Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

1/4 sheet orbital sander

Posts

1/4 sheet orbital sander

#1

1/4 sheet orbital sander

john b SW Chicago burbs

>I own a Bosch 1/4 sheet orbital sander, it leaves small swirl marks that show up after finish is applied. Is the festool 400 the answer or is there a more economical solution. Temper tantrums with the Bosch don't work. Thanks john b.

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#2

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

Barry Irby

>I have a B & D (I think) quarter sheet sander That gets essentially no use now that I have a Porter Cable 5" ROS. I believe FWW just did a report on them in the last few months. You might want ot check it out. I am sure the Festool is leagues ahead of almost any quarter sheet sander, but I am very happy with my PC "Quicksand" that is variable speed. The quarter sheet and ROS's are very different machines.

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#3

I only use orbital for really fine sanding...

John in New Mexico

>Plus edges, rounding corners, etc. For surfaces where you're going to notice the little corkscrew scratches from an orbital, just use a random orbital sander. I'd guess the motion of the sander is more important than the brand. I use a cheap Ryobi ROS, and it works fine, but makes your hands numb after about 30 minutes (Festool ROS's reportedly don't do this). I'll probably replace it with a Festool one day and save whats left of the nerves.

Anyway, its cheap to get a ROS and see if it fixes your problems before taking the plunge on a pricey model.

John

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#4

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>A more economical solution, at least from a dollar standpoint, is a rubber sanding block and hand sanding the last grit of your project.

At least that's been my experience. Quieter, too. Only takes a few minutes, for the projects I do.

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

Dale Lenz

>I've been using the Makita BO4550 since 1990, on my second one. Went shopping today for my third one. I think I can take the two old ones and get another working one out of them. The sander gets a good work out every 6 weeks or less, several days of sanding.

Maybe 1 in 20 projects do I see the swirl marks you are speaking of. Wash the project down in mineral thinner in direct sunlight and view with a raking light to try to find the critters prior to finishing.

Good luck,

Dale

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#6

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

Bob Fawcett

>Porter Cable Speed Bloc.

I own 3 orbital sanders. This is easily the best. It is also the quietest. Costs a little more, but worth it.

Second would be the Makita. Bosch is Ok.

I only use these for 150 grit and higher.

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#7

I've had the same Makita for more than 20 years

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and it just keeps on keeping on. I've had the bearings replaced once, and it's due for new ones now. It is just the most rugged little critter...

I even wet-sanded the cured epoxy of a canoe.

I've had no experience with any other quarter sheet sander, but then I've seen no reason.

Bruce

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#8

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

David Yoho

>I think the bottom line is all of them will leave the small squiggly marks you mention at one time or another. I've got a Porter Cable Speed Bloc, a Makita BO4550, a Porter Cable 5" random orbit, and two Festool 6" random orbit sanders. I've seen those marks after using all of them. It doesn't happen all of the time with any one of them but the 1/4-sheet sanders do it more than the random orbits do.

I use Michael Dresdner's advise and do a final hand sanding with the appropriate grit garnet paper. This makes for additional work but the end result is worth it for me.

One note about the Festool sanders - you could sand for literally hours and not get the tingling sensation in your hand that the others cause. Those sanders are some of the best spent money I've ever removed from my pocket!

David

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#9

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

pecker

>I've noticed that starting with too coarse a grit will cause this to happen on my sanders. You don't notice the resulting squiggles until you're at the finishing stage, unfortunately.

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#10

I'm Partial To My Makita 1/4-sheet Sander

Howard In Toronto

>Tried the P-C version bevause it had the round dust port for my shop-vac but after 20 minutes were TINGLING.

Returned it and bought my first choice - the Makita.

I don't remember its model number but it's the evergreen unit you see all the time.

No vibration to make my hands tingle and it is more aggressive than its specs would suggest.

Wouldn't trade it for any other.

HTH

Howard

Re: 1/4 sheet orbital sander

#11

Second the P+C 330 Speed Bloc, and..

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon John,

I've found that moving the orbital sander more slowly reduces those little curly scratches. However, it is equally important to eliminate residual dust when you use a progressively finer grit. Its always a good idea to finish up with hand sanding.

George