Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

Posts

OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#1

OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

Robert Hutchins

>I'm getting a sound from my primary hard drive that probably means it might be about to go. I am making a new backup to an external USB drive as I type - just to be sure. I have 2 other hd's in the system. The one thats making noise has the WinXP/Pro os and a lot of data.

First, can I just copy the os directory to another drive - changing the slave/master switches, of course, or do I have to do a fresh install? If so, are there any precautions/rules/gotchas? If I can't just copy the os directory to a different device, why not? I have tons of software that would have to be reinstalled if I have to do a fresh XP install. Prolly take a couple of days to get things back where they are now.

Second, what strategies do you guys use to avoid banging the heck out of just one of your drives? I'm thinking of buying the optimum size drive to hold just the os - since it gets hit most often, doesn't it? All of the drives that I have are over 200GB. That's a lot of eggs in those baskets. Wouldn't a small RAID 5 set up on an old system make more sense? What would a fellow have to do to make that happen? How much horsepower (RAM, CPU speed) would the RAID server need? What would the optimum size for HDs in a RAID be? Seems that 100's of GB per drive might be wasteful and that something on the order of 80GB per hd would be cheaper. Would it be feasible to share the RAID with HL's system over a wireless network - too slow, any other reasons not to do it (assuming a WPA-secured setup)?

Got any more tricks up your sleeves? Would really like to hear from you gurus.

TIA

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#2

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

Chuck W

>What I would do is make an "image' of the drive. Just copying over the OS installation does not work. There are programs available from maxtor and others that will let you make the image of your current installation. The OS and applications can always be reinstalled but your personal files should be backed up.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#3

What you need

Ron in Drums PA

>What you need is Norton's Ghost.

You can make a complete image of your hard drive and copy it to a new hard drive.

Some programs will complain and you may have to reactivate them.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#4

Thanks Chuck and Ron

Robert Hutchins

>Do either of you have a recommendation for freeware cloning utilities? I googled and found a plethora of things. I don't have Norton Ghost - and don't really like or trust Symantec based on earlier versions of their products. Creating a clone sounds like something that I want to do as carefully as possible.

Thanks again for the help.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#5

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

John McGaw

>> First, can I just copy the os directory to another drive - changing the slave/master switches, of course, or do I have to do a fresh install?

You can copy the OS but it simply won't work that way -- there are other things necessary to make a drive bootable. There are programs, paid and free, which allow you to make an exact drive image with will be bootable and will eliminate the need to re-install applications. Since you seem to have many applications installed the effort of doing an image would seem to be worthwhile.

>Second, what strategies do you guys use to avoid banging the heck out of just one of your drives? I'm thinking of buying the optimum size drive to hold just the os - since it gets hit most often, doesn't it?

The OS drive does see more activity and a lot of that is access to the swap file. But personally I don't take any special precautions. The computer I'm typing on now has a single 300gB SATA drive in it partitioned as C: (primarily for programs), D: (primarily for data) and a tiny E: (holds only install and update information).

My big system in the basement has five 400gB drives in it and is virtually all data.

>Wouldn't a small RAID 5 set up on an old system make more sense? What would a fellow have to do to make that happen? How much horsepower (RAM, CPU speed) would the RAID server need? What would the optimum size for HDs in a RAID be?

RIAD 5 if fine but most home users will find a RAID 1 (mirrored) arrangement easier to deal with. Depending on the disk controller details very little CPU power may be required. As for optimum size, my opinion is "bigger is better" (witness the 2tB in my basement "server"). YMMV and only you know how much storage you need. Drive prices vary wildly and depends on how sharp your hunting instincts are. I routinely buy 400gB Seagate PATA drives with 5-year warranty for < $110. Sometimes I see SATA of the same capacity for only slightly more.

>Would it be feasible to share the RAID with HL's system over a wireless network - too slow, any other reasons not to do it (assuming a WPA-secured setup)?

Sure you can share the data. If you are working with "live" data across a slow network then it might be too painfully slow to work with for movie editing or similar tasks (I find by gigabit network too slow sometimes) but in that case, copying the work file over, edit and manipulate to your heart's content, and then copy it back. That way the actual brain time involved seems much smaller.

>Got any more tricks up your sleeves? Would really like to hear from you gurus.

Tricks? No only common sense ideas like backing up irreplaceable data frequently and keeping a copy off site in case of disaster. I keep my backups on three 200gB USB drives which rotate into and out of my bank's vault. BTW these drives were very cheap since they were left over after they were replaced by 400gB units -- add three cheap enclosures and go!

Oh, and to make your drives last as long as possible, pay attention to their cooling. A modern drive can work at extreme temperatures but will last far longer if kept near body temperature by good air flow.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#6

Thanks, John!

Robert Hutchins

>I'm using Seagate and Maxtor SATA drives. I had the internal components of my Dell P4 moved to an after-market tower enclosure specifically because adding a hard drive drove the operating temps up in the original Dell case. As soon as I discovered the addditional heat - not long after adding the second drive, I got the new tower. There are 5 different fans in it, each with its sensor on different parts of the cabinet. Don't know what else I might do to avoid heat.

I would really appreciate a recommendation on shareware hd imaging software.

Do you think an old PII that has about 750MB RAM with about a 400MHz processor would support a RAID5 setup? It would do my el cheapo skinflint packrat heart good to put it to use. 7 or 8 200GB drives = 1+TB, even allowing for the overhead that RAID takes, and would allow non-stop swap outs.

I have all my data backed up. The most I can lose is a week's worth based on scheduled backups; however, if I've had a very productive session or acquired a lot of data on any given day, I'll force an interim backup. This is only a personal machine with no business related or income producing data on it.

Thanks again for your input.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#7

Adaptec

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I use Norton Ghost. But let's face it.... a machine with Microsoft Windows that's been in use for a while (programms installed/removed,etc) probably needs a fresh install anyways. Windows is just like that.

I don't suggest using software RAID. It's built into Windows but there is a CPU overhead. You can try it but I'll predict you won't like it. If you do I suggest 3 drives, one for the OS and two mirrored with RAID-1. The OS on software mirrored virtual drives tends to slow things down. Definitely don't mirror the swap folder if you use software mirroring.

Adpatec sells RAID-1 SATA controllers for under $100. A SATA RAID-1 controller and two SATA drives will work much better than software RAID. I think they also sell RAID controllers for ATA drives, but I've never bothered with those.

In fact if you machine is fairly new and has SATA drives, it's quite possible you have built in hardware level RAID-1 mirroring if you get another drive and turn it on.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#8

Re: Thanks Chuck and Ron

Chuck W

>The software you need depends on the drive you have. Maxtor, Seagate and Western Digital all have some kind of cloning, drive preparation software available. I have used MaxBlast with pretty good results. Its wort it to try and clone your current drive just to save time on software reloading. If it is clunking badly then immediately back up all personal data/files/etc to another drive such as a slave drive alreasy connected.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#9

Re: Thanks, John!

John McGaw

>I would only suggest RAID-5 be implemented in hardware -- never in software even if the OS claims to support it. If you are intent on using old mismatched drives for RAID it is going to be an iffy situation. Most RAID calculations depend on having drives at least match in capacity. And if you are seeding to use PATA drives finding a controller any more that doesn't do SATA only might prove to be difficult. Promise Technologies used to sell a RAID-5 PATA controller that well thought of but I haven't looked for one for a while. Using hardware to do the RAID grunt work means that almost any sort of semi-competent computer could be used.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#10

Thanks, Mark

Robert Hutchins

>The only RAID I would even entertain is 5, on a separate server box. And, before I do that I'll have to find 5 or 6 identical, very inexpensive drives and a controller. The notion is more a reaction to any impending problems with my primary HD. All is still well, I just get the occasional clanking and grinding and was thinking ahead of the disaster curve for once - maybe.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#11

Re: Thanks Chuck and Ron

Ron in Drums PA

>Ghost is the ONLY Norton software I would ever recommend. The older the version the better. Ghost 2002 and 2003 being the best and Ghost 10 works well too. If you have an old Norton Systemworks CD, there is a chance Ghost is on there. I would be nervous trying some of the freebies

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#12

Why?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I'm not sure why you would consider moving your data off your PC and onto the server. IF you are the only one using it, the drawbacks outweigh the benefits. There are good resons to put it on a seperate box, but remember if DSL is 1.5 and Wireless is 55 and old ethernet is 100 and new Gigabit ethernet is 1000... well even 1000 is far slower that the bus speed between your CPU and internal hard drives.

I think you asked about your PIII, sure your P-III machine with a hardware RAID controller can certainly handle RAID-1 and/or RAID-5 (I recommend RAID-1 over RAID-5 in your case for many reasons) becaue your bottleneck will be the network speed between the machines.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#13

Re: Thanks Chuck and Ron

Tom

>Search for Hirens boot cd. It's free. I have version 8.2 I think. It will make images with several programs, including Symantec's products and Acronis True Image. Make an image with each, then try to restore them. If one doesn't work, try the other. I've had no problems imaging with either one, and restoring. The boot cd has a plethora of other very useful utilities too.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#14

Re: Thanks Chuck and Ron

Robert Hutchins

>Thanks, Tom!

Googling gets me to a site for this software but no download capability. I found another site that let be download it, but when unzipped (HD or CD, doesn't matter) all I get is a read.me file, a shortcut (back to the site I downloaded from) and a file with an .iso extension. What software reads an iso extension?

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#15

Re: Thanks Chuck and Ron

Dan Donaldson

>An iso is an image. Normally what you do is burn that image to a cd or dvd and it then becomes either a boot or data disk. Most of the cd/dvd burning programs will handle iso files.

Re: OT: Calling All PC Gurus - Hard Drive Question

#16

Thanks, Dan!

Robert Hutchins

>Some days my head stays in a dark place. I shoulda known it's the extension for an image file. Coulda looked it up too. Woulda burned it before now.

Thanks for giving me the info. It's burning as I type this. Guess I'll have me a Hiren's bootable CD in a little bit.

Thanks again.