Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Posts

Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#1

Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I'm close to taking the plunge on a bandsaw (a tool I don't own yet). As I don't want to buy another one any time soon, I'm thinking of going straight to a 17/18" model. I would like to use a bandsaw for resawing, veneering, making boards from small logs, curve work, plus all the normal bandsaw types of things. I've had some people ask me if I need to go that big on the machine, and wouldn't a 14" model be fine. I think the extra capacity and larger motors are the key for good resawing and veneering.

Probably the wrong group to ask, but is there any reason not to buy a larger model? I'm looking at models at about the $1000 dollar range, and Grizzley is towards the top of my list (since I can drive to their showroom and pick up the machine myself). I can't take a really powerful saw because I don't have the power for 3 phase hookups.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#2

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Dennis Yoder

>The larger capacity is very nice and needed if you resaw much. Woodcraft had the Ricon on sale for $999 last time I was in there.

I have the 14 with riser and wish for the extra features of the 17-18 models. Dennis Y

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#3

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Kris Lasure

>I bought a Delta 14 just a couple of years ago and I'm already starting to look at bigger saws just for the simple fact of resawing larger pieces for veneer. I thought about a riser for mine, but I already own 4-5 nice blades for the 14 and don't really want to buy all new blades. If I buy a bigger saw, I thought about keeping the 14 with a 1/4" blade for finer work and having the other for resaw and tougher jobs.

Although I'd have to break it to the wife that having two bandsaws is necessary! That might be a tough sale all it's own.

Anyhow, I would recommend the 17/18 for your intended use.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#4

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Curt Harms

>Hi Stephen

I thought about the Grizzly 0513 or 0513X but didn't think I needed quite that much capacity and didn't look forward to getting 350 lbs. down into a basement shop, and more importantly, back up. I decided on the Rikon 10-325. It had some teething pains (had to replace the motor) but so far so good. The only shortcoming I can imagine would be the 1.5 h.p. motor. I've resawn 8+" white oak with no problem at all. I live near Doylestown if You want to test drive it.

Curt

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#5

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Johanna

>IMHO, the only reason to buy a 14" is lack of funds or only working on small things.

I just bought the Steel City 18" and really like it -- especially the tension release lever! I sold my Jet 14" that I had had for about 12 years. It went to a very good home.

Johanna

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#6

Ellis Walentine

If you can only have one bandsaw...

Ellis Walentine

>... for the needs you listed, I would definitely be looking at something bigger than 14". Also, don't worry about your lack of 3� power; unless you are looking at old machines or large new ones that require 5hp or more, all the motors on the models you'll be looking at will be 1φ. For a saw of 16" or greater capacity, I'd recommend either a 2hp or 3hp motor.

If it were my choice, I'd get the big saw now and then keep your eyes open for something smaller -- maybe a 14" -- as a second saw. That way you don't have to change blades every time you want to switch from resaw to scrolling mode.

Ellis

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#7

More than just resaw capacity

wilbur

>There are two nonobvious things a larger bandsaw will get you besides increased resaw capacity.

1. Increased throat capacity, allowing you more flexibility if you decide to do a crosscut on your bandsaw.

2. The larger diameter wheel means that the bandsaw blade does not have to curve as much as it wraps around the wheel. This means that you can use a wider and thicker blade, which leads to better resawing, all other things being equal. If you have only done resawing with a 1/2" blade, wait till you try it on a 3/4" blade.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#8

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Barry Irby

>I agree with everything said. I have a 14" Delta. By the time I added the riser block, the tension release lever, better guides, and other stuff I can't even remember, it may have been cheaper to buy a big saw. If I understand it correctly, you can put a tiny blade on a big saw and do anything a little saw can do, but there are things a little saw just can't do.

If money were no object, first, my shop would be bigger and I would have two bandsaws, one let up for ripping and resawing and the other set up for curves. It takes between ten minutes and half an hour to switch back and forth.

If I were buying a bigger saw I would shop more for quality and features than price. If you over pay by a few hundred, you have a lifetime tool and you are out a few hundred. If you buy the cheapest one out there, you may end up with crap and waste the entire amount. Go ahead, get a good one you are worth it.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#9

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Pat Evans

>I just bought the Jet 3hp 18" bandsaw to replace my ancient 12" Delta. I've only made a few small cuts so far, but it waltzed thru 8/4 walnut like a knife thru hot butter. It's on sale at WoodingWorking Shop, plus Jet is offering a $100 rebate. I did have a problem with the table not being flat, but a new one is supposed to be on the way.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#10

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Doug Ball

>I really like the Rikon 18", available through Woodcraft. It comes with a blade tension release lever, nice bearing guides, dual dust hookups, nicely balanced cast iron wheels. Blade changes take only 60-90 sec , due to good enclosure design. The only thing really lacking in it is a high quality fence. Since most users make their own tall fences for resawing, I don't consder that a deal breaker. It's a strong contender in your price range.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#11

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Brian

>I don't think Rikon and Grizzly belong in the same sentence. I have a Grizzly (14" 3/4 hp) and got what I paid for. I lust for the Rikon and if you can afford the $999 go for it.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#12

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

James Dillon in MD

>Stephen,

I've had my 14 inch Delta for about 10 years now and it has been great especially when just beginning and not knowing if I would continue with woodworking as a hobby. But, if I was buying one today, had the money and the room, I would look at the bigger models. There is a much better selection now than back then with better features, especially dust collection - the bugaboo of bandsaws. If I really had the room, then having two bandsaws makes sense - at least to me. My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#13

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>I have the Delta 14" that I recently added the riser to. It meets my needs, although I think if I were to be buying a bandsaw now, I'd look at an 18" model. I live near Curt, so if you want to see and try out both and compare, you might be able to do that all in one trip down. Q'town is only about 30 or 40 minutes from here.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#14

Plus I'd get to see that nice new shop

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I remember you saying you were close by. I used to have family over in Reigelsville, so I can usually find my way around over there. I wouldn't mind a trip sometime, maybe to both shops. I love hands on to see how the tools really work. If I recall, you have some massive old iron in the form of a jointer too.

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#15

Thanks for the responses!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Wow, just a lot of good information here. I figured I would continue down the 17-18" model path, but now I have some new things to consider - mainly around that Rikon.

I really am looking for a tool I'm not going to replace for a good long while, so a big machine really fits the bill. I'd also really like to try using a bandsaw for ripping instead of my table saw (regardless of how safe I am, it never "feels" real safe)

Hopefully you'll see a "new tool post" from sometime in the near future. I'll have to make space in the shop first!

Re: Bandsaws - 14 vs 17/18 inch models

#16

Massive Old Iron--Indeed!

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>That would be "Frank"--16" jointer. By all means, come visit us. Just give a holler. Or email would do the trick.