Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

cutting board

Posts

cutting board

#1

cutting board

bill tindal, E.TN

>I am teaching a class this week and I make a door prize to give away. This year it is a cherry cutting board. I make these from junk as I think the gum streaks and sap/heart contrast is attractive. I sand very smooth, usually 220 grit and finish with vegetable oil. I find the vege oil doesn't bleed back out like mineral oil. The board is nothing special but I post it because it might give others an idea for using otherwise useless wood.


img

Re: cutting board

#2

Re: cutting board

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Bill,

Nice board and a nice touch giving a gift (in addition to your wisdom) to your students.

A warning though: some people (me, for instance) can smell rancid oils a mile away. Trust me, vegetable oil does become rancid.

Uh, I might have exagerated just a bit when I wrote "a mile away," but it is unmistakable.

Al

Re: cutting board

#3

a contrarian view

bill tindal, E.TN

>I have used vegetable oils for many years on these things without complaint. An acquaintance sells wooden ware for a living at craft shows and she uses vege. oil. Walnut oil, a commonly recommended finish for wooden ware differs only slightly chemically from many vegetable oils and would suffer the same problems if indeed there were any. Furthermore, a cutting board that is used will accumulate oils anyway unless, heaven forbid, the board is scrubbed. Bottom line, I have not found the potential problem to be significant in my hands. My cutting boards have much less odor than the things I typically cut on them, for example sour dough bread, cheese, etc.

On the other hand, if you have finished wooden ware with peanut oil (or similar) and found it acquired an objectionable odor then I will concede others might too. In that case avoid using walnut oil and avoid using wood boards for any oil containing foods for they will have the same issues.

When in doubt there is always testing. Put some oil on a test piece of wood and sniff it for a year to see if you can live with it.

Re: cutting board

#4

Re: a contrarian view

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Bill, why do you say no scrubbing? A cutting board, by definition, is used to cut food. Bread is no problem but vegetables (onions for example) and meats cooked or uncooked, and cheeses, can leave dangerous "remains" and must be scrubbed off the board. We always scrub ours with soap and water, hot water.

I have made maple and cherry boards for many years. I will not use anything except BLO and allow it to cure prior to first use of the board.

Re: cutting board

#5

I'll go with Bill

Don Henthorn

>We have been using two cutting boards made of walnut for years and we seldom really clean them. We always rinse the gook from them after use but I seldom use soap. The University of Wisconsin study found that wood has a natural ability to destroy microbes and although many have expressed scepticism regarding the study, I find nothing wrong with the study design or the way it was carried out. Works for me. Of course we are both old and tough and hard to get rid of.

Re: cutting board

#6

HERE WE GO

Mike from Tn.

>This is the same argument That I've heard for years. To veg or not to veg.. If you make it for yourself, use whatever you want or whatever you feel comfortable with. On my own stuff I use mineral oil,because an old guy told me to. If I make stuff to sell I use mineral oil and tell people I do. If I make a custom piece, I give them the choice of mineral oil or they can rub in what they want. Why am I sold on mineral oil you might ask? Because an old guy told me to. I'm 50 by the way. I hope you all take this in the lite hearted way it was meant.

Re: cutting board

#7

Re: cutting board

vlparisian - Houston

>Hard to find my chess pieces on that. :>)

That is rather attractive. How long from start to finish on a couple of those?

Re: cutting board

#8

Re: cutting board

Mike from Tn.

>I love the abstract design. Did you set out with that pattern or did it just fall togeather like that? I remember a poker table from 35 yrs ago that an old shop teacher made during the school year using scrap. Similar pattern but with triangles. Did you put any pads on the bottom?

Re: cutting board

#9

Re: walnut oil

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I'm not sure that it is fair to compare walnut oil to other vegetable oils as it is a drying oil. it takes longer to dry than BLO but it will and then there is no danger of it going rancid.

Another option is Howards brand feed-n-wax. it is a blend of bees wax and lemon oil. basically it is edible and will not spoil, kind of the best of both worlds. I have used this and like the sheen but as a finish on treenware it does need to be renewed a couple times a year.

Robin Corell

Re: cutting board

#10

Re: a con-contrarian view

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Bill,

Not to be argumentative (he said before commencing in his agrumentative tone)...

First, most folks wouldn't bother regitering a complaint with the maker of a cutting board that developed a rancid odor. They are relatively cheap (the boards, not the buyers) and who's to say the maker cause the stink? The buyer might well assume that he caused the problem.

Second, and more important, many, many people can't smell rancid vegetable oil. I'm the only person I know that can. I've found smelly cutting boards and asked relatives to smell them. Noone but me can smell it.

If you can't detect the odor and your customers are happy, then I'm happy for you. Just don't try to sell me a board finished with vegetable oil.

Written for information purposed, not to detract from your product.

Al

Re: cutting board

#11

Re: cutting board

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Rarely do cutting boards catch my eye. This one sure did. Cool!

Tom

Re: cutting board

#12

What about "Salad Bowl" finish???

Dave Anderson, SoCal - From Home

>When I've read threads like this over the years, the discussions seem to center around veggie vs mineral oil.

I've often wondered why "salad bowl" finish is seldom if ever mentioned as another option?

Is there a reason why using a salad bowl finish should be avoided on cutting boards?

Work Safely!

Dave in SoCal - wondering if Al's sniffer can tell the difference between canola and corn oil...

Re: cutting board

#13

Re: What about "Salad Bowl" finish???

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>From what I have read on this finish, and I have some, it is basically a mineral oil and a very light one.

Re: cutting board

#14

Ellis Walentine

Re: What about "Salad Bowl" finish???

Ellis Walentine

>Salad bowl finish is a film finish -- a varnish. If you cut on it you cut through it. Oils, whether drying or non-drying, reside in the surface layers and pores of the wood, so they can't become torn up by normal cutting activities.

Regarding the vegetable oil controversy, I've tried every type of oil on cutting boards and I could definitely smell the non-drying vegetable oils, especially if they were kept in an enclosed space such as a drawer. Maybe, like someone said, I am just more sensitive to such smells than most people, but Michael Dresdner and others have persuaded me that nut oils and other drying oils are a better choice for cutting boards.

I do like the concept of your brickwork boards, Bill. Did you use epoxy to glue up the pieces? How thick is the board?

Ellis