Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

Posts

HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#1

HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

Steve Yakoban

>Please help! Doing construction/rebuilding on my house and the 2x10's I'm using are splitting end to end.

I have a load of lumber from HD (not a "real" yard) that I'm using now for repairs and later for a small addition. Some of the lumber is in my basement but most is in my garage. Both are unheated but the basement has a dehumidifier set to 35% humidity. And it's in the 20's here in NJ. I buy from the orange box because I can select the lumber myself - the yards don't let me.

BTW - Not a big fan of the orange box, but other lumber from them has been fine including very straight KD DF studs. I have a new bath framed in the basement using a little bit of everything and nothing has warped or split after months w/the dehumidifier.

Currently I'm replacing some 60" long 1st floor joists (exposed to the basement) and both a 2x10 from the garage and from the basement have split end to end while just sitting fitted snug in position without any fasteners. It's Douglas Fir, but I can't help noticing that the growth rings are quite far apart. Also, most pieces are centered or nearly centered w/the tree, causing me to believe these are small trees being harvested.

Any idea why this is happening? What can I do about it? Is it really the source I'm getting this stuff from? Can it be something done wrong at the mill? Can you return cut wood???

I'm in a bind because we have about 250 sqf. of open joists and I need to get these in and subfloored before someone falls through...

Thanks guys!!!

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#2

Here are photos of the wood

Steve Yakoban

>http://www.spia.net/stuff/split1.jpg

http://www.spia.net/stuff/split2.jpg

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#3

Dale Lenz

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

Dale Lenz

>I'd load the lumber up in my truck take my receipt and take it back to where to purchased it from. See what they say. Might make a phone call first and talk with the manager. Be polite but firm.

Good luck

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#4

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

Steve Yakoban

>Another point: I bought them extra long to trim the ends which were already split 6-8" per end at the store...

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#5

JL

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

JL

>Take them back if you can. They look like they were improperly dried. Hopefully Bill Tindall will chime in, he's more of an expert.

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#6

a guess......

bill tindal, E.TN

>Well, I don't know anything about softwood lumber. If it was oak the problem is obvious. The center of hardwood trees always split upon drying. It all has to do with the nature of the early growth wood in a hardwood tree. I have the details in some publication if more details (which I have forgot) are needed.

The yellow pine we use in these parts for floor joists are cut away from the tree centers and the very center of the logs are cut for 4 x 4's which normally split upon drying.

If I was a detective I would visit a lumber yard catering to contractors and look at their fir 2 x10's. If they didn't have the center of the tree in them I might suspect HD of getting a "bargain" on some lumber that knowledgeable customers (contractors) would not buy. Then they pass this bargain off to unsuspecting buyers at what seems to be a bargain price.

I got some "baltic birch" plywood at HD ONCE. The price was a steal, until it started drying out and warping like potato chips. I measured it at 18% moisture! It was clear from this episode that HD will buy reject junk that looks like a bargain and foist it off on customers that they hope won't know the difference.

People should examine their desire to shop at places that allow picking through piles. The concept might be valid for a small quantity of lumber but at some quantity, unless you are the first person through a pile you will be getting less than average lumber. We never allowed it. It annoyed the small customer (that was not a source of significant profit) and delighted others that knew they were not buying picked through lumber.

When I buy from a yard catering to contractors I tell the person loading lumber what it is to be used for. For example if I need a 2 x 12 for stair stringers it needs to be more sound that for a floor joist. I expect them to load lumber that I can use, and by in large they do. If contractors can build houses out of it I figure I can.

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Over 20 years...

Dale Lenz

>ago, I was moonlighting rebuilding/repairing antique furniture. Had a piece made out of D.fir. Purchase a 2x something D.fir and it was terrible, fuzzy, pinched the saw during ripping, and wet inside. I guessed it was green reaction wood. I got another board, not sure if I got reimbursed for my first board or not. But, the salesman was kind enough to listen to my story and I came home with another board, probably better grade. It was as different as night and day. BTW, the picture of your board(s) does not look like D. fir to me, just an observation, I'm weak on my softwood ID. So I guess my thoughts are: try to get a better grade of lumber for your project. There should be a mill stamp on your lumber that tells the grade among other things. Any chance the stamp says something like Hem-Fir?

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#8

Re: Over 20 years... *LINK*

Steve Yakoban

>Thank you guys for the responses!

If you look at the linked image, the triangle says D FIR best as I can read it on the actual wood.

I didn't shop HD for a bargain - I never even compared the prices. I went there to select what I wanted and because I can over-buy and return the extra. Also, many of the yards leave their materials uncovered in the rain. Maybe it's a Jersey attitude thing, but my experience has always been unless you know the yard man in the local yard and you're his Buddy, he pulls the closest boards that take the least of his effort. That's it. I'm an occasional customer so I don't know anyone. And tipping the guy doesn't change the situation much either. Ironically, my family was friends with the owners of a local family run yard and they would always take care of my Dad. It was located less than 1/4 mile from the orange box but is now a used car lot and fitness club.

I will try a real yard tomorrow and see how their stuff differs. It's just hard to believe there is something like "defective" lumber.


D-FIR stamp

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#9

Willamina Lumber.. I have a question

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Is that what the stamp says? Luke Herzberg used to live just down the road from that mill. Was the lumber Kiln dried or green (I didn't see a KD stamp on it). If it was green any idea how long it had been inside before you bought it, and how long was it inside at you house before you started to use it. My experience with green framing lumber is... Once the bands are broken on the unit, you need to get it used NOW. Otherwise you have premade knidling (splits), whitewater canoe keels and / or airplane propellers.

I buy KD lumber for all my framing needs, just because I'm usually not able to buy whole units and use them in the next week or so.

glc

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: Does...

Dale Lenz

>appear to be D.Fir. also surfaced green, did not see KD any place on the stamp, kiln dry. Usually says something like KD<19% or less. If you can't take the lumber back, let it dry some more on a flat and level surface with plenty of air flow around and under it and you will eventually find a use for it.

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#11

Re: Willamina Lumber.. I have a question

Steve Yakoban

>It's green. When I've asked yards for anything other than KD 2x4's I've been told that I need to buy a whole skid and that it's special order and... One board was here over 3 months, the other over 3 weeks. I have a whole load of 3 month old stuff for use in May.

If I could buy by the piece I would pay the premium for KD and #1 but that option doesn't exist in Jersey... if anywhere.

Re: HELP!!! 2x lumber splitting like crazy...

#12

I had to comment about Willimina lumber

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I grew up about 35 mile from Willimina. It's to bad you can't buy just what you need. I can go to my local lumber yard and buy any amount of just about any kind of NW soft wood, special order stuff takes a day or three, but I sure don't have to buy a whole unit, just one board. If I am picking up the wood I can put back a few that just won't work for my needs, but I mostly just pull off the top of the stack. Admittedly I do buy lumber for my Job and my personal use, but the only difference I see in my treatment and the avereage homeowner is they know my name and I get the same discount as the company I work. I do work hard at maintianing good relationships local suppliers.

glc