Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT Chainsaws

Posts

OT Chainsaws

#1

OT Chainsaws

Jeffrey D. Rose

>I am in North Eastern Iowa and we resently got hit with a small storm that has shut off the power to about 100,000 people, plus caused a lot of trees to fall. I would like to get a good new chainsaw to do some clean up with to replace my 20 year old Homelite 240, to bad homelite doesn't make saws like this any more. I have narrowed my search to Husqvarna and Echo. I am looking at 16"-20" bars. Any thoughts on either?

TIA

Jeff in Iowa.

Re: OT Chainsaws

#2

Husqvarna

Ken Oakley--Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>See Thread below and also one on Turning Forum for other views.

Re: OT Chainsaws

#3

There are a whole bunch of

Mike in Paradise

>options available to you. Stihl is the biggest selling chainsaw and if you look at Ebay you will see that they outnumber all others.]

I think that both Husky and Echo make decent saws except for the the very small husky which is made by Poulan, but I forget the model number (Maybe 137).

If you go to the chain saw forums they will tell you that need to buy a professional model which is not really true but if you do you will not regret it.

There are really the basic small saws for occasional use, then the homeowner saws which are plastic cased and sell for less then the professional models which are magnesium cased in order to give good power to weight ratio and cost more.

I love my Stihls(MS260pro, MS361, MS660) and use the MS260pro the most. It is a great saw but it is expensive.

The most popular Stihl is the MS290 and the most popular husky is the 455 (or 55) rancher as both companies make the price point of these saws to be a very good value. The chainsaw enthusiasts will pooh-pooh both of these saws as the power to weight ratio is poor compared to the pro-models.

If I lived in the states was going to buy a Husky I would get a price from baileys-online as they are very competitive and are great folks to deal with.

Have fun!


img

Re: OT Chainsaws

#4

Re: OT Chainsaws-one Iowan to another

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Jeff,

A Husky is a good choice, but if your going to run a 16" or 20" bar, look for something in at least the 360cc size. After cutting wood for nearly 10 years here in NW Iowa, I found the bigger size pays off. The clutch will be sized to match a bigger bar, so stall outs and burnt clutches are less likely. It's aggravating to not be able to cut larger trunks & limbs simply because of not having enough power or not enough clutch to do the job! It might be a little more tiring to swing around a larger saw all day, but you'll also find that the extra weight can also be benificial to ease of the cut.

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT Chainsaws

#5

I hope you meant. 36cc Ron....

SanMan

>....Stihl doesnt have a saw that big....'ceptin for the jet fueled competitive ones that can cut a log in 'bout 3 seconds.

360cc is a big ash saw!

SM

Re: OT Chainsaws

#6

If those are the only two choices.....

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....go with a Husky.

They can run with the Stihl's I guess, I wouldnt make that statement for an Echo IMHO.

Were it me I would add Stihl in place of the Echo for comparison.

For about the same money I would go for a Stihl damn near every time hands down.

I run a MS 310....great saw.....love to have a MS 440 or 660, but cant justify the high tag on those "pro" end saws. Ive used a 660 before with a 36" bar on it...and it is a dream to use for tall guys.

Did you lose power at all during the weekend? Any damage up your way? Hope not Jeff.

Scott

Re: OT Chainsaws

#7

Re: OT Chainsaws

Tom Stockton

>Jeff

Most important part is the dealer I wouldn't buy a saw from a big box store, Service is key on a chainsaw. Around here there are a number of dealers that carry husky and sthil so you can compare them side by side. Also pro saws are nice but carry a premium price for features you may not need.

Tom

Re: OT Chainsaws

#8

Re: I hope you meant. 36cc Ron....

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Yup, your right--was thinking of my old 360 Homelite I once had! Thanks for the correction!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT Chainsaws

#9

Re: If those are the only two choices.....

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Scott-

We lost power over night here in NW Iowa. Guess I can be proud of the work I've done on this old house-68 deg at 8:30pm when the power was lost Sat night, and 65 deg the next morning at 7:00am as I went out to blow the driveway. Outside temp overnight was around 20 deg. with a NW wind at about 15mph!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT Chainsaws

#10

Re: If those are the only two choices.....

Jeffrey D. Rose

>Scott,

We were without power for about 24 hours, not bab for having 18 poles down in the field next to us. A lot are still without power around us. Not expected to get power back until Friday. We had a message from Homeland Security last night to see shelters if you do not have power, because of two more storms that are moving in. I mostly ahve trees with limbs down and I need a good saw that will last like my Homelite 240 has.

Jeff in Iowa.

Re: OT Chainsaws

#11

Poulan plug

John Foster

>The best thing about Poulans is that you can go into town for lunch, leave the Poulan in the back of your truck, and know that it will still be in the back of your truck when you leave the diner.

Re: OT Chainsaws

#12

No

Dan Donaldson

>You will have two of them in the back of your truck ;-)