Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Sawing and drying beech

Posts

Sawing and drying beech

#1

Sawing and drying beech

Paul in NJ

>I know this is the power tool board but I thought some of you might have experience with beech. I might have the opportunity to have some beech custom sawn for wooden plane stock. Anyone have suggestions on how to cut for optimum yield? I am thinking of 5/4 and 8/4 quarter sawn with some 16/4 either quarter or completetly flat sawn (re-saw later to quarter). I need true quarter sawn stock to properly build planes. I understand beech may twist and cup a lot when drying. Is there an optimum length for drying efficiently and minimizing loss to end checks? Most of my planes will be 12" or less in length with a few up to 30" or so. I plan to coat the ends, sticker, and cover the pile for air drying.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#2

some thoughts

bill tindal, E.TN

>Anyone have suggestions on how to cut for optimum yield?.... I don't understand this question.

I am thinking of 5/4 and 8/4 quarter sawn with some 16/4 either quarter or completetly flat sawn (re-saw later to quarter). ....you had better discuss sawing with who ever is going to saw it. You may find that you don't have the option to saw all these options. I don't know what can be done on these small band mills, but you aren't going to be able to get most of a log mostly flat or quarter sawn on a circle saw mill. If you can't live with rift cut lumber you have a looming problem. If the log is big you can get a lot of rift cut from a log with one quartered cut from the log center, plus some flat sawn boards from squaring up the log so it will sit on the carriage securely. .

I need true quarter sawn stock to properly build planes. ... I don't agree with this statement. I don't even agree that beech is essential, or desirable unless your goal is to replicate antique planes.

I understand beech may twist and cup a lot when drying.... You got that right, but the problem is vastly less if indeed you can get quartered lumber with no knots.

Is there an optimum length for drying efficiently and minimizing loss to end checks? Yes, as long as possible, results in fewer ends to split. But end checking is a ove-rated concern on this Forum. I don't ever worry with it. But you need to dry your pile slow and uniformly. cover the pile, weight it down and provide for good air circulation and don't let the sun bake it.

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#3

Re: some thoughts

Paul in NJ

>Hi Bill,

Thanks for responding.

"I need true quarter sawn stock to properly build planes". ... "I don't agree with this statement. I don't even agree that beech is essential, or desirable unless your goal is to replicate antique planes".

I enjoy making tools and plan to replicate traditional planes. I like using vintage ones but can't find some profiles or planes bedded at a steep enough angle. I think quarter sawn is essential for these planes to work properly through the seasonal humidity swings. I agree other woods can be excellent for planes but feel beech has some advantages and after all was the choice for a long period. I like using hand tools on beech: it has a very consistent grain, not to hard, works smoothly, and is fairly durable. Plane makers Clark and Williams have an article on their website that is very interesting on why beech is a good choice for planes.

I know some woods are more difficult to dry than others are and was looking for some tips. Thanks for your thoughts.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#4

Re: some thoughts *LINK*

Keith Newton

>Paul, You may want to post your question over on the woodweb sawing and drying site. There may be some things that those guys know that can really help. Some white woods like beech and maple can have some tricks that you might need to know, like cutting asap after falling, and best in cold weather, and go straight to the kiln.

The second link is in the knowledge base, and is a list of earlier discussions on QS. I hope your trees are larger than ~3' otherwise, I personally don't think the yield is worth the effort, but then my mill is all manual.

If you don't already know a sawyer, you can find a link there for that also.


http://www.woodweb.com/cgi-bin/search/search.cgi

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#5

I've always suspected...

John in New Mexico

>that beech was traditionally used because its less useful for other purposes such as furniture and shipbuilding. I've read the Clark and Williams article but still don't see any great advantage to beech over a number of other hardwoods. From a traditional point of view though, by all means use it.

John

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#6

finding the beech and a quartered question

bill tindal, E.TN

>Imagine finding a 3' beech that wasn't hollow and had grain straight enough to yield quarter sawn lumber over any length. I spend a lot of time in the woods and I don't see them.

Sounds like you have a mill and I have a question. Question- I have seen diagrams of how a whole log would be quarter sawn(in theory) but I don't see how the log could ever be held on any carriage I have seen. I have had logs "quarter sawn", but in fact we split the log down the center, lay the flat side on the carriage and slab this cant. The center cuts are quartered and the rest more of less rift. It works for what I need because I am really looking for rift cuts. But if someone really wanted only quartered how would you get it in other than the center cuts on a typical carriage?

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#7

some more thoughts

bill tindal, E.TN

>You may know about what you are doing way more than I, and if so, ignore the rest.

It will be easy sawing a small fraction of true quartered beech (not rift) from a log if it is big enough and clear enough, both problems with beech that grows in North America. Big and clear is not such a problem with European beech, which is why I believe planes (English tradition) were made of beech rather than something else. In my experience you will get one quartered 4' plank from the center of each log. The rest will be rift or some combination of rift and flat.

However, beech is cheap. In fact there is usually no market for it and it gets left in the woods. So you can buy trees for firewood prices. Before I decided that beech was no better than most any other wood for planes, and that rift cuts were just as good as quartered, I laid in a stock of 4" quartered beech very easily. I cut some fair sized beech trees. Blocked the lower trunk into 24" sections and then with the chain saw sawed a 4" plank out of the heart of each section, yielding a 4" perfectly quartered plank. The rest went to firewood, which I needed. In a couple of hours I had more beech than I would ever practically use to make planes for just myself. The 4" planks were easy to dry, if in general you know how to dry lumber,with no end splitting. The tree center (pith) shattered, as it always will, but I was left with lumber on each side that was big enough for plane bodies.

I have heard that N. American plane makers boiled their beech. I have no idea if this is true, but it makes sense. Boiling will be like steaming and it will tame beech's propensity to dry with tension.

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#8

Thanks all!

Paul in NJ

>

Re: Sawing and drying beech

#9

I've seen them too

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Apparently it is possible, but most sawyers will charge you a lot more to do. I think it's pretty labor intensive and without a fully hyrdaulic saw physically demanding as well. I seem to recall seeing one sawyers website that advertised it. If I ever see it again, I'll send you the link.