Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

ethical question regarding selling "your" work

Posts

ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#1

A.J. Hamler

ethical question regarding selling "your" work

A.J. Hamler

>I had thought about posting this a week ago but kept talking myself out of it. But it's still eating at me so I'd like your opinion. Legalities aside, what are the ethics of this?

While looking for something else on eBay, I stumbled across an auction that instantly caught my eye. The guy has taken a project that I published a while back in Woodcraft Mag while I was editor. The project wasn't mine, but rather one a friend of mine did which I edited and largely rewrote for publication. It was clear to me that this guy has copied it exactly, and has even gone so far as to use a shortened version of the opening paragraph of the article which I wrote as an intro, as his description for the auction.

I stewed about this for a day or two and e-mailed him, politely taking him to task for using it without giving credit to either the magazine or my friend. Figured I'd never hear back from him. He did respond, though, and defended his actions. First, he stated that because the article gave full details on how to make it, that this somehow gives him the go-ahead to make it and sell them. He also claimed that the dimensions of his are different from the one in the magazine, which wasn't true -- unless he listed incorrect measurements in his auction description, they are the same.

He also pointed out that because the project reproduced a common 19th-century object, that the writer of the project article had no "right" to it in the first place, which is, of course, technically true. He further noted that because the writer was compensated for the article, that this relieves him of any obligation when making his own and selling them.

Now, I don't really care that he's taken the intro I wrote to the article and used it. Since I was working for the magazine at the time, everything I wrote while there was work-for-hire, so I have no rights to it. Anyone who wants to rip off the magazine has my blessing. I further don't care that he's making these things and selling them; there are several other people on eBay selling their own versions -- this is, after all, a common object -- and have been doing so long before I published the article.

The thing of it is, is that my friend did considerable research of the project based on his study of actual historical samples in coming up with the design, measurements, method of construction, etc. But this guy's auction listing claims that *he* did the research and all the hard work to create the item.

I guess that's what irks me about all of this. I've seen numerous woodworking items for sale on eBay and elsewhere, where the seller acknowledges that the item is based on another or inspired by another that appeared elsewhere in one place or the other, frequently even mentioning either the publication or original maker. This guy describes it as though he's done all the research and background work.

Am I off-base here?

A.J.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#2

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Hey A.J.

First of all I can see why you are frustrated. It sounds like that guy is quite the "opportunist" and playing fast and loose with the facts. However I'm not sure it would be easy to disprove him about his claims of "researching" the piece. (even if he is lying)

It was published and placed in the public domain so he took advantage and copied the piece. He is guilty of having poor ethics but probably not much more. I doubt there is much satisfaction to gain with any attempt at recourse I'm sorry to say.

Tom

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#3

Re: It is almost impossible to ....

Jamie Donaldson

>..legislate ethics and manners, and you have stated the dilemma very well. Unfortunately there is very little you can do now legally as far as copyright is concerned- proving infringement is very complicated and all you will accomplish is to verify that the guy is a jerk. To claim "authorship" is the final blow.I know from first hand experience how this galls, but trying to gain some measure of satisfaction is a long and winding, and very expensive, path. Jerks happen, but don't be bitter and self destructive over it either. His reckoning will come someday.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#4

Fact of life . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>I only mention this as an example of "plagerism" (sp) in the "selling" world. Pretty much along the same lines as your situation. At " Craft Shows " when you start selling a new design for something ( example : Raindeer Christmas card holder my Dad-in-law came up with.) the five other vendors at the show will run home, produce them, and have them for sale the very next weekend at the next show. Personaly, I think its wrong. The bottom line is that your only option is to sue. Does the bottom line justify your cost to sue. In my world of custom models I get blueprints and designs from manufacturers to work from that the model kit outfits can't get yet. I've had them try and "spoof" me to get them ( they identify them selves as Boy Scout Troops and other non-profit orgs ), no kidding ! Its a cut throat world ! BUT . . . thats how we get better mouse-traps I guess.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#5

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

Charles Sharp

>I think you are over reacting a bit. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. What have you or your friend lost other than an acknowledgement? If you were competing for the same customers I could understand your anger. If I were your friend, I'd be bragging about this guy using your plans, even if he is a ........ (bad person)

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#6

Steven Antonucci

A different point of view

Steve Antonucci

>This one is difficult for me to rationalize, AJ. I understand your frustration with his representation of the facts, but in reality , didn't you do the same thing?

The facts as I understand them:

1.) nowhere in the magazine does it credit the "original" author of the plans. There is historical reference to the objects being commonly produced, but in the end, you represent it as your own original design?

2.) Nowhere in the magazine does it forbid the subscribers to produce these objects for their own profit? (maybe it does, but I don't read the small print inside the cover, do you?)

3.) While design is important, 90% is in execution. He did that by himself, so the plans are such a minor part of the effort that I think it's fair for him to represent it as his work, albeitnot his design.

4.) My assumption is that the magazines produce plans to entice readers to buy a subscription. If the readers were not allowed to use the plans to produce the items in the magazine, that should be clearly indicated in big letters. Once the item has been produced, it is the producers (the magazine has no commercial rights to the objects, only the design.)

I agree that folks should clearly credit their inspirations, but the production of these objects is the right of the craftsman, and should not be restricted by the magazine. If it was restricted, what do you think that would do to readership?

Steve

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#7

Question of intellectual property law

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Actually, many magazines do expressly prohibit the reader from making profit from anything in the magazine. Now, this opens up that whole realm of intellectual property, which I know slightly less than nothing about.

I do have a fear that with so many people trying to profit from "ideas" and "plans" that soon nothing will be in the public domain. For instance, a magazine puts out a plan for a side table. Once it is in the magazine, it is a copywritten work. The table may be nothing new under the sun at all, but now no one can make AND SELL it without permission from the copyright holder. I recently watched Norm make a reproduction of some Cowboy furniture. Does that mean I could not also make this piece without the consent of New Yankee Workshop?

Personally, I don't think anyone should have rights to what is done with a plan. A person or entity can own the rights to the plan, and as such I purchase it from then. Now, if I copy and sell the plan, that is wrong. But if I make the item and sell it, that should not be illegal. Apparently, it is though.

As for AJ's question, I do think it was wrong of someone else to take your words without notice to their origin, even if they were in this case owned by the magazine.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#8

Last sentence

HC Sakman

>Hi AJ,

You said: " I've seen numerous woodworking items for sale on eBay and elsewhere, where the seller acknowledges that the item is based on another or inspired by another that appeared elsewhere in one place or the other, frequently even mentioning either the publication or original maker. This guy describes it as though he's done all the research and background work."

This just describes that something rather is not right. Unfortunately. he can get away with it.

You did what's right. You tried to awaken his conscious which may be present or absent, I don't know. Most thieves don't have any.

Chico...

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#9

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

Paul Waddle

>I agree its an ethics question and this person was unethical. Can't say more,there is no more-there all types of people. Anyway,your friend and you enjoyed making this item,so I suppose that is some consolation.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#10

There was a similar discussion recently...

John in New Mexico

>over at family woodworking. Hypothetical in that case, unlike this thread, but still fairly informative thanks to a couple of copyright lawyers. One of the overall impressions I got from that discussion is that the sale of a piece of work from a published plan is a grey area. It would basically come down to a determination of "uniqueness" in a civil suit, but no one seems to take it that far, thus even the lawyers are left speculating on the subject.

As far as this guy's plagiarism goes, thats a bit easier. If he did lift the first sentence verbatim, with no permission or accreditation, then that would violate the copyright (take note, that I'm not a lawyer), and the holder of the copyright -presumably the magazine, would be able to take some action. If you wanted to do something about this, draw it to the publisher's attention. Best case is this guy would get a stiff letter from their lawyers, and might end up with an hours worth of richly deserved anxiety.

It sounds like if he'd just replied with an apology and thanks for the effort (ie research), and give due credit, then you'd have no problem? Though detestable, its easy to understand his reaction. He know he's in the wrong, didn't think he'd get caught, and has to come up with all these excuses to justify his actions to himself. Having told you all about the reasons he's really right, he can just continue his little delusion with no pangs of conscience.

I guess the flip side of that coin is this. Whenever one puts their designs or research work out in the public domain there's always a risk that someone will copy it. Though I don't have any respect for a person who would directly copy, say the chair I posted a picture of, I'm still content with the knowledge that I can just design another, whereas they must steal their ideas, and are therefor at a disadvantage in my view.

John

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#11

He's a hairball.....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>but there's nothing you can do about it. Laugh it off and have a hit of 12 year old, or vice versa.

Clint

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#12

Answer re: intellectual property law

Stephen Roth, Chatham NJ

>You raise a number of interesting issues here.

Under copyright law, an author's work is protected for his life, plus 70 years (or in the case of anonymous works, the earlier of 95 years from its first publication or 120 years after its creation). Works published prior to 1978 have different standards applied to them, and may have fallen into the public domain even before that time. The bottom line, though, is that copyright lasts a very long time.

But, take for example, a Townsend highboy built in 1800. Here, the copyright would have run out by now. Thus, if you saw one in a museum, you could photograph it and copy it without infringing on any copyrights, and make or sell as many copies as you want. (Assuming the museum let you, and you did not try to sell them as originals.) However, let's say a fellow woodworker Mr. Smith photographed the highboy and made plans from it. While Mr. Smith doesn't own any rights to the Townsend highboy, he does own the copyright in the photographs and the plans. These are what are called "derivative works." For example, I could take a photograph of Niagara Falls and sell it. I own the copyright in MY photographs. I don't own the falls, and you could take your own picture and sell it, but you can't copy my picture and sell that.

Getting back to the highboy plans, Mr. Smith's publishing them in a magazine doesn't change his rights in the plans. Usually, in the magazine or plan book, they say that one has the right to make a single copy for personal use. This is essentially a limited license. It does not give you the right to sell the object made from the plans. The license is only to what the author allowed.

Selling a copy of the piece made from the plans would be a making derivative work from the derivative work.

That is, Original Highboy

... to .... Mr. Smith's plans

... to ... Your highboy.

Note that someone could argue that Mr. Smith's plans are not copyrightable at all because they add noting to the original and thus are not works of authorship themselves. But anyone who has drawn plans quickly realizes that there is real creativity in drawing the plans. Perspective, angle, measurements, and details must be drawn. Thus, this argument is not that good.

Thus, the best bet would be to copy from the original that is in the public domain.

Stephen - Copyright Attorney

Caveat: I am not saying this is the right policy with regard to art; it is just what the law says. The trade off of an artist's rights and the right to expand on that theme has been debated for hundreds of years, and will continue to be debated with new technology. The kid's complaining that they have the right to download music for their I-Pods don't realize how much they have in common with the manufacture's of player piano roll music, who were being sued by the sheet music people, who said that no one would buy sheet music if piano roll music was available. (And the sheet music people were sued by the musicians, who said no one would listen to live music if they could but sheet music.)

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#13

Alan Young

ethicalRe: question regarding selling "your" work

Alan Young

>

It was clear to me that this guy has copied it exactly, and has even gone so far as to use a shortened version of the opening paragraph of the article which I wrote as an intro, as his description for the auction. ....The thing of it is, is that my friend did considerable research of the project based on his study of actual historical samples in coming up with the design, measurements, method of construction, etc......I guess that's what irks me about all of this...This guy describes it as though he's done all the research and background work.

Am I off-base here?

A.J.

He seems like an opportunist that will justify his actions no matter what you say. Imitation may be the sincerest form of flattery but claiming credit for others ideas and efforts is pretty creepy.

Here's the deal-I doubt too many people reading the auction notice would recognized the name(s) of the actual creators- something this guy surely counted on when he posted the auction. You are the needle in the haystack. Your power to stick it to him is probably limited to the actions you've taken. If his conscience isn't bothered now, nothing else will.

Alan

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#14

Lee Gordon

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

Lee Gordon

>This sounds eerily familiar to the ongoing debate over the ethics of people making and selling pieces "in the style of Sam Maloof" that appeared in the Letters to the Editor column of Woodshop News when you were in charge at that publication.

I believe the conventional wisdom at the time was that it's OK to make and even sell such pieces as long as the maker does not represent them as having been made by Sam Maloof himself but identifies them either as copies or designs "inspired by" Sam. Just as in your situation, the bottom line is the attribution.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#15

Interesting

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Some things I did not know in there. One point that still confused me though, with something like plan is what is actually controlled? I certainly agree that the plan is copywritten - it is an original work, even if it is of an existing piece. However, how does the copywrite extend to the use of that plan? If I use the plan from a magazine, I paid for the magazine, which means I compensated the company for their work. I guess what I don't understand is the "Limited Use" clause. I do agree that I should not be able to copy and sell the plan (or even copy and give it away - but that's another thorny issue these days).

Fascinating discussion, though. Quite relevant, too. Take for instance a person is perusing magazines at the book store. They see the plans for a piece of furniture they would really like. They buy the magazine, but don't have the skills or tools to build a piece. So they ask a woodworker to build the piece for them, and then compensate the woodworker for the time and labor. Would that be considered in violation of limited use?

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#16

So how does a design patent figure in?

John in New Mexico

>As I understand it- which means very shallowly ;), the copyright protects photos or drawings of an original work, in this case furniture. Wouldn't one need a design patent to prevent the copying and sale of direct imitations?

John

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#17

Furniture has virtually no copywrite protection

Earl Kelly

>Only Furniture considered as "Art" has copywrite protection. Now, you can have Design Patents on certain aspects of a work. And you can Trademark a name. But normally, because it's considered a "Utility" piece there's no protection. There has to be uniquness that signifies that you're the owner and creator. When was the last time you saw something that had never been done before.

The best protection is a "Brand", a design or name that can be trademarked, that separates your work from others. Even,then you have to feed the Lawyers to protect yourself.

Earl

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#18

Alan Young

A Ha! Time to make a few leaf tables! :^)

Alan Young

>

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#19

How does " prior art " figure in ?

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#20

Hey, A.J.

Don Henthorn

>You want I should send my boys over to take care of him?

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#21

Is it the same?

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>My understand is that Sam taught people how to make chairs to his design for pay. Was there any mention either way of these people selling the chairs they made? To me unless there was a clear prohibition against then selling them is ok as long as Sam got credit as the designer.

Does Woodcrart have a disclaimer on making items from their plans for profit? Most mags do. His claiming to be the originator of the design is lying, period.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#22

A.J. Hamler

Thanks everyone

A.J. Hamler

>Thanks everybody for your thoughts.

To clarify, I have no intention of doing anything about it other than the e-mail I already sent him taking him to task. But I did want to get your thoughts on it in the interest of healthy discussion of a subject that affects us all. My main concern was that I was letting it bother me unduly, but it seems that most of you feel as I do.

Thanks again. My next post won't be so controversial.

A.J.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#23

Controversial, but enjoyable

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I thought it was a great discussion.

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#24

It wasn't controversial at all.

HC Sakman

>When something is in print, does not mean person X can put that in production and use it for commercial purposes.

Perhaps making one or two to sell may be acceptable with due and proper credits. That's how I feel.

Chico...

Re: ethical question regarding selling "your" work

#25

More answers

Stephen Roth, Chatham NJ

>You all raise very interesting issues and questions.

How does copyright extend to the plans?:

It covers the plans and any derivative works from the plans. The piece built from the plan is a derivative work, even though it is in a different form. (Think about making a movie from a book.)

What about a commissioned piece.

(Really interesting question.) That is a really close call. I could argue both sides (we lawyers always do), but the I'd say if you have the right to make one, then you probably would have the right to pay someone to do it. I couold easily argue the other side because of the commercial transaction component.

What about a design patent?:

Design patents and copyrights can coexist. Furniture can be protected by both, and often is. Design patents last only 14 years. Also, in the United States, you must apply for them within one year of the public disclosure of the piece.

What about prior art:

Now that is a very long discussion. It is basically all that came before the invention.