Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Posts

OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#1

OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Seriously. I can remember when I was young a banker told me that there was a legal limit in the state of TN on the amount of interest that a lender could charge. It was called a usury law. One of the definitions of "usury" is "An exorbitant rate or amount of interest." I know all that has changed, but I don't know when or how the change took place. I just wondered if anyone on the board has any knowledge as to how the borrower in this country lost legal protection from the lender.

What prompts this question is that I looked closely at the Sears bill today for the first time in awhile. They have the nerve to charge an APR of 30.4%! That's correct: Thirty-point-four! Thirty percent wasn't sufficient. They had to add on the extra point-four to finance the company jet, I guess.

Anyway, it's not been that many years ago when that rate of interest would be considered criminal. I remember a year or so ago when we opened the account to buy some tires. I almost nixed the deal because the account carried too high a rate. I don't remember exactly what it was, but it wasn't any 30%! Needless to say, that account got paid off today and there won't be any other purchases from Sears. No wonder people today are flocking to not shop there.

Gary

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#2

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Ted Wong

>Store cards are notorious for high rates. It surprises me anyone still has one. Unless you have been late or missed payments you have a lot of leverage in getting your rate down. A couple of months ago I callled my Visa card and told them I wanted a lower rate w/ no annual fee or I'd be shopping around for another card soon. I got my rate down from 18% something down to 12% and the annual fee waived for a year. I know it still isn't that great but the reason I keep the card in the first place is the frquent flyer miles.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#3

Holy Smokes.....

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>....Id be shredding that card and sending it back to them Gary!!!

Thats what they used to call.....highway robbery....aint it?

Scott

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#4

Deadbeats *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>Did you know that credit card companies call people who pay their cc bills in full and on time "Deadbeats"


Credit cards

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#5

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Geoff in Madison

>It used to be Federal law that states set their own maximum interest rates and companies couldn't could 'export' those rates to other states (i.e. to cardholders in other states). About 15-20 years ago (I think), the companies got that law changed and many of them set up their credit card divisions in states that allowed high maximum interest rates---ever wondered why Citibank cards originate in South Dakota (or used to)?

There is an interesting book titled 'The Two Income Trap' that goes into this.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#6

The Strict Definition of the Term

Robert Hutchins

>"usury" used to be charging interest on interest. In other words, adding the unpaid interest into the balance before calculating the next period's interest.

Until the last decade or maybe two, lenders were regulated very closely by the states. The lenders formed lobbying groups and hired lawyers - particularly the credit card lenders - and had laws modified in a few states giving them virtual carte blanche (no pun intended, Colonel). Then, they got the feds - can't remember if it was court decision or Congress - to allow what is called 'exportation of usury' to those states whose favors they had bought. Delaware and South Dakota were the primary states but others may have followed their lead in favoring lenders over borrowers. Remember when Citibank moved its credit card operations to Sioux Falls? It was the favorable laws and their ability to operate nationally under those laws that caused the move. So, nowadays you have a few folks - the legislators in those states - controlled by highly focused lobbying efforts, effectively selling the consumer down the river. And only the voters in those relatively small (population-wise) states can remove the politicians who did this from office. Citizens in other states have been, effectively, removed from the equation - their rights emasculated. Frontline (PBS) did a very good expose on this that aired some time ago and has repeated several times. Watch it if you get a chance.

About 35-40 years ago, William Proxmire, US Senator from Wisconsin, succeeded in pushing legislation through Congress that provided many protections for borrowers. Those have been repealed, watered down or are openly ignored - based on administrative rulings - by the lenders. Since then, the industry has successfully amalgamated resulting in approximately a tenth the number of institutions. All of this with the blessings of lawmakers. It is, IMO, one of the most remarkable - and most dangerous - things I've witnessed in 6 and half decades. The names McColl and Crutchfield figured prominently. NCNB - now BankAmerica - and First Union - now Wachovia are the institutions they headed.

Where are the legal checks and balances that the public can invoke to protect themselves from corporations? Bought and paid for by those corporations with monies they gathered from your patronage.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#7

Re: The Strict Definition of the Term *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>"There are no legal limits on the amount of interest and fees that banks can charge for a credit card because two U.S. Supreme Court decisions permit banks to charge what the market will bear."


How it started

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#8

Spot On , Ron ! Didn't Think to Google for It

Robert Hutchins

>

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#9

That's me!

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>I consider it a compliment, at least when it's coming from the cc companies. :)

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#10

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Years back while we stiill had a Sears cerdit card I realized their APR was over 20%. Never having a balance above a few hundred dollars it was easy to pay it in full, cut up the charge card, cancel the account and never purchase another item from Sears. The interest rate was not the only reason for taking that action but it was the straw that broke the camels back. Home Depot is getting very close to the Hit List for almost identical reasons that I boycott Sears.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#11

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Charles Self

>You should live in Virginia. There is a Payday Lenders' law that allows small loans, against checks, to be made at what is an effective annual interest rate of 356%, IIRC. These people, and their supporters, claim they are providing a service for people who need emergency loans and can't get them elsewhere.

They also usually can't pay them back and roll them over at ever higher payments until...bingo! Bankruptcy, after being hounded half to death.

Yeah, the people should have better sense.

But so should people who pay 20-30% interest on consumer goods loans.

The banks are gorging on our money, as always. Incidentally, if memory serves, Sears sold their credit card business to someone else in one of the fitful management "improvements" it has made over the past decade.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#12

I was going to bring that up.

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>The Pay Day lender operations are IMHO nothing other than criminal. Each political party tries to convince us that the other is evil, but if anything proves that they are all a bunch of crooks it is the way they allow the Haves to shaft the Have Nots. Granted, there seem to be a handful in Congress who have tried to put a check on this kind of thing but they are very much in the minority.

Pay day lenders target as victims (I refuse to say customers)those who can least afford them. I really don't know how the people who work there can sleep at night.

As far as Sears is concerned, when they sent the letter several months ago saying the rate was going over 30% - and I think it might have even had a chance to go to 35% if you missed or were late with a payment - I cut my card in half and sent it back to them. Along with the card was a letter telling them that I would no longer be a Sears OR Kmart customer. Needless to say I never heard back from them. There are too many other sheep in the flock to fleece.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#13

Re: Deadbeats

jared

>Thats me too. I use credit cards all of the time, mostly for internet purchases as there is no other good way to do it. I have always paid my bills in full every month. I have never paid an interest charge. They are a valuable tool for me but trouble for the people who dont seem to get the whole interest thing. IT is just like an interest free loan to me, rather than me paying someone the 30 percent interest. The amazing thing is that companies keep sending me offers of more cards all of the time, probably average at least one or two a week. Jared

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#14

I've had my trouble with Sears credit cards

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I opened up one their Sears Citibank cards when I bought a new dishwasher several years ago. Hey, I got another 10% off of a costly purchase. A few months later they activated automatic credit monitoring at $20/month, without asking me. A while after that, I cancelled the card. Then another month later got a note saying I still owed them for the credit monitoring, which was charged to the card, but a separate service. I called the monitoring service (which is still Citibank) and cancelled the service and asked how I should pay for the outstanding month. They said I should take it up with the credit card company (which was them!!!). So I called that office, and they informed me that I had no outstanding payments. Since I can't get any more information I hope I don't owe somebody $20 somewhere and have that start hitting my credit rating - which these days seems to be the only measure of a person's worth.

I now keep one credit card only, from my bank and I never get store cards.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#15

Re: The Strict Definition of the Term

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thank you, Ron, and everone else.

That is exactly the info I was looking for. I thought the last bit was most telling about the attitude toward the customer in corporate America. To paraphrase Mr. Kahr, "fairness is not profitable."

Well, Mr. Kahr can kiss my a**. We haven't been active credit card users for a number of years, and if I can help it, we'll never go back. The only two credit accounts I still have are Home Depot and Lowe's. From now on, those will be paid in full monthly, if they are used at all.

Gary

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#16

I heard that lotteries are taxes on people who ...

Ron in College Station, TX

>I heard that lotteries are taxes on people who are bad at math.

I suppose there is some similar statement that applies to people who can't adjust their consumption down to the level of their income. I have a daughter (27) who is one of the latter, but I can't bring myself to feel very sorry for her. It's part of a series of life lessons, and she'll have to attend all of those classes herself. Although there are certainly exceptions, as there always are, the highly indebted have had a very strong role in their plight. They've heard the advice and chose to ignore it.

I too am shocked that there are anything near 30% rates out there. And I'd feel abused if some dept store snuck up on me with such a thing. But all market interest rates have 3 components: the price of using someone else's money (true interest), expected inflation (because repayment is with future devalued $), and a risk premium. Some people are much riskier borrowers than others, so having a wide range of credit card rates is quite believable. Perhaps we do really need effective usury laws to prevent the stupid from selfabuse, but let's not simultaneously expect everyone to have a guarenteed right to borrow. The very risky should pay their own way or stay home.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#17

Re: Thanks Gary Evans - you have

Carol from AZ

>just demonstrated the power of the Internet - and the very reason the government is looking for every way they can to control this medium, or at the very least, make money off of it.

If we use it to make people aware of things they perhaps have not thought all the way out, things will change. I, too, do everything I can to keep my credit cards (2 non-store) paid off every month.

Let's start a Credit Card Deadbeats Club. I'll join up.

Someone once said, "power to the people." Maybe its time to say it again.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#18

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Robert Henderson

>I periodically cancel my high intrest cards.

Immediately after that I start receiving 0% introductory offers.

I rarely have to pay any finance chatges.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#19

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>I got the notice of the big rate increase on my Sears card several months ago. I immediately took the card which I have had for over 36 years and shredded it. I did not inform them of this decision since I want them to keep me on the books and continue to cost themselves money by sending me junk mail which I toss out unopened and using that miniscule amount of computer storage space. I realize it's not costing them much, but it at least makes me feel better.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#20

Not always a good idea

Ron in Drums PA

>That credit card will still show up if a credit check is done. Even with a zero balance an open CC account is considered a debt.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#21

Re: Not always a good idea

David Hay @ Denver

>Plus, it becomes a credit card someone could potentially use for identity theft...and since you never use it or look at it, would go undetected for a longer period of time.

David

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#22

increase in rate

Allen Bryant - Bumpass, VA

>I had a credit card that I got way back right after I graduated from high school. I mainly used it to finance my way through college for things that student loans typically did not cover and no I did not put any partying supplies on it, just books, gas, meals when I had to eat out and the occasional bill or two when I was short during the month. Unfortunately I was only able to make the minimum payments in college and by the time I had graduated the balance was just under $10k. After college I was being really diligent about paying it off making 5 and 6 times the minimum payment or more each month. The interest rate stayed pretty even the whole time until I started paying it off. I noticed that every 6 to 8 months or so I would get a notice stating a change in interest rate usually .5 to 1 percent. The card has been paid of for several years and if I use it, I pay it off every month and still the interest rate climbs. It started out at 9.9 and is currently sitting at 19.9% when I called and complained and canceled the card. I've never missed a payment and I know my credit score is almost 800, so I'm not even close to default risk. I'm guessing that they are hoping that I won't pay it off one month just to make some more money. I did a little shopping and was able to get a better card from a different bank and will stick with them unless they do the same thing.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#23

There is Nothing Colder Than A Banker's Heart

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#24

I keep one credit card which I use to buy

Don Henthorn

>on the internet. I pay the bill monthly. I have paid no credit card interest for thirty years.

Re: OT---Whatever happened to usury laws? RANT

#25

Re: Thanks Gary Evans - you have

Sonny Asburry

>One way that I have found to beat them at their own game is this:

I obtained a GM credit card which I get 5% off on a new GM car if i purchase one. When I got it, it was interest free for 12 months. I used it for 11 months, obtained another one from a different bank with no transfer fee, and interest free for 12 months. I transferred the balance, and now use the GM card, and pay off the balance every month.

The current one I don't charge anything to, and will pay it off in 11 months with no interest.

So, I'm using their credit cards to my advantage, not theirs!

Sonny