Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

Posts

Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#1

Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

Mike Fitterling

>Hi All. As I mentioned in Woodworkers Weekend Accomplishments, I delivered doors and drawer fronts to my friend for his kitchen over the weekend. He called me today and said that they seem to have a "curve" where they join each other. It is hard to explain so I am posting a couple pics. The first below is how the doors/faces were cut. The idea is that there would be a continuous board and grain running from the floor up to the ten foot top of the cabinets (We have a strategy for dealing with the cross grain situation on the drawer fronts). In the pic the finer vertical lines in the wood "field" represent the glue lines. The thicker line represents the sides of the doors/faces and the divisions between each door/face. The white horizontal and vertical bars represent pulls.


img

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#2

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

Mike Fitterling

>And here is a pic showing, greatly exagerrated, what my friend observed. We have not come up with a plausible explanation, at least one that panned out. I thought perhaps the face of my fence was slightly curved, but that upon testing was proven not to be so. Even so, if the cuts were off, because the pieces were all cut out of one (glued up) board, the cuts should complement each other. If this was cross grain I would suspect it was simply warping, but the distortion is with the long grain. As I said, this is exagerrated, and we think we can deal with fixing it, but we are scratching our heads figuring out what could have happened. By the way, all this was from kiln dried black walnut, usually a very stable wood, and which had been stored in a reasonably humidity comtrolled environment (we have been maintaining 55% rh to match Ray's house where they went, to minimize movement issues). Finish is two coats dewaxed shellac, three coats Deft Lacquer. Any ideas?


img

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#3

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>I Dunno Mike,

You did check everything for square prior to assembly. If you had a problem initially, you would have surely seen it in a dry fit. If you are like me, I fuss with a couple dry fits. I wonder if you or your friend have checked the assembly with a straight edge/square to verify the perceived curves. I am thinking there may be some optical illusion messing with your minds. Have you, yourself, seen the assembly?

George

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#4

Did you use an edge sander on the ends?

Mike in Paradise

>If so I would look there.

What tool were the ends cut and or trimmed on?

Very Strange!(insert twilight zone music here)

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#5

Ellis Walentine

No idea

Ellis Walentine

>You didn't quite mention it but I read that all the fronts are solid wood, right? With the grain running vertically? If so, longitudinal shrinkage should be negligible, but uniform in any event. The only thing that could change the rate would be something on the back of the wood that is keeping moisture from transpiring into or out of the wood. Even so, It makes no sense to me.

Ray doesn't sleep-walk with a block plane, does he?

No help here,

Ellis Walentine

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#6

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

Mike Fitterling

>Ray used a straight edge and told me about it. He is about 40 miles away in Brandon, so I have not seen it myself. I am not doing the install, just the construction. There should be about an even 1/32" between everything and Ray said that the gap is correct at each side but as you get to the middle the gap increases to as much as 1/8".

Everything was cut on the tablesaw on my big sled or against the fence, and a few cuts were made on the radial arm saw in the pregluing stages when the pieces were narrow enough to crosscut on that (I did keep checking alignment, etc.). I did not use any sander to smooth the edges.

Even though everything is "one board" obviously I previously crosscut the individual planks then glued each to it partner in sequence. But, when gluing these up I could reference the alignment because I would make sure the ends of each piece were lined up perfectly (I took great pains to do this). If they had slipped during glueup I would have probably had a kind of stairstep situation, but Ray says it is a really smooth curve.

The only thing I can think of was they had to be sprayed outside; perhaps some moisture crept in somewhere during that process, but when it was dry enough outside to spray we generally had close to the 55% rh. although temps were pretty low at times, down in the upper 50s I guess.

Hmmmmm? Scratching my head.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#7

Re: No idea

Mike Fitterling

>Haha! That's funny! It MUST be Ray's fault! lol

Yes, that is correct; the grain runs vertically thorugh all the pieces.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#8

Here's a Pic of How I Did the Glueup

Mike Fitterling

>A typical section, representing one "column" of cabinets. The individual pieces were cut on the RAS with a stop so they are perfectly the same lengths. Final trimming of the ragged ends only was done on the tablesaw.


img

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#9

Nope

Mike Fitterling

>Only trimmed each end and widths on tablesaw. All the crosscutting was done using stops and on the radial arms saw before glueup.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#10

Re: Optical illusion?

David Hay @ Denver

>Could it simply be an optical illusion, due to the way the grain happens to run? Or if you put a straightedge on the boards, are they actually curved?

David

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#11

Re: Optical illusion?

Mike Fitterling

>David, that's what I'm told; a straightedge across the edge reveals a gap in the middle.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#12

My Drawing might be a Bit Off . . .

Mike Fitterling

>. . .now that I think about it and look back over the drawing. Ray said this was happening to the drawer fronts; he did not say anything about the same problem with the doors. Hmmmm.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#13

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

Rich S

>Are you certain your friend's straight edge is really straight?...if there is 1/32 on each end and 1/8 in the middle you would definately see this with your eye and could feel it with your finger as you run it along the gap...very perplexing...seems it would not be something you could have missed in assembly...

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#14

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

Rich S

>Another question would be to check to see if the doors are actually "square'...if not it could be that during assembly the exterior edges were lined up wih the cabinet body for the doors..essentially there is some tilt to the door...one would think this would mean the vertical center line gap would be off as well, but if the door wasn't "square" it may not shw up there....but looking at your photos and the cabinet makers trianlges you used for layout I have confidence in your skills and would doubt you made an error in "square"..instead that is something I would screw up...

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#15

Thanks for the vote of confidence.

Mike Fitterling

>I am not feeling it right now. Just got back in from the shop from re-making a couple more boxes that the "designer" decided to change after the installation of the wall cabs (He decided to replace one original box with two half the size--ugh!). I was making a lot of stupid mistakes, so I guess this problem is bothering me more than I think it is. I got them put together anyway. Time to take a break before I cut something off. There's always tomorrow.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#16

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

DB

>If the gap between the 2 pairs of doors were not even then I would have to say that the shelf where the 2 pairs of doors meet was cut just a little short. That would bow the sides in a little thus giving a larger gap in the center, also if the hinges were not properly adjusted this will give the same effect.

If it were my project I would go there with my trusty straight edge and square and check each door for straightness and squareness.

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#17

Re: My Drawing might be a Bit Off . . .

Paul in NJ

>Perhaps there is a little cupping or bowing across the grain of the drawer fronts. That could give the illusion of a curved gap.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Strange Warping/Cut? Anyone Explain?

#18

I've Seen It with My Own Eyes

Mike Fitterling

>Ray came by to pick up those two cabinet boxes and brought one of the drawer faces with him. I laid it across my cast iron tablesaw table and sure enough, there is a small gap in the middle. I did not measure it tonight, but it looked to me like it may have been between 1/64" and 1/128" difference between the middle and the corners. Of course, when two drawer faces are placed together the difference is doubled. Not an unsurmoutable problem, but strange nonetheless.

Good night everyone. I'm pooped.