Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Cheap AFS - bad design

Posts

Cheap AFS - bad design

#1

Cheap AFS - bad design

Pat Evans

>My shop is very small with barely 8' headroom and I used to have to leave the shop and wait for the dust to settle after making too many cuts. My homemade AFS really helps and I can now continue working in relatively clean air. However, the floor fan I used, despite being rated at 6000 cfm, was not designed to be used with a filter. I happened to walk behind it the other day and noticed an unusual air distribution. I removed the filter and the normal air flow and distribution returned, and the fan speed increased at least threefold. No way I can add more efficient filters and still expect this fan to work.

Lesson learned. I'll be looking for an old furnace blower with sufficient horsepower to handle the filter.


img

Re: Cheap AFS - bad design

#2

Re: Cheap AFS - bad design

Jim Swank

>Air movement of a fan is normally given for use in free air. When you start restricting air flow, performance depends in large part on the design of the fan blade as much as the motor. Go with the furnace motor - it should solve your problem nicely.

For more info than you really want google "fan curves".

Re: Cheap AFS - bad design

#3

You're not the first.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>You're probably not the first to make that mistake.... but you're probably the first to admit it.... publicly.

Good for you, your selfless honesty is sure to help someone else down the road.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Cheap AFS - bad design

#4

Re: You're not the first.....

Pat Evans

>Thanks Mark. There may not be anyone else out there who makes the same mistakes I do, but just in case, I hope they can learn from mine. All is not bad with my AFS. I really like the portability. I position it near whatever operation I'm performing and the air immediately around me stays clean and breathable even during the most dusty operations (eg. routing mdf). It sucks so much dust out of the air that I have to clean the filter every day. When I eventually build an AFS with sufficient power to handle multiple filters, it will be on a movable stand for portability.

I still get a fine layer of dust on everything in the shop, but no AFS is going to be 100% effective. I can observe dust migrating quickly toward the AFS, but I can also see that some of it bypasses the AFS and is picked up in the discharge air stream. That dust settles out before it can return to the fast moving air in front of the AFS.

Re: Cheap AFS - bad design

#5

Re: Cheap AFS - bad design

Bill Howatt

>Well, I must admit it is pretty!

You can help the situation by using more filters. The unit I made has the furnace fan inside and I have 4 of the 6 sides containing filters. Since the squirrel-cage fan has plenty of oomph having a larger filter area helps keep the fine dust from being drawn through the filter by brute force since the pressure drop across the filter is less due to the increased air-flow.

I also stacked my filters. In each opening, I have a high-class Filtrete closes to the fan, followed by a furnace filter that looks similar to cloth (about $4-5) and on the outside I have a regular furnace fiber-glass filter. I spray the outside filters with cooking oil to increase their effectiveness. You can do the second filter too but very sparingly!

Depending on usage which determines how much dust gets caked on the outer filter, I vacuum the crude off and respray it. I change it and the second filter from time to time. So far the Filtrete expensive filters are looking good.

Talk to heating contractors about surplus fans. Nice ones IMO are the electric furnace ones which are beltless and multiple speeds. These fans are used on other furnaces too but you may find electric furnaces being changed for gas. Don't go nuts on multiple speed furnace fans since the rpms aren't all that different. I just use the fastest and the slowest 2 speeds.

Good project, worth the time.

Bill