Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Hinges vs pivot?

Posts

Hinges vs pivot?

#1

Hinges vs pivot?

Barry Irby

>I�m working on a side board/hunt table that has two doors. Similar to the one that was featured in FWW. Calls for offset knife hinges on the doors. Was shocked to find that Brusso ones range for about $16 to $21 a pair. LV has some cheaper ones, but they are still $11. Maybe I�m out of touch, but this seems a lot for hinges. And, I�m not �sold� on the appearance of the knuckles sticking out top and bottom.

What about drilling a quarter inch hole top and bottom and using piece of brass rod as a pivot? I could put a washer of two to support he doors. Or am I just being cheap?

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

#2

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

Ben

>I agree that the brusso hardware is spendy but for what it is worth the quality is really high. I use a lot of their box hinges and never regret the results. The amount of time to mortise a hinge is the same reguardless of the cost of the hardware, and a cheap hinge always looks cheap. The few times that I did not use them I regretted it.

The brass rod will work but it will eventually wear out the wood and the fit will become sloppy. You could could put in a hat type bushing in the door so there is a metal to metal wear surface. I would look at the 35mm inset cup hinges as well. They don't look all that great but you only see them when the door is open, I think the last set I bought was under $10.

Hope this helps.

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Be careful

Ellis Walentine

>Hinges, regardless of the type, confine the door's movement to a very particular arc depending on the relationship of the knuckle or pivot point to the door and the cabinet. A straight pivot as you describe will swing the back corner of the door through an arc that may require some modifications to the cabinet in order to clear. An offset knife hinge is usually used to move the door away from the cabinet as it opens or to clear the cabinet or adjacent architecture when it is fully open, in a way that a straight knife hinge will not.

Without exception, every time I ever designed a door, I drew full size section views of the door, the jamb or cabinet chassis, and the hinge itself. Draw the relationship in closed and in partially open and open positions so you can see where all the relevant edges are in space throughout the action of opening.

Regarding the cost of the hinges you use, I'm always more inclined to spend a few extra bucks for better materials, including hardware. Compared to the labor of building the piece, material cost is usually insignificant in the long run.

Ellis

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

#4

Thanks Ellis,

Barry Irby

>I have been thinking about this very thing. This piece has the door directly against the upper, square or straight portion of a tapered leg, without any face frame. The face of the door is set back about 5/16". Therefore, it would be easy to use a hinge that would allow the door to bind against the leg and not swing much past ninety degrees. On the other hand, the off set knife hinges seem to me they would cause an issue on the other edge of the door, in effect "throwing" the inner edge of the door against the "jamb" as the door swings forward.

Another thing I want to look at is the width of the door opening. This is supposed to be storage for diner plates. I need to be sure the door does not block the opening. One thought I had was to reverse the swing of the doors and have them hinged from the stile supporting the drawers. Then I could use ordinary butt hinges and the doors could open fully. Just can't decide if that would be odd looking. Another option would be to install a stile up the leg of the piece to create a place for butt hinges, but that would limit the opening.

Next time, I will make the doors that have the hinges already on them.

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

#5

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

calvin in Irmo, SC

>See the web address below for a handout from John Leake concerning his design for a Piedmont sideboard. He uses regular brass butt hinges on his doors and they look great. John is a great maker of reproductions of period furniture.

The handout: greenvillewoodworkers.com/pdfs/JohnLeakeFebruary2007.pdf

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

#6

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

Barry Irby

>Thanks Calvin.

Does he mortice the hinges into the legs or just surface mount them?

It seems you would not want the knuckle of the hinge let into the leg so that the pin could be removed on a slip or loose pin hinge. You could also angel the mortice so that the inside edge of the leaf was flush and it angled out to nothing near the pin.

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

#7

Re: Hinges vs pivot?

calvin in Irmo, SC

>Barry,

Check your e-mail.