Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Computer geeks - Motherboards

Posts

Computer geeks - Motherboards

#1

Computer geeks - Motherboards

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Thinking of putting together a 'puter while I can still get XP. I think I will do a dual boot with Linux so I can start migrating completely away from BG. Any good suggestions for motherboard and processor combos that work well for you. Kinda medium high, I want to make sure Linux drivers are available for everything. I haven't kept up since retirement, decided I didn't want to build any more, guess I'll eat those words. I'm going generic and open source as much as possible.

Ray

BTW - I don't think much of SJ's proprietary stuff either.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#2

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

Chuck W

>How much do you want to spend? Do you want to do a high end build with top of the line Core 2 duo?

I like intel processors,Asus motherboards, Seagate harddrives, Corsair memory(RAM), ATI videocards and Antec enclosures. Also make sure to buy a quality power supply to run it all.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#3

Gives me a start.

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I used to like Asus but haven't read or heard anything for some time. I don't need a high end system, slow dial up - no large downloads, no grandkids - no video, minor photo editing and my old design software, which will never be upgraded, part of the reason for keeping XP running. Don't know the differences between processors either, duo core vs.? I can make a guess at what they are but don't know for sure.

Ray

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#4

Re: Gives me a start.

Bill Howatt

>I agree with Chuck W's hardware recommendation although I have had good luck with AMD processors, Crucial memory, generic memory, and various HDs as well. I do buy only Asus motherboards, favor ATI graphics card, Antec cases.

The Intel Core 2 Duo is a dual-processor core chip for better performance and is the latest Intel offering. This seems to be the way processors are going and a quad will be coming out next. Apparently there is a big bang for the buck for the duo, a bit more for a quad and then it kind of fizzles out. Also, best performance is achieved when everything is written with multiple processors in mind.

Doesn't sound like your requirements require a top end machine.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#5

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

wilbur

>A lot depends on your budget. Components are pretty much commodity items these days, with the only new thing is that since the Intel Core 2 processor release, Intel is currently giving you the biggest bang for your buck, instead of AMD.

I would splurge on memory. These days, I think that adding more RAM gives you a bigger performance hit than upgrades to processor speed.

And even though you said that you don't care for SJ's proprietary software, if your budget is anywhere near $1200, I'd seriously consider the 17" iMac. (Not the $1000 version -- not enough RAM.) You can dual boot Windows XP, and you can even set up a triple boot OSX/WinXP/Linux system. A lot of popular open source software runs on OSX (I have the Gimp and X11 running). If you're bound and determined never to run proprietary software ever again, that's one thing. But for your stated purposes (minor photo editing), iPhoto is a great little program.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#6

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Ray, my son Brad and I both just finished building systems about a month or two ago. We used the same components. He worked a couple years as a �puter tech and has stayed more abreast of the current offerings than I, so I let him do the research. He said he had found certain Intel "dual core" processors were not nearly as fast as the E6300 core 2 duo. We used that processor - but the slowest version of it due to cost. The parts we used were the ASUS motherboard P5PE-VM, 1 gig of memory, Intel Core 2 duo E6300 1.86GHz 2MB 1066Mhz Skt LGA775 Processor and approved cooling fan. I bought these as a package from PartsPC.com - total was around $363

Remainder of items I purchased ( used my old monitor)

Samsung DVDRW drives (2 drives) total with cables $85

Mid Case (Aluminum Intel approved cooling) with 500 Watt power supply

& Mitsumi FD Total $47

Seagate 200 Gig SATA hard drive $77

New Wireless Logitech Keyboard & optical mouse & Logitech speaker set - $38

(Didn�t like the mouse �seemed to have some �delay� so used my old wired optical Logitech.)

My eldest son is the IT supervisor for the County, he purchased and gave me (as a gift) the XP-PRO operating system. I haven�t had any problems with the system at all since I powered it up (other than not liking the mouse). The motherboard comes with built in Audio, Video & LAN. All work very well IMHO. If I can assist you in any way, just Email me.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#7

Thanks for the detail Larry,

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>I used to build all the computers back in the day but it seems like a million years ago now. Being the only support person for a 24/7 operation for a couple of years kind of burnt me out on the subject.

Ray

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#8

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

Tom

>Core 2 Duo is the way to go, if you need fast. If not, and it sounds like you don't, I'd stick with an AMD Athlon 64, X2 or an Intel Celeron D for cheap. Don't laugh at the Celeron, they are just fine for what 95% of people use a pc for. Pentium D (dual cores, but not Core 2 Duo) are also relatively cheap now. Whatever you decide on, check the Newegg combo deals. You can get a motherboard/cpu combo for as low as $80 (for a Sempron or Celeron D, which would still be fine for running linux), or around $150 for an XP64 or X2 (maybe a little more on that one). Look for the combo deals that have a 'retail' cpu, or you will spend another $20 or so for a hsf. If you're not paying MS $100 for an OS, you should easily be able to build a serviceable machine for $400 or less.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#9

XP will be around for a while.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...Thinking of putting together a 'puter while I can still get XP..."

XP will be around for a while. Microsoft has "forced" retailers to stock Vista powered PCs since the beginning of the year. So any computer you buy at BestBuy or Circuit City will have Vista on it. And any consumer grade Dell or HPs will also have Vista (only).

But they can't force an immature OS like Vista on businesses. Most business won't use Vista for general use for another year or until the first SP is ready and all the bugs are ironed out. For home use, it's not an issue, for business it's critical.

So WindowsXP may not be an option on any consumer grade machines, but it will be available on business grade machines for at least another year.

A Dell Optiplex (std 3yr warranty) is about the same price as a lesser Dimension (std 1yr warranty) once you extend the warranty to 3 years.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#10

Re: XP will be around for a while.....

Tony - Memphis

>That's certainly the case where I work. "They" have sent our several emails stating that Vista is not approved. And to carry that further, those of us who have network access from home cannot upgrade our home pc's either. Which is fine with me.

Tony

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#11

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

Ray, SW Ohio

>My 2�, go with an intel board and processor, they work great together.

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

#12

Re: Computer geeks - Motherboards

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi Ray, how you been?

About a year ago, I had to build a new system from scratch. In the past I have used motherboards from Super Micro, and Asus. Both gave me excellent service. The Super Micro is still running a Pentium Pro. Now how long ago was that?

This last time I settled on the Intel 925 motherboard with a 3.2 GHz processor. The 925 chip set was new at that time, and Intel was the only one that had it to market at that point in time. It has all the standard bells and whistles, SATA disk for the people who don't understand SCSI, lots of USB plugs, built in audio, etc.

Time flies like an arrow, (but fruit flies like a banana.) And the 925 board is 'old hat'. But I expect to have it for a long time. You can down load various tuning tools, and microcode updates from Intel at no cost.

I have had no problems with either Super Micro or Asus, but I thought it was time to go with Intel, or wait until other board companies had the newer chip set on the street. Besides, remember the old saying, dance with the one that brought you. I hadn't had an Intel board before and I am glad I bought it.

Just my ramblings from someone that at one time had Linux, FreeBSD, OpenBSD, and Windows spinning.

Saw dust is more fun than pushing electrons around,

Ken