Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors

Posts

Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors

#1

Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors

Dave Morris

>Every so often I come up with a dumb question (okay, quite often). Here's one of 'em:

So I'm out rummaging around in the Shop/Garage/Family-Storage-Area, looking for parts to compare to a 1980's vintage Jet bandsaw I'm restoring. I have a few other old machines waiting to be reborn once I get a larger and/or separate S/G/FSA. Two of them have old Delta motors, one on a 4" jointer, the other from a tilt-table saw/jointer combo. I noticed the amp numbers on the tags are quite different, despite the horse power ratings. Here's the skinny, given in the order the tags show...

Bandsaw--

Jet Model C

VOLT 115/230

HP 1

AMPS 10/5

HZ 60

RPM 1720

POLE 4

YEAR 1989

Jointer--

DELTA MILWAUKEE

DUAL VOLTAGE REPULSION INDUCTION MOTOR

MODEL KE 54M910 CCW

1HP

115/230 VOLTS

1725 RPM

60 CY

1PH

TYPE SR

FRAME 181

AMP 14.6/7

Saw/Jointer Combo--

Double Duty Motor

DELTA

MODEL M (N? It's faded))

TYPE SR

RPM 1725

FRAME 184

HP 1/2

AMP 7.8/3.9

VOLTS 110/220

40 �C CONT

CY 60

1 PH

Catalog No. 820

So, my question(s): Do the higher amp draw per HP on the older Delta motors mean they are less efficient than the newer Jet, or has the way motors are rated changed over the years? If they haven't, would the older Delta 1 HP motor have more power than the JET? Do electric motors have a HP *and* a torque rating like combustion engines, making one more suitable for a particular job than the other (like gas vs. diesel for towing). Yeah, I know a larger pulley size multiplies electric motor torque to the tool the same way a lower transmission gear multiplies torque to the wheels in a truck, but are there different "types", or power curves, for electric motors?

Just to keep the blood pressure down on the purists in the group, I'm not considering robbing either of those old American machines of their motor and putting it on my new(er)import bandsaw. But I am curious as to what I should look for on any other motors I happen to come by in the future, should I want to upgrade the bandsaw's power.

Hey, if I don't ask, I'll never learn, right?

Dave--- who knows a little bit about some things, but admits he knows hardly anything about almost everything else ;-)

Re: Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors

#2

Re: Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motor

Jim Swank

>The way tool HP has changed greatly over the years, and not for the better. It's now figured primarily at peak torque, not at nominal ratings as in the "good ole" days. Some things don't change though - 1 HP = 746.5W is still one of them. With roughly 80% efficiencies and other factors, somewhere around 8 amps at 115V makes an "honest" HP. Half the amps for 230V.

Re: Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors

#3

Re: Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motor

Bill Howatt

>Why don't you ask something simple :).

The generally accepted method is to ignore any HP ratings and consider the more current the motor draws the more power it will produce but that is probably an oversimplification.

The worst cases tend to be with universal motors (have brushes and will run on AC or DC) such as found on electric lawnmowers, and shop-vacs. They measure the current just as the motor stalls and then use it to calculate the HP. Naturally, the current is very high and if the motor ran like that for more than a very short time it would burn up. They do similar tricks with other devices like air compressors. Mine is rated at 5 HP. The most you can get out of its 120V circuit in terms of real sustained HP is about 1.5.

Motors do have different torque curves but generally all induction motors are similar. You might select a DC motor for one job, a synchronous motor for another, an induction for another. Your repulsion-induction motor has a higher starting torque than a regular induction motor.

The efficiency of modern motors may be higher due to improved materials and manufacturing. There is often confusion between efficiency which really is how much of the real energy consumed by the motor is turned in mechanical force vs how much is consumed by heat due to resistance in the windings, losses due to stray magnetic fields, losses due to magnetizing the stator.

The other issue confusing the picture is power factor. Motors present a highly inductive load rather than resistive which causes the voltage and current to be out of phase. The breakers, wiring and electrical supply must be able to provide the power to run the motor but not all of it is converted into useful work and actually is returned back to the grid. So you may have a motor drawing 10A but is really only using 7A to do real work. Don't worry about being charged for 10A and only getting the work out of 7A, your residential electric meter only counts up the 7A component. Big factories are a problem for the utilities and they will charge for what they have to supply regardless of how much is used since this can require a much larger installation. Factories will adjust the power-factor by putting banks of capacitors in the circuit to cancel out the inductive effects of the motors (which is usually the main problem). You sometimes see ratings like KVA and KW. The KVA rating which stands for Kilo-Volt-Amps is the voltage/current the device requires whereas KiloWatts is a measure of the actual power converted to work. KVA is always equal or greater than KW.

Bill

Re: Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors

#4

Re: Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motor

Dave Morris

>Jim and Bill, thanks for your excellent answers. I knew about the peak HP ratings game on universal motors (a 5 HP motor on a shop-vac or a 3 HP router running off a 15 amp 110V circuit? Yeah, right...). I figured there had to be a lot of advances over the years in motor design and efficiency. A couple of 3 and 5 HP motors on other machines I have dating back to the 1920's or so are truly monstrous compared to their modern descendants. I just wasn't sure if there was enough to warrant a 45% difference in amp ratings between the older 1 HP Delta and newer 1 HP Jet motors.

Thanks again.

Dave--- always ready to broaden his horizons