Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

One for the car battery experts (OT)...

Posts

One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#1

One for the car battery experts (OT)...

John in New Mexico

>So the truck battery gave up the ghost recently, and I've been using the battery out of my flatbed temporarily. Yesterday I bought a new battery for the PU, now I'm wondering if its better to swap them back or not. The one out of the heavy truck is a 3 year old gel cell, the new one is a middle of the price range conventional battery. I'd like to keep the gel cell in the PU, as the flatbed is going to be sold in the next 6 months or so, and I won't get a chance to see how the new type of battery performs over several years. So the question is, has anyone used these new batteries for 5 years or so? Would it be really dumb to keep the 3 year old gel cell instead of a conventional battery I know will last about 4 years? The heavy truck has no corrosion on the terminals, though it doesn't get anywhere near the mileage of the PU. Anyone know if thats the result of the type of battery or just the low use (and thus low re-charging).

Thanks,

John

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#2

Battery sceince and marketing

bill tindal, E.TN

>Automotive batteries are designed different from golf cart batteries and this discussion relates only to automotive batteries. The source of this information comes from the R&D department of a local large battery manufacturing operation.

This factory uses identical components for all their automotive batteries. The only meaningful difference between their "cheap" battery and their premium battery is the length of the warranty. The long warranty on the premium battery is longer than they expect the battery to last. The details of the car's charging system and battery operating temperature have a big impact on battery life. All this would suggest being rid of the old battery. "Cold cranking power" is a meaningless measure of battery performance. The starter motor only uses a small fraction of this capability so more or less is meaningless.

I don't know about your corrosion question, but I think it is caused by sulfuric acid wicking out of the battery. It isn't anything I get excited about.

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#3

Re: Battery sceince and marketing

Sam

>I call BS on this one. Next time you're at NAPA....go over to the battery rack and pick up a 6024 in your left hand. Then pick up a 7524 in your right. You will notice a difference in weight...therefore a difference in the number of plates inside. More plates..better battery.

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#4

The only thing about the corrosion...

John in New Mexico

>is it makes me hate working on batteries. Holes in clothes, can smell it and taste it even all day, even when I'm being careful. I was wondering if anyone knew if the gelled electrolite wicked less or if the corrosion was a function of charging (truck w/o corrosion got about 2,000 miles last year).

Even if the gel cells have less of a corrosion problem, I don't think I'd find it worth twice the price! Maybe, just maybe, if it lasted twice as long too. The previous owner of the heavy truck put in the pricey gel battery, so I've got no financial or emotional attatchment to it, just looking for input on whether the marketing reputation is based on reality.

John

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#5

Re: Not necessarily

Dale Stansbery

>Are they rated the at same cranking Amps? They may be equal in quality, just more amps. I once read, and tend to believe that the main culprit to battery failure is that they short out when enough of the plates slough off and short the plates. Therefore the longeveity is proportional to the capacity to contain the crap before it starts covering the plates. I don't know if this applies to gel cells, maybe not.

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#6

exactly

bill tindal, E.TN

>this is what the battery company person told me too about how batteries fail.

More weight means more lead which means more capacity. But more capacity does not directly translate to longer life. Longer life depends on the construction of the plates and spacers and how effective this arrangement is in preventing shorts, which will eventually occur.

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#7

a guess

bill tindal, E.TN

>I don't see any reason that charging would correlate with corrosion, while I can imagine the gel battery (a configuration I don't know anything about) may wick less, or not at all. Coat the terminals with grease to minimize corrosion.

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#8

may be irrelevant but..

John @ Doraville

>...bought a Delco Voyager group 27 for my trolling motor in '92. I know it's a deep-cycle and not automotive but was a gel-cell. Lasted 12 years before refusing to take a charge. Last time I used it in '04 it still let me push the boat around most of the day.

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#9

Turns out... *LINK*

John in New Mexico

>The battery in question is not a gel cell, its a spiral AGM. Reduced terminal corrosion is one of the features of an AGM. Longer service life as well, but too many variables to really predict how much longer. Did find a very informative site for anyone with a bit of curiosity and some time to kill.

John


http://www.uuhome.de/william.darden/carfaq7.htm#type

Re: One for the car battery experts (OT)...

#10

Speaking of holes....

Tony - Memphis

>I bought a new Sears battery for my truck on the way home and they said to just drop off the old battery when I could (no core charge). The old battery had been leaking. When I dropped it off on the way to work, I was real careful with it. Couple of months later, I washed my nice company logo coat I bought, and it came out of the washer with white spots and holes. I guess the water and/or detergent reacted with the acid on the coat. I never realized there was anything on my jacket before I washed it. Bummer. Now its a nice warm work coat.

Tony