Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Lacquer peeling off...

Posts

Lacquer peeling off...

#1

Dale Lenz

Lacquer peeling off...

Dale Lenz

>like dead skin after a good sunburn.

I was sanding a project made out of cherry w/400 grit sandpaper and had a slight bump on a corner-round surface, rub hard and notice quarter inch squares of something coming off. Rubbed with a green Scotch-Brite pad and I was pulling long skin like strips off, dunk a strip in lacquer thinner and it dissolved instantly, me think, its the lacquer, 4 coat worth, after sanding. I've done the same procedured before.

BLO, dried overnight.

Sealed with Seal-Coat, maybe passed it's shelf life, but dried good.

Sprayed lacquer, a few month old, have used prior w/o problems, sprayed lacquer had been drying for 3~4 hours, 70*, 25%RH.

I've never had this problem before. I sanded, and washed with lacquer thinner a test spot and resprayed 3 more coats of lacquer prior to coming in from the shop. Assuming this test area works, I'm thinking the shellac was old, as in bad. So based on that assumption, I will need to sand off lacquer and shellac, use fresh shellac, and spray more lacquer.

Any other ideas out there.

TIA,

Dale

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#2

No need to sand

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Use lacquer thinner to remove the lacquer and alcohol to remove the shellac. Start fresh.

Ray

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: Thanks, Ray...

Dale Lenz

>so you think it's the Seal-Coat, also?

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#4

Re: Thanks, Ray...

Kirk (KC) Constable

>Is overnight long enough for the BLO to dry?

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#5

Re: Thanks, Ray...

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Don't know but it sounds suspicious. I would go back to before the first film coat and redo from there.

Ray

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#6

Ellis Walentine

Oil not dry enough

Ellis Walentine

>As Kirk suggested, the linseed oil was probably not dry enough. Michael Dresdner always suggested a couple days drying time at a minimum before coating over with shellac or lacquer. I've known craftsmen who have waited a month to be on the safe side.

Ellis

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Maybe, so.....

Dale Lenz

>but I've been doing it for years. Maybe the signs are all wrong for me on this run. Thanks to all that has offered advise.

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: But, come to think of it....

Dale Lenz

>I might of forgot to add japan drier to the BLO, as I normally do, and I did notice some "oil blotches" on my finishing paper, the outline of my cases...My guess is to strip off/sand off the finish, and start over. I keep telling myself it could be worse, but I hate backing up. Kinda reminds me of getting a traffic ticket when I was young, : ' >.

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#9

Re: Oil not dry enough, agree, however

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I think I have read everything posted about finishing for quite a while now and everyone says let BLO dry longer. Here is the part I don't understand. I have never waited more than 24 hours, and sometimes less, overcoated with poly, shellac, and lacquer and have never had a problem. In one case I put on BLO in the morning and shellac in the afternoon without problems. Class project and severe time constraints. Have I just been lucky or have I discovered some deep secret? If I have I sure don't know what it is.

Ray

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#10

Ellis Walentine

My hunch, Ray,...

Ellis Walentine

>...is that shellac is impervious to oil and will dry if you float it on a puddle of wet oil. But it doesn't combine chemically with the oil; rather it relies on a mechanical bond, which it can only get when applied to a dry surface. Whatever you put over the shellac will adhere to the shellac without issue. The weak link in the chain is at the oil/shellac interface. The right kind of rubbing action will cause the finish to separate at that interface. Since the shellac and other films you've applied add more and more air/moisture protection, the oil will dry very slowly, if at all.

I've been warned about Japan drier as an accelerator, too, since there doesn't seem to be a good way to calculate its effect in terms of drying time and the integrity of the dried oil. That's why paint companies pay high-priced formulators to do the research and add just the right amounts of all the various ingredients that give the finish its characteristics. Boiled linseed oil already has driers in it and I would bet that every braned is slightly different.

This all comes back to the age-old discussion of home brews. Everyone swears up and down that their favorite mixture of this and that has always performed well, but I'm always skeptical of what is really going on, whether it can always be repeated, how sensitive the mixture is to concentrations of the ingredients, etc. Something as simple as thinning your lacquer with some other brand of thinner is often a prescription for failure. I'm not saying don't get into alchemy; I'm just saying to finish firewood first.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#11

Dale Lenz

Re: Very well put, Ellis...

Dale Lenz

>I could not sleep well last night, keep on thinking of how to fix my mess and what I did differently. I did try wiping the lacquer off with thinner last night, end up smearing the stuff. I think it will take a lot rags and thinner to get it off. I think I going to resand, wiping with lacquer thinner to get some/most of the lacquer out of the pours, and sand some more. At the end, wipe off with mineral spirits, LET DRY. Use new shellac, and try cautious again. I really do appreciate every-one's help. I hate problems, just as must as the next person, so frustrating. Dale

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#12

Thanks Ellis, I keep trying to wrap my

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>hands around this oil thing and every time I think I have it something happens to cloud my confidence. Sure miss the Thursday nights with Sam, can't tell you how much I learned from him.

Ray

Re: Lacquer peeling off...

#13

a basic primer on BLO

Michael Dresdner

>There seems to be some confusion about drying oils, how fast they cure, what affects the cure, and how added driers work, so here is a basic primer.

Driers or dryers (both spellings are common):

BLO is linseed oil, a natural drying oil, to which has been added heavy metal salt driers in order to speed the drying process. Different companies use different combinations of driers (there are over a dozen) and different amounts. Drying speed will be affected by the mix, type, and amount of driers added. Since you don't know that information, err on the side of safety, or experiment with the brand.

How driers work, and why they fail:

Some driers are called through driers, and help shuttle oxygen deep into the film. Others, and these are far more common, are top driers, and will cause a top film to form. On a thick application, top driers can create a thin film that further prevents oxygen from entering the oil, hence extending cure time.

Adding your own driers:

There is a problem here. If you add too much drier, it has the reverse effect -- in other words, it prevents drying instead of accelerating it. Since you don't know how much is in there to start, or what kind of driers are in the mix, this is risky business. Some dryer combinations have a synergistic affect on one another as well. If you must add driers, do so sparingly and use a through drier, such as cobalt, rather than cheaper top driers which are sometimes used in non-specific 'Japan Driers.' You can find cobalt driers at an art supply store.

Drying time:

Both temperature and humidity vastly affect drying time, as does thickness of application. Because oils dry by taking in oxygen, thicker applications can form a top skin which prevents oxygen from easily getting to layers below. In such a case, dry time is extended not arithmetically, but exponentially. Low temperatures slow cure time. High humidity can VASTLY affect cure time. In fact, high humidity can disable the driers completely. That means you are now essentially working with raw linseed oil, a very thin coat of which takes over a week to dry. In cold weather, it is not unusual for the shop to be at the dew point. Hence, even though it does not feel muggy as it does in the summer, you will be well over the 85% relative humidity mark that can disable the driers in the mix. All these issues affect drying enough to render bumper sticker rules, such as "oil dries in 24 hours," both useless and inaccurate.

Topcoating oils:

First, make sure you wipe off all the oil you can, leaving only what the wood absorbs. A solid film of oil is soft enough that you can get peeling or chipping even if it is dry before topcoating. Second, make sure the oil is dry before topcoating. Ellis explained this very well.

A final note about SealCoat:

Unless it was improperly stored, none of the SealCoat on the market is out of date yet. This is not true of regular Zinsser liquid shellac, of course, but it is, at least for the present, true of SealCoat.