heating your workshop
David Barr
>Looking for ways to heat my work shop. Its 12' x 24' and insulated. Wife fusses about me using 3 space heaters (as she pays our utility bill). Any ideas?
thanks, David
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
heating your workshop
David Barr
>Looking for ways to heat my work shop. Its 12' x 24' and insulated. Wife fusses about me using 3 space heaters (as she pays our utility bill). Any ideas?
thanks, David
Re: heating your workshop
GarryVA
>David...I just built a 12 x 12 semi-insulated workshop. I installed a in the wall heat pump. However I just bought a EdenPure 1000 Quartx Infared Portable Heater to keep some heat while I'm not working in the shop. It keeps things toasty and mine's not insulated. There is a website to check the portable heater out. The in the wall heat pump works well
Re: heating your workshop
DB
>It really does not matter what type of heater you use. You will use the same amount of energy to heat the shop. To save money on heating use the fuel that has the lowest cost per BTU, taking into account the effientcy of the heating unit.
Taking the above into account a heat pump may be cheaper to run than electric heaters, but the instalation cost may be pretty high.
Re: heating your workshop
Bri in Mtl
>My shop is about that size. Heats pretty good with a 220V construction heater.
Freestanding kerosene
Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA
>Not the bullet type (those are way too noisy). I have a low unit that reflects the heat out the front and doesn't get hot on top. Takes a few hours but I can make the shop comfortable on a 20 deg day. Works great for weekends, but may get expensive to run every day. You do get some odors, as it is kerosene.
Re: heating your workshop
arw01
>It is true that electric heaters use the same energy for the BTU's they make, but it is also true that a ceramic and oil filled will retain some heat for a longer period of time.
When an air exposed element heater turns off, it's cold in seconds. When an oil filled heater turns off, the oil holds heat for a long time radiating it into the surounding room.
Personally I have a Glo-warm radiant unit that I used in the garage. My new shop still being worked on will have gas heated in-floor radiant heat. Currently I heat it with a 35,000 btu reddy heater from Lowes. It's a bit noisy, and runs me about $0.80 an hour to us it. I suspect when I get my radiant heat in I will spend maybe $60 a month in the coldest part of winter, but hope for less. That is figuring 2 therms a day.
Alan
Re: heating your workshop
Webster Stump
>Well, Ive experienced some problems with this issuewith my shop, and a few friends who asked me to help them. I'm own an HVAC company and here is what I have found best after I did the numbers. Electric heaters, like those from Modine, (which is what I have) seem to do best. As far as BTU count, the only thing that passes Electric when it comes to this is Fuel Oil. You will get more heat per KILOWATT of energy than any other fuel besides Fuel Oil. 3413 BTUH per kilowatt for those who want to know specifics. You will get more BTU per gallon of Fuel oil than any other heat around. Its the hottest, but also, one of the least effecient ways to deliver heat. Most, and when i say most i say 95% of fuel oil furnaces get about 80%, thats if you keep them tuned and serviced. most people dont, so i give it about 72%. There is one furnace out there, ADAMS is the name that claims to be 99% effecient. The bad thing with Fuel oil is 1. it get expensive to by, and two, IT STINKS! So......my recommendation for anyone is electric. There are two reasons for this. 1.Its a very dry heat, so it will help dry out your wood, not so much time waiting for wood to dry. 2. For energy efffeciecy and price, right now Electric heat is cheaper than any other fuel. If anyone wants to know the specifics, i can email them the numbers to show this. However, i have heard that electicity will be rise soon. Natural Gas and Propane, unless they are free, I wouldnt even consider. However if someone does, make sure to get a vented one. You lose a little bit of effeciency, but those ventless heaters, they put out way to much moisture, one of the many evils that haunt woodworkers. A friend of my didnt believe me on this and ended up with a pile of wood in his home after a poker table literally fell apart drying out Hope this helps someone.
Re: heating your workshop
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>Webster, I have to politely disagree with your figures as to cost of heating with Natural gas, oil or electric. At the current pricing in Indiana Electricity is around .07 KWH which calculates to $20.52 a Million Btu (at 100% efficiency. In Indiana the cost of natural gas is about 1.10 a Therm. I am using a 95% efficient gas furnace in my shop (direct vented intake and exhaust) which converts to $11.30 a million Btu. A rather neat conversion table is found at: http://www.pelletheat.org/3/residential/compareFuel.cfm This allows you to enter the efficiency of the unit you have or contemplate purchasing to determine the cost per million BTUs. I worked as an Engineer for about 40 years, but subcontracted installation of HVAC equipment as a second job for about 25 years. I agree with your assessment of oil, however my experience also suggests the efficiency of oil fired units does not remain high. Soot is generated in the firebox / burner areas (and chimney) and the efficiency drops as this accumulates. Possibly this has been corrected in the last few years since I installed or serviced any oil fired systems.
Re: heating your workshop
Webster Stump
>Larry,
Gas here in Ohio is getting pretty ridiculous, and so gas heating is not a very popular sudject. The Fuel oil Subject, well, unless your a farmer and get it for free, in my opinion isnt worth the headaches of dealing with. I just put three of them in and they are running about 81.2% Effecient. but you are certainly right, soot, dirty parts and lack of maintenance kills them. Most of the units I service are running about the 70% mark before i get done with them. I have a digital flue analyzer that gives me a ton of info, sometimes more than I need. I was wondering if you took into consideration the COP ( Coefficent Of Performance) of the gas furnace, versus the electric. I am certainly not say you are wrong, sounds like you have quite a bit more experience than I. I too am getting ready to be an Engineer, getting ready to graduate, but I have only been doing the HVAC for about 6 years now. None the less, i personally think i would still go with electric, the size, versatillity, ease of installation and life span of electric heaters has got me sold. However, i am going to check my supplier to find out my costs for energy are, just to see what i am paying. Thanks
Re: heating your workshop
Mike from Tn.
>I heat with wood. I have an Ashly stove with a steel grate not cast. I have a modest shop 24x40x10 and it takes me about an hour to warm up to 65or 70 degrees on the coldest days. Our winters are pretty mild here but the old bones are getting a little age on them. I generate enough scrap for kindling to last until about March. I have a semi ample supply of wood stacked up by Oct. and enough construction sites going on to simply ask for scraps of 2ft or smaller to keep the big stuff going. Most contractors are glad to have someone haul it off for them. I realize that every situation is different and that size and location will dictate what kind of heat you use. No matter what you use there are two key words to use- cheap and Safe. I use a radiator type oil heater in my paint room on nights below freezing. But using a open coil space heater or any type of open flame heater in a dust filled enviroment or when finishing is asking for trouble. Even with an enclosed wood burner I keep the dust and fumes under control. In a small shop with a Kerosun type of heater you have to remember about the CO2 also. I'm really being a hypocrite here as I've used everything I've dissed here but it was all I could afford or had on hand at the time. If I had to install a real heating system I would go with not the cheapest but the most eficiant central heat I could afford. Be safe and good luck
Re: heating your workshop
DB
>True oil filled and ceramics do hold the heat longer but they also take longer to heat up. You end up using the same amount of energy to maintain the desired temp for the same length of time.
Re: heating your workshop
Barry Irby
>Webster, You mentioned Electric being Dry Heat. Any vented heating system is dry heat. In an electric heater the coils get hot from resistance to the flow of the electricity and we blow air over them to warm it. In an oil furnace the heat exchange is heated by the fire and we blow air over it. The fumes and some of the heat go up the chimney. Same for a vented gas furnace or wood stove. As long as the unit is properly vented, NONE of the products of combustion enter the air space. None of them would contribute moisture to the air and all would be "dry" heat.
There are differences though. A vented hater takes air from the living space/shop and uses it for combustion. Air form out doors comes in to replace it. That air might be cold and it could be humid (for winter Air), but when it warms up, its Relative Humidity Goes down. That's why we think winter air is dry. So if you have a vented heater and it takes combustion air form the shop, you are ventilating the shop whether you meant to or not.
Some heaters draw their combustion air form out doors and would not exchange the air in the shop.
Unvented heaters are another story. When you burn a hydrocarbon fuel in air, one of the things you get is H2O (Water) in the form of steam. 18% of what comes out of it is moisture. I have seen people using a bunch of them to heat their houses and they have water drooling down the windows and mold in the closets.
I use an unvented gas heater in my shop for ten or fifteen minutes to knock off the chill and then use a small (1350) watt electric "barn" heater to maintain it.
Re: heating your workshop
David Barr
>If anyone wishes to donate a central heating/air conditioning unit and pay for my utility bill I'd be very happy. So would my wife!
thanks for all the info!
The check is in the mail
DB
>