ethical question regarding selling "your" work
A.J. Hamler
>I had thought about posting this a week ago but kept talking myself out of it. But it's still eating at me so I'd like your opinion. Legalities aside, what are the ethics of this?
While looking for something else on eBay, I stumbled across an auction that instantly caught my eye. The guy has taken a project that I published a while back in Woodcraft Mag while I was editor. The project wasn't mine, but rather one a friend of mine did which I edited and largely rewrote for publication. It was clear to me that this guy has copied it exactly, and has even gone so far as to use a shortened version of the opening paragraph of the article which I wrote as an intro, as his description for the auction.
I stewed about this for a day or two and e-mailed him, politely taking him to task for using it without giving credit to either the magazine or my friend. Figured I'd never hear back from him. He did respond, though, and defended his actions. First, he stated that because the article gave full details on how to make it, that this somehow gives him the go-ahead to make it and sell them. He also claimed that the dimensions of his are different from the one in the magazine, which wasn't true -- unless he listed incorrect measurements in his auction description, they are the same.
He also pointed out that because the project reproduced a common 19th-century object, that the writer of the project article had no "right" to it in the first place, which is, of course, technically true. He further noted that because the writer was compensated for the article, that this relieves him of any obligation when making his own and selling them.
Now, I don't really care that he's taken the intro I wrote to the article and used it. Since I was working for the magazine at the time, everything I wrote while there was work-for-hire, so I have no rights to it. Anyone who wants to rip off the magazine has my blessing. I further don't care that he's making these things and selling them; there are several other people on eBay selling their own versions -- this is, after all, a common object -- and have been doing so long before I published the article.
The thing of it is, is that my friend did considerable research of the project based on his study of actual historical samples in coming up with the design, measurements, method of construction, etc. But this guy's auction listing claims that *he* did the research and all the hard work to create the item.
I guess that's what irks me about all of this. I've seen numerous woodworking items for sale on eBay and elsewhere, where the seller acknowledges that the item is based on another or inspired by another that appeared elsewhere in one place or the other, frequently even mentioning either the publication or original maker. This guy describes it as though he's done all the research and background work.
Am I off-base here?
A.J.



