Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Garnet sand paper disapearing?

Posts

Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#1

Garnet sand paper disapearing?

Barry Irby

>The owner of a local hardware store that caters to woodworkers told me garnet sand paper is "going away". He claims there are fewer and fewer sources of the garnet and that since it is naturally occurring, we will stop seeing it. Anyone know anything about this?

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#2

Slightly OT

Andy Halterman: Finally some winter fun

>I was just in NV spending time with some friends. We went mineral hunting at an old mine site. That place was loaded with garnet. I brought home some good size crystals. Not gem quality but still pretty. It was once a tungsten mine but they obviously had no interest in the garnet, molybdenite and a few other things I saw there.

Kind of a waste if you ask me.

Andy Halterman

Still jet lagging a bit in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#3

Could be, but for a different reason...

John in New Mexico

>Garnet is a very common mineral, so while the explanation sounds good, it's probably something more mundane, like it doesn't work as well as SiC, Al2O3, or whatever they're using on modern sandpapers; the synthetic abrasives are harder and probably cheaper to produce these days.

The way mineral economics works, if the hardware dealer's explanation were correct, you'd see first a large price increase with no supply decrease, followed by limited availablity with further price increases, followed by decreased use causing the price to stabilize. If the product were superior to alternatives it would still be produced, as there would continue to be some demand, and it would take decades for it to disappear due to lack of available materials.

John

(Former mineral exploration geologist- also becoming scarce due to lack of demand!)

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#4

Re: for yet another different reason...

Carol from AZ

>An even more cynical view.

Papers other than garnet have been marketed as superior and thus accepted by users as such.

Other papers now cost less to produce and/or there is more profit to be made with AO papers, etc.

Simple capitalist economics.

When is the last time you wished you could have purchased something you used to be able to get, worked as well as or better that what is now available, maybe even cost less, and is now no longer available?

See?

Carol, with too much homework this weekend taking a break and venting a little. :)

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#5

Another Tid bit:

Barry Irby

>The guy in the hardware store claimed that really serious folks (serious about perfect finishes) liked garnet best because it DID wear down. That they would not use a piece until they had broken it in a bit on something of less importance. Something about not being ultra sharp was good.

First I ever heard of this.

Of Course, the same fellow was unaware of the sandpaper grading system that includes a P in the designation.

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#6

Thats a new one...

John in New Mexico

>I thought the folks serious about perfect finishes just used finer paper when appropriate ;). Carol's got dibs on cynical, so I'm going for snide.

Seriously though, I never really paid much attention to various types. Seems like I always bought the cheapest variety of Norton's paper from HD or where ever.

John

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#7

Actually not new.

Chuck Nickerson

>For some time, finishing expert Michael Dresdner has recommended a final sanding by hand with 180 garnet for this very reason.

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#8

Sounds kinda fussy...

John in New Mexico

>But I usually just go right from 120 or 150 to 220 and call it good there. Can't see any advantage to having to get special 180 paper and "break it in" before final sanding. Maybe if one were sanding in between coats of laquer or something, but then we'd be talking about much finer grits.

I know of one custom shop that sands to 600 before oiling. Aside from that their process is the same as mine, and I've seen no significant differences in the finished product.

John

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#9

utility of garnet

bill tindal, E.TN

>Garnet abrasive was used in the furniture industry for sanding end grain. Don't know if this is still the case.

The way the abrasive particle wears is very different for the various abrasive materials. This in turn results in a different scratch pattern on the material, which can affect appearance.

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#10

Why I recommend garnet

Michael Dresdner

>Both garnet and AlOx start out sharp, but while most synthetic AlOx is made to be friable, garnet is not. That means the AlOx fractures as you use it, always presenting a sharp cutting edge to the wood. This is great for all but the last hand sanding.

Garnet gets dull as you use it. That means unlike the sharp, V shaped scratches AlOx leaves, slightly dulled garnet will leave softer U shaped scratches. The result is a surface that both stain and finish addresses differently.

In two of my books I have photos of two halves of one piece of wood, both sanded with the same grit sandpaper, but one half with AlOx and the other garnet. The board was then stained and wiped, and the AlOx side is darker and less uniform. I also have a sample of the same thing that I carry with me when I do lectures so folks can see the real thing.

People have stopped buying garnet because most do not know of its advantage. Also, this advantage is only on the last sanding. Hence, the only thing that there is an educated market for is 180 or 220 grit garnet. The combination of a poor market overall and an educated market that only buys one or two sizes means it is not worth it for companies to continue making garnet sandpaper. I, for one, will mourn its passing if and when it goes.

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#11

Stain? what's stain?

John in New Mexico

>Seriously though, put like that I can see how the sharper grit would be a problem. I'll have to remember that if I ever find myself using stain.

John

Re: Garnet sand paper disapearing?

#12

Re: Why I recommend garnet

eliot d

>Would your logic lead to using worn sandpaper --not garnet-- for the final sanding? Most experts I have talked to council against ever using worn sand paper. They say things like, " Worn 180 is not 220; it's just worn out 180!" I have heard of one rather famous maker of wooden boxes who "polishes" his wood with worn sandpaper on a mechanical sanding belt.