Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Near miss

Posts

Near miss

#1

Near miss

Doug Ball

>Earlier today, I had one of the more frightening moments of recognition in my woodworking life. I was table routing some 4" x 1/2" walnut boards for a panelling project, using a whiteside rabetting bit in a PK 890 series router. I was taking the initial shallow (1/8") pass, when I noticed the cut rapidly converting to full-thickness. I pulled the piece away and saw that the rabetting bit had risen, and was now protruding an alarming distance above the table. I killed the power and dashed to the side, with images of an imminent flying bit in my mind. The bit did stay in the collet, although I found that I could now move it easily with finger pressure (!).

In trying to reconstruct the near miss, the only potential causes I could come up with were: 1) failing to insert the bit fully into the collet; or 2) dialing up the speed to 21K rpm, when 12K or so might have been more appropriate; or 3) failing to tighten the collet adequately. Another possible contributing factor was leaving the bit in the router from the weekend before, and not re-checking the state of things. I don't think I'll do that again. The PK 890 uses a single-wrench type collet that seems to work well; I'm chalking this up to user error rather than a mechanical issue.

Parenthetically, I find that my mishaps occur when I assume the mindset of a production worker rather than a one-off craftsman. I've got to remember not to act like a human machine! Any additional thoughts welcomed...

Re: Near miss

#2

Re: Near miss

Carol from AZ

>Another thing to look at, and often ignored until something like this happens.

The collet, the socket it sits in, and the router bit shamp must be pristine clean. Pitch or gum anywhere here compromises the friction fit of the collet to hold the bit.

Onece had a student.....never mind. The bit came out and got him in the leg.

Glad you weren't hurt.

Re: Near miss

#3

Re: Near miss

Keith Newton

>Doug, You probably already know this, but I think the most common reason for a router bit to loosen especially on a table router, is for the bit to be bottomed out in the collet before the collet can get all of the way down in the taper.

Re: Near miss

#4

Re: Near miss

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Well Doug,

That same thing happened to me a couple times when I was less experienced. Its easy to slip up and let the bit slip out. Mine never rocketed around the room either. So I suppose we were both in luck. Incidents such as yours and mine serve us well so long as we remember "how NOT to do it". I'm glad you were unhurt.

George

Re: Near miss

#5

Probably option 2) in all seriousness

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Doug

It's probably 2), running the bit overspeed.

This creates vibration and centrifugal forces way above the design load of both the bit and the router. Vibration is exascerbated by the speed at which the bit is hitting the wood.

Just check that all is clean, leave the bottom of the router bit shank about 1/8" clear of the bottom of the collet and try again at mfg recommended speeds.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Near miss

#6

Oops, response to wrong person . . . Sorry George

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: Near miss

#7

Get some o-rings

Jesse in New Mexico

>Forgot where I heard this tip, but I use it and love it. To keep the bit from bottoming out, go to the hardware store and buy a handful of 1/4 inch and 1/2 inch o-rings. They are cheap.

Put the o-ring on your bit about where you want the collet to end and slip the bit into the collet. The o-ring will hold the bit in position while you tighten th collet. Eventually, the o-rings will wear out, but they don't cost much.

Re: Near miss

#8

Re: Get some o-rings

Carol from AZ

>Minor course correction, Jesse.

If you put the o-ring on the bit it won't fit into the collet. The suggestion is to place the o-ring in the bottom of the socket so the bit bottoms on it. The the tightening process compresses the o-ring and allows for a better grip in the bit.

That is one outlook. I personaly do not concur with it. Routing heats up things, including the bit. Heat is not good for rubber, causing it to deteriorate, contaminating the socket/collet mating. My story and I am sticking with it.

To keep the bit from protruding beyond the end of the collet, I simply insert the bit in the collet until is is flush, then using an extrafine Sharpie, draw around the shank of the bit. After I have tightened things up, I KNOW how far into the collet my bit is (or isn't!).

Re: Near miss

#9

Re: Near miss

Doug Ball

>Thanks for all the responses and concern. I shared the anecdote because I think that it could happen easily to others. I'm fairly sure the bit wasn't bottomed out. I appreciate the reminders about keeping the collet absolutely clean. The router-bit combination had performed normally for about three dozen passes a week ago at a moderate speed setting. I think switching to max speed, and maybe an initial sub-optimal tightening job were jointly responsible.

Cheers,

Doug

Re: Near miss

#10

Re: Near miss ? ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>I love this phrase. Think about it: "near miss". Sounds like a "hit" to me.

News flash: A plane had a near miss today. Should equate to a collision.

Oh, the English language........

By the way, normal O-rings are Buna rubber and good to around 300F. If your router gets that hot in that area, you have another problem. Putting the O-ring at the bottom of the chuck won't account for a short shanked bit. Up close to the radius transitioning between the cutter and shank is best.

Re: Near miss

#11

Re: Near miss

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>one more possibility is saw dust. If you ever store your router bottom side up, or have it mounted in a router table saw dust can settle in the bottom of the hole where the bit goes. at a critical point enough sawdust will acumulate and will block the collet from being able to tighten up.

Robin Corell

Re: Near miss

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: Get some o-rings

Dale Lenz

>Got my o-rings at NAPA loooong time ago, maybe a better grade than hardware stores (??)they have not gone bad yet, cost 25 cent each, well over 10 years ago. My 1/2" shank rabbeting bit I just got done using 30 minutes ago has shipped lapped both side of 1100' of cottonwood some 8 years ago, Jasda(sp) bit. But, I agree with Carol I'd think something in the hole ain't clean. Had a Sears router with that problem back in the 80's. FWW had an article on that (cleaning router collets), late 80/early 90's and a pencil eraser seem to work the best on clean gunk out of the collet and the housing that houses the collet.

Re: Near miss

#13

Re: Near miss ? ?

Barry Irby

>Could a near miss be something that missed, but was close to a hit? Knowing that a bullet was fired somewhere in the world is of little concern to you, it missed by a wide margin. One that you felt go by your ear is a Near Miss.

A router bit nearly coming out to the collet is not a "hit" but nearly was. It missed, but it was closer to an accident than it should have been.

English does have a lot of phrases that are idiomatic and nonsensical. Like the guy in the turning club who told me I could build a gloss finish with Danish Oil, it would just take about 15 coats. So I dutifully wiped on a coat a day for about three weeks before I gave up. When I mentioned to him that it never worked for me, his answer was, Well I told you it ain�t never going to happen. I guess I might have gotten the message if he had said a �million� or a bazillion coats. What passes for communication surpasses understanding. Come to think of it, his name was English.

Re: Near miss

#14

Re: Near miss ? ?

Doug Ball

>For near misses,I also like the concept of "near-earth objects" or NEO's. Most encounters are just another near-miss; once every epoch though, a mass-extinction event!