Question for all you Sparky's.... Elect. Motors
Dave Morris
>Every so often I come up with a dumb question (okay, quite often). Here's one of 'em:
So I'm out rummaging around in the Shop/Garage/Family-Storage-Area, looking for parts to compare to a 1980's vintage Jet bandsaw I'm restoring. I have a few other old machines waiting to be reborn once I get a larger and/or separate S/G/FSA. Two of them have old Delta motors, one on a 4" jointer, the other from a tilt-table saw/jointer combo. I noticed the amp numbers on the tags are quite different, despite the horse power ratings. Here's the skinny, given in the order the tags show...
Bandsaw--
Jet Model C
VOLT 115/230
HP 1
AMPS 10/5
HZ 60
RPM 1720
POLE 4
YEAR 1989
Jointer--
DELTA MILWAUKEE
DUAL VOLTAGE REPULSION INDUCTION MOTOR
MODEL KE 54M910 CCW
1HP
115/230 VOLTS
1725 RPM
60 CY
1PH
TYPE SR
FRAME 181
AMP 14.6/7
Saw/Jointer Combo--
Double Duty Motor
DELTA
MODEL M (N? It's faded))
TYPE SR
RPM 1725
FRAME 184
HP 1/2
AMP 7.8/3.9
VOLTS 110/220
40 �C CONT
CY 60
1 PH
Catalog No. 820
So, my question(s): Do the higher amp draw per HP on the older Delta motors mean they are less efficient than the newer Jet, or has the way motors are rated changed over the years? If they haven't, would the older Delta 1 HP motor have more power than the JET? Do electric motors have a HP *and* a torque rating like combustion engines, making one more suitable for a particular job than the other (like gas vs. diesel for towing). Yeah, I know a larger pulley size multiplies electric motor torque to the tool the same way a lower transmission gear multiplies torque to the wheels in a truck, but are there different "types", or power curves, for electric motors?
Just to keep the blood pressure down on the purists in the group, I'm not considering robbing either of those old American machines of their motor and putting it on my new(er)import bandsaw. But I am curious as to what I should look for on any other motors I happen to come by in the future, should I want to upgrade the bandsaw's power.
Hey, if I don't ask, I'll never learn, right?
Dave--- who knows a little bit about some things, but admits he knows hardly anything about almost everything else ;-)



