Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Time for a new ROS

Posts

Time for a new ROS

#1

A.J. Hamler

Time for a new ROS

A.J. Hamler

>I've used my old DeWalt 421 random orbit sander to death. Had it since the first year they came out. Trouble is that even though it worked fine until now, I dropped it last week and it hit the concrete just right on the edge of the pad, bending the pad's mounting post. It's no longer a ROS, now it's a RWS --- random wobble sander.

So, which 5", 8-hole sander to get? My first instinct is to just go out and get another 421 since it's served me well for years, but I thought I'd run past youse guys first and maybe consider a different one. Now, I'm well familiar with all the specs and all the performance ratings of every machine out there, so quality and reliability isn't an issue in my question here. What I want to know is which one you guys really *like* using. Which one is a pleasure to use? Which one would they have to pry from your cold, dead fingers?

TIA

A.J.

Re: Time for a new ROS

#2

Re: Time for a new ROS

JackLane

>AJ

Have you looked at Festool sanders? I just bought a RO 125 with the mid size vacuum for sanding face frames. My guys and I really like it. It's built like a tank and has the best RO action I've seen. It takes a little getting used to as it's a very aggressive sander. They're also a little pricey but come with a three year warranty. BTW, Klingspore is now selling paper for the Festool stuff. Good luck

Jack

Re: Time for a new ROS

#3

Go with BOSCH *LINK*

Doug

>I just went through the same thing, and ended up buying the BOSCH 1295DVSK. FWW also rated it a best value.. and it'son sale now at amazon. I got mine through the local Lowes for $69.00

Low vibration, easy to control, and fantastic finish on the wood.


Bosch on Amazon

Re: Time for a new ROS

#4

Alan Young

I disagree....

Alan Young

>I've seen this before. Let me tell you this is not original tool damage. There must be hundred's of woodworkers who drop their tools everyday. Claiming that you dropped it on the floor implies that you originated this form of tool abuse. Taking credit for other peoples previous fumble fingers is next to plagiarism. If you really want to justify a new sander purchase I suggest you create an original form of tool abuse such as "I clamped the sander in a vise so I could file the edges of the sandpaper and make sure it was real sharp, when I took it out of the vise I realized I had clamped it too tight and now it is deformed"

C'mon AJ get real.

Alan

Re: Time for a new ROS

#5

A.J. Hamler

Well, Mr. Smartypants

A.J. Hamler

>For your information, I have NEVER mounted my sander in the vise too tightly to do something so stupid and silly as to file the sandpaper edges to make it sharp. Do you think I'm an idiot?

I use band clamps to do that.

So there.

A.J.

Re: Time for a new ROS

#6

I'll agree there.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>A.J.

I finally broke down and bought the Festool 6" ROS. I've been skeptical of the value of Festools but I must admit this is a really great tool. I hope to get their 5" 125 sander soon.

If that's rich for your pocketbook perhaps consider Bosch.

Tom

Re: Time for a new ROS

#7

Alan Young

Bandclamps eh?....Why didn't you say so?

Alan Young

>See it's always better to get at the real reason. In that case I'd say look around before getting another 421. I too had reason to replace mine a couple of years ago. My tool's death was in the style of "Old Age" I have always admired that time of tool demise and was inspired to use that when deciding to get a new sander. I did just go out and get another 421 but I can say this-The newer version was not as robust in it's housing and feel. It has been OK but I'd look around a bit.

This opinion is my own- any resemblance to any previous opinion is pure co-incidence.

Alan

Re: Time for a new ROS

#8

I don't have to make up ROS stories....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>...the truth in my case will suffice. Just last week I was "muti-tasking" in the shop. I walked away from doing some sanding to do something else. Came back to do more sanding with my ROS. I had apparently been in the process of changing discs but didn't complete the process. I started sanding and went well beyond 30 seconds before I realized there was no disc! Trust me, velcro hooks alone do very little for surface preparation.

No real damage to the ROS. Just a little damage to the ego. ;-)

Tommy

Re: Time for a new ROS

#9

That's how I found out they make

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>replacement velcro disks.

Ray

Re: Time for a new ROS

#10

Ridgid

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning AJ,

I've never tried a Festool, and couldn't justify its cost anyway. I own a DeWalt 421, a P+C 330, and a 5" Ridgid. I bought the Ridgid because my Bosch 1295 died, and they wanted an arm and a leg to rebuild it. The Ridgid has the same hole pattern as the Bosch and the DeWalt, and I already had a couple hundred bucks worth of 8 hole discs. So after reading many reports I bought the Ridgid. It was a great decision. When one of my other ROS dies, I'll get a second Ridgid to replace it. I liked the DW 421 very much, and it was one of the best sanders I ever owned, save for the awful speed control malfunctions I experienced. I keep it for back-up now.

George

Re: Time for a new ROS

#11

I 2nd the Ridgid

Bri in Mtl

>I have the PC 333(?) and the Ridgid. The Ridgid is smoother, quieter, way better dust collection, cuts faster, stops faster, and has a 10 ft cord.

The PC does seem to work better upside down and on small surface areas though.

Re: Time for a new ROS

#12

Re: I 2nd the Ridgid

Stuart Hough

>I'll 3rd that!

Re: Time for a new ROS

#13

I 3rd the Rigid -Great ROS & 6" made by Metabo

Chicago Bob

>

Re: Time for a new ROS

#14

Bosch or Makita

HC Sakman

>

Re: Time for a new ROS

#15

Is Metabo in CHINA

john b SW Chicago burbs

>I own a Ridgid R2611 and it was made in China. This 6" sander is about 3 months old, it worked great until i hooked up a vacuum to it. I found a statement on the internet that the vacuum causes static and toasts the cicuit board. I cn't confirm this yet as i have not contacted Ridgid. Anyone heard of this. thanks john b.

Re: Time for a new ROS

#16

Re: Time for a new ROS

Geoff in Madison

>If your budget will allow, I would also agree that Festool is the way to go. I've got their 6" and detail sander. Both are magnificent. The Deltex (detail) sander is virtually as fast as my PC333.

I personally won't consider any power tool that doesn't have a well thought out integrated dust collection system--and in my opinion those little canisters or bags just don't cut it. I love being able to sand stuff and not spew dust everywhere.

Geoff

Re: Time for a new ROS

#17

Re: Time for a new ROS

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>AJ, I have the Dewalt 421, a Bosch 6 inch and the Festool 150/5 EQ. Hands down I use the Festool 95% of the time and it is most due to the extremely low vibration and great dust collection when hooked to the Festool shop vac. Fred

Re: Time for a new ROS

#18

Re: Time for a new ROS

DB

>Have you given any thought to just replaceing the bent mounting posts?

Re: Time for a new ROS

#19

Not that one...

Hoa Dinh

>The model discontinued last year, RO2610, is made by Metabo in Germany. In fact, the user's guide has a list of Metabo Service Centers.

The current model, RO2611, is Ridgid's own design, is made in China.

I can't say anything about the claim that "the vacuum causes static and toasts the cicuit board."

-- Hoa

Re: Time for a new ROS

#20

Not a fan of Ridgid 5"

Rich Glisson (Durham, NC)

>I have had DeWalt and P-C 5" sanders and got disgusted with both because of dust canisters falling off and pad brakes failing. Thought I would try the Ridgid and it also is flawed. They didn't spend the 5 cents it would have cost to have a backflow prevention flap at the dust canister inlet, so if the sander gets knocked over you get a blast of dust in your face the next time you fire it up. Also, the switch was designed by an absolute imbecile, as it protrudes so far that the sander will turn itself on if it falls over on its side. EXTREMELY irritating. Lastly, I am having the same pad brake failure issues as with the other makes. It requires disassembly and cleaning to make it work again. Maybe eventually I will bite the bullet and get a Festool.