Why I recommend garnet
Michael Dresdner
>Both garnet and AlOx start out sharp, but while most synthetic AlOx is made to be friable, garnet is not. That means the AlOx fractures as you use it, always presenting a sharp cutting edge to the wood. This is great for all but the last hand sanding.
Garnet gets dull as you use it. That means unlike the sharp, V shaped scratches AlOx leaves, slightly dulled garnet will leave softer U shaped scratches. The result is a surface that both stain and finish addresses differently.
In two of my books I have photos of two halves of one piece of wood, both sanded with the same grit sandpaper, but one half with AlOx and the other garnet. The board was then stained and wiped, and the AlOx side is darker and less uniform. I also have a sample of the same thing that I carry with me when I do lectures so folks can see the real thing.
People have stopped buying garnet because most do not know of its advantage. Also, this advantage is only on the last sanding. Hence, the only thing that there is an educated market for is 180 or 220 grit garnet. The combination of a poor market overall and an educated market that only buys one or two sizes means it is not worth it for companies to continue making garnet sandpaper. I, for one, will mourn its passing if and when it goes.