I have a 97 Honda CRV with 270,000 miles on it. My son has been driving it, and hit a deer. The Insurance company spent $4800+ fixing it. (I was stunned, and tried to get them to "total" it, but they would not) Within a month of getting it out of the shop, the alternator has gone bad and my son believes the transmission is on its last legs. My son bought a new truck and no longer needs the car.
So, What's the good move here? Sell the car as is? Replace the alternator for about $250 and sell it? Work on the transmission? What is a high milage CRV with a squirrley transmission worth? Part of what is confusing to me is I don't think its worth what the insurance comapany spent on it, but what do I care? Are there any good web sites for evaluating older cars?
>You can try Kelly Blue Book on line to get an idea of what the car is worth. The last two cars of mine that were wore out, I just donated to a local charity for the write-off, but since the IRS changed the rules last year, I don't know if that is still a viable option.
>Donation is viable, but the rules changed such that the value the charity receives for the vehicle is what you get to deduct, rather than some 'estimate'.
For a vehicle such as Barry's Honda, that's the path I'd take. For these things, there's way to much chance of downside to sell to anyone you'd like to have a relationship with. I mean, that's a ton of miles on almost any vehicle, ten years old.
And Barry, I agree with you. Lots of cash for the insurer to spend on that car in a crash repair scenario.
>I have a '97 CR-V too, with 165K on it. Last night, in a fit of insomnia, I went to Kelley (www.kbb.com) and checked it out. I was pretty amazed to see that my car is worth close to 5K in trade and more as a private party sale. Milege like yours is probably a dealbreaker though, despite the fact that Hondas retain their value well. At some point, the race is over and it doesn't owe you anything anymore. If it runs now, I'd wait 'til the next "push, pull or drag" sale at the dealer, and trade it toward something a tad newer.
That's my 2¢, but I'm the guy who owns five vehicles that traded together wouldn't buy a new Chevy. :-)
>The question is just how bad is the transmission and what is the book value of the car factoring in the mileage. It would be hard to sell it with a bad alternator so you probably need to get it fixed. Can you do it for less by buying a used alternator from a wrecker?
The insurance company obviously thought it was to their advantage to sink all that money into it rather than writing it off.
I have been told that junk yards are even offering more for junkers these days because of the price of steel.
>As others have pointed out, a good source online to get an idea of the market value for your used car is Kelley Blue Book - http://www.kbb.com. I just used it myself this week.
While there are choices, the question is which one is right for you. Between repairing and selling, selling for scrap, donating, or fixing and keeping, I'd only be comfortable doing two of those. Whatever you do, don't take it to Chesterfield Auto for cash. They don't pay squat!
I'd most likely donate it to one of the local charities, which I've done in the past. I believe in the end more good comes from this choice than the others. I'd also check into selling it for scrap at one of the local scrap yards, like the one off I-95 down by Philip Morris.
I think the car is at the point where it doesn't owe you a thing and beyond further investment. Also, I couldn't feel right about repairing and selling, even if I came out in the black after the cost to repair. I'm sure there's other parts beyond those you mentioned that are close to giving up the ghost too.
Ellis I went to Kelly Blue book too and was stunned at the values they posted.
The dealer my son bought his truck from told me I should have insisted my insurance company give me the money they were aobut to spend on the car. I hinted to them strongly that I thought they should toatal the car, but they said No. The dealer tells me I could ahve taken the money and either junked the car or just patched it up enough to pass Inspection (headlights). I could have put in an alsternator and a couple fo junk yard head lights for $800 and had $4000 in my pocket.
Now it seems stupid to give away or sell cheap a car that somebody just spent almost five grand on.
I am willing to spend $250 for an alternator, but not $1300 for a transmission and then whatever it costs to install it. I assume the engine is not far behind and that was $2800 at the junk yard. So it seems really stupid to spend $4100 for an engine and transmission and whatever it costs to install them on a ten year old car that I don't really need anymore.
>If someone uses Carfax on your vehicle, they will see the accident and it will be worth less than blue book. I think 10% less seems to be the "magic" number that is thrown about. I sign up for a month of carfax when I'm looking for a used car. I've been burned by poor repairs in the past and don't even bother to go look at vehicles that aren't clean on the carfax report. If it were me, I'd try a junkyard for a used alternator and then sell it cheap. There's more money in your pocket selling it for well under blue book than donating or even trading it at a "drag, drive, or push it" dealer event. I have a little experience as I purposely drove beaters for 10 yrs. to avoid personal property tax when I lived in VA. It was cheaper to have spare vehicles than to pay the PPT on one expensive one. Sounds like Ellis has a "collection" similar to what I had ;).