacuum bag (14.4 lb / sq. in.) would require both more work and more expense than using a standard vacuum system - and be a whole lot safer.

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#8

I used the bicycle tube method to build

Don Henthorn

>laminated archery bows many years ago. Made male and female forms held together by 1" steel straps bolted to the forms. Put glue on the laminations and riser, stacked them into the bottom form with a sheet metal caul on top then put in the inner tube which was encased in a fire hose, bolted the forms together and inflated the tube to 60 lbs pressure. Worked like a charm

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#9

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

ben

>You can do it with pressure but as others have pointed out the size of the containment vessle will be substantial. My brother worked for a heat exchanger company and they pressure tested their work up to 1.5 times operating pressure to check for leaks. Most were hydro tested with water but some required an air pressure test. For the air testing they had a blast proof room and tied / chained the exchanger core down. most would leak fairly early on and stop the test. They had one that let go towards the end of the test and it rocketed across the room and through and concrete and steel reinforced cinder block wall.

There is a lot of energy stored in compressed air and can accidently be release with very damaging results.

some types of alloys are worked by hydro forming. Similar to what you are suguesting except they us water instead of air. Much safer, you only need to leak a tiny amount of water to remove the pressure.

Hope this helps

Ben

Re: Laminating Press Idea Question

#10

Doesn't everyone have one of these?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>;)

Happy Woodworking!


img