Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

OT Computer Purchasing Service

Posts

OT Computer Purchasing Service

#1

OT Computer Purchasing Service

Stuart Johnson

>I'm in what seems like an endless loop trying to decide what laptop to purchase. So far they seem to range from $1,200 to $3,000 depending on what is included.

I know what I do now, what I would like to do and in some cases what I have no interest in doing. What I don't know is what else might be available or what I need to get the maximum long term use from a machine. I tend to stay with what I have. The machine I have now was purchased in 1998 and I feel a car or truck isn't broke in under 10 years.

Does anyone know of a service, fee paid or free, that will assist in this decision? If there isn't one out there I think someone is missing a money making opportunity. I would think a form with maybe 20 - 30 questions, possibly more, connected to a data base could very rapidly spit out several options for comparison.

For example a $1,200 HP will do what I now want but might not handle future needs. The $3,000 HP mobile workstation will certainly do everything I now need and I can upgrade when needed. In this example the lower priced one has Vista and is using all available memory. The higher priced has XP Professional and the memory can be doubled.

Is this like purchasing say a lathe where buying the very best you can afford is usually sound advise?

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#2

Flawed thinking..

Mike in Paradise

>Technology is different than other items...You pay through the nose for another couple of years of longevity in computers. Instead of spending $3000 for a high end laptop you would be better spending $1000 on a laptop every 3-4 years.

What you pay $1000 for in 3 years will probably be more powerful than what you are paying $3000 for today.

Personally I would stay away from Dell. I have had great luck with Thinkpads and the last one bought last year was a Toshiba.

Technology decisions get more difficult year after year as there are just more and more options.

My opinion is that you look for a middle of the road reasonably priced PC "THAT DOES WHAT YOU NEED IT TO DO NOW" and plan on replacing it in 3-4 years.

Good luck!

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#3

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

dwr

>With a laptop, your upgrade opportunities are almost non existent but you do get portability. With a workstation you get extended longevity via upgrade opportunities but sacrifice portability. So, if portability is your main desire you have to accept the limitations and compromises.

Also, maintenance history and the MTBF (mean time before failure) figures are better for desktops than laptops.

Laptops are more expensive than a comparable desktop.

Lastly, with the rapid advancements in computer technology, it is impossible to predict what will be available in the future and when. However, it is a sound bet that it will integrate into an existing desktop where as you would most likely have to purchase a new laptop to get the same upgrade.

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#4

Re: Flawed thinking..

Ray SW Ohio

>I agree with Mike. You can add more memory or a bigger hard drive to a laptop, not much else. I like Toshiba laptops myself. Right now seems like prices are as good as they are going to get for awhile. Just my 2�.

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#5

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

David Yoho

>Stuart,

The only laptop computer out there right now I'd even think about spending $3000 on is a 17" MacBook Pro and I'm a PC person! I believe you can configure an HP Business laptop that will certainly meet your needs now and later for much less (recently did a few).

Look on HP under small business models. There is a "configure" button that allows you to equip the computer with a selection of hard drives, memory amounts, processor type and speed, and others.

Personally, I'd go for one with 2 GB of memory, and the fastest processor offered. Whether it comes with XP Pro or some version of Vista shouldn't matter. In fact, I just saw a brand new Compaq with Vista loaded and it seemed slow with the Core 2 Duo processor and 1 GB of memory it had. Perhaps where XP Pro was fine with 1 Gb of RAM, Vista needs more. Either way, I'd max out the amount your laptop can take. Many times on a laptop the on-board video adapter will use some system memory, which decreases the overall available for the OS.

David

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#6

Re: Flawed thinking..

Matt Berry

>Any computer you buy now would be more than adequate for your needs. I also wouldn't worry about having more then 1gb of ram. As for the brands, they all have their pros and cons, go with the one you feel most confident with, and try not to get too wrapped up in the brand bashing.

You should be able to find an excellent laptop from between 1000 - 1400. Good Luck with your search.

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#7

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

wilbur

>Can you be more specific as to what you want your new laptop to do? That will really determine what laptop is best for you.

Having said that, I really like Macs, especially for laptops. If you are interested in having a computer that will maintain its performance over time, Macs do better than Windows computers in this regard.

There was a recent discussion here on laptops, where you can see why I like Macs instead of Windows computers. Here's what I had to say:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl?noframes;read=309235

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl?noframes;read=309379

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#8

Total cost Of ownership

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>you must determine the value by your yearly budget.

laptops don't last forever. period. end of story. I use one daily for work and play. they are fragile, easy to drop etc.

if you are a road warrior you needs are different from a home based situation.

there are two parts to a home based PC. storage of data and functionality in running programs.

separate them and you are free to go cheap if you need.

you can get a tera-byte lan based file sever at bets now days. sure it's a 500 to 700 dollar investment but you have all the room for you data so if pics, movies, music and scanned drawings plans are your thing.

all you need to worry about every is the processing speed and memory which get faster every 6 months or so. disk and network speed improves slower and last longer.

a 700 dollar investment could last you 5 to 10 years depending on your storage needs. that is 140 dollars a year to 70 cost of ownership.

disk cost per megabytes drops every year. you may not gain much but it is easier on the loss of time to upgrade every year add more hard disk enclosures etc. you can get it down to probably 30 bucks a year by some computer savy usage of items and configuration.

all pc and laptop worst bang for the buck is the latest and greatest home entry system. there are many reasons that we could go into later.

to decide what price bracket you want to jump into is simple. how much can you budget a year or feel comfortable shelling out. it is not a good idea to charge a pc that will take 5 years to pay for but be useless in 3.

line up you software needs, OS needs and your concurrent running of programs. size the memory, CPU. if you are into gaming the disk IO and graphics are real important.

also as important is the user experience. how long will you wait for screens to refresh, open, save etc.

if you consider that a 600 dollar laptop would last you 2 years and a 1200 laptop would last you 3. it's cheaper to own a 600 laptop. and in two years the next $600 laptop will be way better than your 1200 one.

on the other hand if user experience is more important than your budget gte the next to the latest release(all the bugs are worked out and the chip sets are optimized).

don't expect a laptop to be much use in 5 years. I do know some people pride themselves on being thrifty and using things way after they are useful but the advancements of technology in the everyday lifestyle are advancing very rapidly. once you could run a PC for 5 years and be happy. It's going to be more like 3 years soon. vista, OS X lepoard and the 3d linux desktops are diving the way of the future. money will be spent on new technology advancement so programs lifespans will be shorter. support will fall off quicker for old version and your user experience will be non existent.

just my 02c.

I like a nice stable usable system so I do plan on buys macs for home until the other "OS" actually reaches sp 4. this is a major move in windows so I expect it to go beyound the other OS's to reach stability

by sp2. they cost more but I place a high value on my time. so overall I am willing to pay more in hardware cost.

just my .02c

Re: OT Computer Purchasing Service

#9

Thanks everyone,

Stuart Johnson

>you must determine the value by your yearly budget.

The reason I used the $1,200 - $3,000 range was I really wanted to take budget out of the equation. Like many things I would rather wait and save a bit more and buy something fairly good and fairly priced rather than spend less on something less expensive but also cheap. There is a difference.

More than likely I will keep looking but wait until we or I guess I should say every have broadband access or we take a trip. My current system is slow, won't handle some stuff I would like to have but I can't access it on the web anyway. On the other hand when we travel I would like to have a laptop so I can have access at the hotel or in coffee shops.

One of you more might want to consider starting a web based business that asks all of the proper questions. It should then spits out a recommended configuration that isn't brand oriented but does point to brands that include the recommended specs.