Philosophical musings
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>An earlier post raised the question of the relative importance between design and execution. Which carries more weight in the final �value� of a piece of work? The poster suggested that the overwhelming factor in the relationship is execution. Perhaps this is true in a very narrow way; if a dozen craftsmen were to each duplicate a single example of a Chippendale chair, then the most finely wrought copy could be considered the best among them. On the other hand, Chippendale style furniture has been popular for more than 250 years, whether manufactured in a Chinese factory or hand made by the most skilled craftsman, only because of the design. In today�s market, the most financially successful craftsmen fall into either of two categories: the copier, who executes the highest quality fit and finish in a borrowed design style; and the designer, who creates a unique design that he may or may not make himself. Regardless, both rely on design for recognition. My conclusion is that design carries way more weight than execution in the final analysis.
Comments?
Clint



