Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT email problem

Posts

OT email problem

#1

OT email problem

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>A number of my e-mails are not getting through. I show sent but apparently off they go into the wild blue yonder, never to be seen again. I understand I can use return receipt, but that does n ot solve the problem. I use Thunderbird.

Second, I have not tried OE simply because I cannot get it to run. For some reason OE refuses to find pop.server . . . I made a mistake the first time I set it up many months ago and used us rather than com. Now I cannot do anything with it.

The major problem, however, is the disappearance of the e-mails. Any suggestions?

Re: OT email problem

#2

Re: OT email problem

Dan Donaldson

>Normally, if it gets to the smtp server and says sent, it is. If someone doesn't get it after that, it might be that their spam filter has decided that your address is spam. Usually, it is all or none. Either all of them go or none do. If they are going, but not received, it sounds like the other end. You can get OE to work if you just go into the email settings and set up the account. You may need to delete the previous one that is messed up. You need the mail server address and the smtp server address to do that. That said, I personally would not use either Outlook or OE unless forced to. I use Outlook at work because I have to, but would never use it at home. I also use T-bird.

Re: OT email problem

#3

Re: OT email problem

Robert Hutchins

>Howdy Professor!

What you are experiencing one of the frailties of email on the Internet.

In the old days, when we built networks, they lacked intelligent workstations. We network builders used lots of techniques to ensure that messages were received and understood at the receiving end. Sort of like the old "Roger?" and "Roger, Willco!" from voice transmissions of times past.

Well, things have changed in networking with the arrival on the scene of intelligent terminals (PC's); so networking protocols have changed. Now we send an email with the expectation that it will be delivered or that the network nodes will return a 'failure to deliver' message of some sort. It is then up to the sender to figure out why the message was not deliverable, correct the problem, and send it again. Many people do not accede to the 'tell the sender I read his message' request if you ask for a return receipt, either. Sometimes, a node in the network that is 'passing traffic' will experience a problem and just drop the ball. Even very low level protocol handshaking doesn't recover the traffic when that happens. I've even heard of network mail servers whose memory or temporary storage capacity was exceeded who just dropped all subsequent traffic sent to them. There are redundant routes built into the Internet message handling software and the message handling protocols allow sending the same message via different routes expecting the network software to detect duplicates and drop them.

This is a verbose way of saying that Internet email communication is of the 'indeterminate' type - meaning that it is fallible and that the failure is not always detected or determined. Internet email is not considered, technically, to be a 'highly reliable' message exchange technique. That it is, practically, highly reliable makes us come to believe that it is nearly infallible. Alas, it is not so.

You could try doing a little detective work to determine, if you can, where your mail goes by default and see if there have been network problems; however, without tools and technical knowledge this would probably be an exercise in futility. Try contacting your ISP and give them as many details about mail that wasn't delivered as you can. If the problem is inbound email (you mentioned your pop server which handles your inbound mail; outbound is handled by your SMTP server - probably), the problem could be that the sender is not proficient, they're using an incorrect address, their ISP is dropping the ball, the network is dropping the ball at any one of tens of thousands of nodes, or your ISP is dropping the ball - instead of the problem being on your PC with your software.

Sorry, but this is the best I can do to help explain why you might be having problems - without a great deal more information and very specific examples.

HTH

BobH

Re: OT email problem

#4

If the Problem is Filtering, OE Won't Work Either

Robert Hutchins

>

Re: OT email problem

#5

Send 10 people an email

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Try sending the same message to 10 people, including yourself, then see who gets them. Like Robert said, email is a fragile thing, and becoming moreso due to the idiot spammers intent on disrupting the internet.

A very large (don't know how big) percent of the spam/virus emails these days are "Unable to send, message returned".... so if someone gets 100 of these a day, and there's one legitamite one in there with 199 fakes ones... well, it ends up in a deleted box and part of the clues to why your emails aren't getting anywhere are lost.

Also, if your email has a webmail capability, try using that for a test. Webmail, since it's direclty on the email server is not susecptible to any problems your PC's configuration could introduce.

Happy Woodworking!