lawsuit re: condemnation of wood shop *LINK*
Clay C in Miami
>FYI --
Here is an article about a legal ruling over condemnation of a woodshop. Seem that the "city seized Mr. Kaiser's woodworking shop on Third Avenue in the Bronx to make room for [an] Urban Renewal project." He handed them the keys and walked away. He then claimed, as part of his condemnation loss as a tenant, the value of 132 woodworking machines, for a total of $525,000. The court said that the machines were set up in a particular way for workflow, and "the panel of five judges weighing Mr. Kaiser's case decided the machines would face "substantial depreciation in value if removed." "
Mr. Kaiser won the appeal and all the value of the machines, the city of Manhattan was offering $129,000. Hard to believe they were really ruling that the machines were valueless if moved, and I guess the city did actually get the machines for their money. "Still the court did decide that Mr. Kaiser should not be reimbursed for a tiny fraction of the items, including handheld tools, cinder blocks, or a custom door."
The city's lawyer did say "I don't think this decision would provide any type of road map for how the courts would compensate a tenant who was not a woodworking shop."
I guess I would have expected the compensation to be the amount it would cost to move all the machines and rearrange/retune them in their new home. And, it probably would indeed cost more to move cinder blocks than replace them, so I think he shoulda got those!
Mr. Kaiser has since retired to Florida, this could be to some extent a case of hard facts making bad law ...
Clay
NY Sun Article



