Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Philosophical musings

Posts

Philosophical musings

#1

Philosophical musings

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>An earlier post raised the question of the relative importance between design and execution. Which carries more weight in the final �value� of a piece of work? The poster suggested that the overwhelming factor in the relationship is execution. Perhaps this is true in a very narrow way; if a dozen craftsmen were to each duplicate a single example of a Chippendale chair, then the most finely wrought copy could be considered the best among them. On the other hand, Chippendale style furniture has been popular for more than 250 years, whether manufactured in a Chinese factory or hand made by the most skilled craftsman, only because of the design. In today�s market, the most financially successful craftsmen fall into either of two categories: the copier, who executes the highest quality fit and finish in a borrowed design style; and the designer, who creates a unique design that he may or may not make himself. Regardless, both rely on design for recognition. My conclusion is that design carries way more weight than execution in the final analysis.

Comments?

Clint

Re: Philosophical musings

#2

I disagree

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>This may come down to "how many Angels can dance on the head of a pin?" type discussion. (Does anyone here remember the answer?)

If you are discussing top quality execution whether factory or individual craftsman, then I agree with design. However, if one is looking at the difference between a piece sold by Porters of Racine (WI) and the same design sold by American or Colders in Milwaukee, then execution is more important. The design is fine but the quality of workmanship, well, there is no comparison at all.

However, I think you may be talking more of "style" instead of execution. I believe your assumption is, given competent joinery/workmanship, what is the flair of the craftsman making the piece. How does his interpretation fit with the piece. Is there any flair to the execution.

This will be true of the design as well as the execution. Some designs are excellent and demand to built. Others are basically ho hum.

Re: Philosophical musings

#3

Third category...

John in New Mexico

>"In today�s market, the most financially successful craftsmen fall into either of two categories: the copier, who executes the highest quality fit and finish in a borrowed design style; and the designer, who creates a unique design that he may or may not make himself."

The salesman. I'm not talking about a guy who sells used cars or whatever, I'm talking about a craftsman who talks to people and gets them excited about what he builds, be it copies or unique pieces. The ability to communicate his passion for his work is what makes for financial success, as I think this is what convinces the buyer that the product is worth the extra expense over the factory competition.

I know a couple builders who can do this, now if only I could learn it myself!

John

Re: Philosophical musings

#4

The Water Got Muddy Real Fast

Robert Hutchins

>First we juxtapose design and quality of workmanship as comparators. Then suddenly financial success jumps into the discussion without so much as a "by your leave".

I maintain that they are 3 separate and distinct things. The Professor and I have corresponded about the relative merits of Frank Lloyd Wright's product. I hope he will excuse my disclosing our evaluations.

In Wright, we have one whom we may study in all three aspects: design, execution, and financial success. IMO - I think shared by The Professor - Wright was an able designer in some respects and a very poor one in many others. He was woefully inept when it came to execution. And, he was a financial failure despite very great renown and patronage from some very lenient clients. Designing Falling Waters for the aesthetic values but failing to construct it so that it would not rot is but one example of his failings. We won't mention the cost over-runs that his very wealthy clients had to experience.

I don't think it is possible to measure the value of design or execution exclusively - or even largely - with financial yardsticks. "A thing of beauty is a joy forever." The marvelous One Hoss Shay was executed - well 'marvelously'. How does monetary value enter either of those valuations?

Some things require more than 'either/or' logic; must have multiple simultaneous equations to solve correctly.

Re: Philosophical musings

#5

Re: Philosophical musings

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>The point I was trying to make, perhaps too simplistically, is that every example of furniture, past and present, that enjoys popularity and wide appeal has a common trait. The first thing that draws attention and commands a second look is the design, if that doesn�t work, then it doesn�t matter how well the dovetails are crafted. Check out any craft show that displays a lot of furniture. Some booths may as well have the plague, even though the workmanship is outstanding. It�s a little like baton twirling; one may be able to do the most amazing things throwing a stick around, but it�s still baton twirling. How significant is that?

Clint

Re: Philosophical musings

#6

To set the record straight

Robert Henderson

>"The number of angels" was not really a "number".

The medieval debate was whether angels had a corporeal existence or were entirely spirit. If the former, none could dance on the head of a pin. If the latter, an infinite number could dance on the head of a pin. Therefore, it was a actually serious theological debate (if you believe in that stuff).

Re: Philosophical musings

#7

Re: To set the record straight

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>What does the religious debate refer to, angels or infinity?

Clint

Re: Philosophical musings

#8

I agree

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Basically yes. FLW was a magnificent designer who was totally unable to execute his designs, nor can anyone else without serious changes in the structure of the designs. Although we cannot legitimately split the three categories, we can separate them for discussion.

I think the financial side is important but it is the third leg of the stool which depends upon additional factors we are not discussing here.

We started out with design and execution. A design that has never been executed/completed is, by definition, incomplete. The executor may not be totally competent and the execution of it will suffer as a result. Had FLW's plans and designs been lost and then found today, the outward aspect of the building would be his but the structure would be re-engineered and would work. I could, for axample, follow the plans for a Chippendale piece. The result would be ok at best. Although the joinery, dimensions, materials and so on would be correct, there would be no flair. Everything would be by the book and only by the book. On the other hand, were I to do a Shaker piece, then there would be some flair. The same is true of orchestras and conductors. I prefer Ozawa and the Boston to Bernstein and the New York for any Berlioz, Mendelssohn, Brahms - any romantic.

Re: Philosophical musings

#9

Well, Clint, . . .

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>youo posed a question and got "unintended answers". But that's what's fun here.

Re: Philosophical musings

#10

Re: To set the record straight

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Actually, if you remember your Medieval History, it refers to both. The question was interminably debated far too long. Let us leave it alone - for now!

Re: Philosophical musings

#11

Re: To set the record straight

r payne

>I always thought the answer was 42.

:)

ron

Re: Philosophical musings

#12

It is, but to what question? ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: Philosophical musings

#13

Requires Deep Thought and Very Long Time !

Robert Hutchins

>

Re: Philosophical musings

#14

Re: Philosophical musings

Rob Lee

>Sooo....

If I take that chair - paint it blue, drive a bent nail into it, sell it on eBay as art, get 17 bidders, the last of whom pays $450,000 dollars for it - then that's it's true value....! :)

A bit tongue in cheek - but I would assume that the assignation of value depends on what the buyer perceives the value to be...and different buyers will assign different values...

I would value a "first of" differently than a perfectly crafted second, but for completely different reasons...it's an apples to oranges comparison.

Cheers -

Rob