Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

Posts

Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#1

Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

durk

>to heat their garage workspace. I'm investigating the pros/cons of the various garage heaters.

thoughts, suggestions greatly appreciated!

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#2

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

Paul D. May

>I put one in a couple of years ago and really like it. It heats my 20 x 20 space starting at 35 deg and heats to 60 in 15 min.


img

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#3

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have the same type unit. Mine is called a "Hot Shot" made by Lennox. 40,000 BTU as I recall. Heats my shop from 45 degrees to 60 degrees in about 10 minutes. I've used it for 7 years and it has worked great.

Tom

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#4

Re: Yep

Grant Smith

>I have the 45K BTU unit andit works great. My only complaint is the double wall vertical chimney I installed drips condensate in damp, cold weather. You can also run the chimney out through the wall, but I elected to go upwards since I thought I might add on to the shop one day.

On purchasing them:

-They are sold under various names, and though I have no proof suspect they are all the same. Modine (which I have), Resnor, and a few store brands (Menard's began selling them lately.

-I bought mine from Johnstone Supply for $425 plus another $100 or so for the flue/Chimney parts. Installed it myself, but contracted for a gas line to be run to outside my shop. I installed the black iron pipe from the regulator outside in through the wall the the unit. Having the gas line trenched about 60 feet cost me $350 to have done.

-Menard's had them lately in 45KBTU for $299. It wasn't Modine, but some store brand... looked the same, however.

I am perfectly happy with mine, it heats my 24x30 shop well in the Iowa winters. Note that the tables they provide for sizing them assume heating the space to 70 degrees or so, which I seldom do. Also I was told by an HVAC contractor to NOT oversize the unit for the space, because it will cycle more frequently leading to more failures and rust internally due to condensation. Mine would probably heat a four car garage (insulated 2x4"s, insulated door, drywalled) without much trouble based on how much it runs in bitter cold temps.

I installed the thermostat near the light switch so I can remember to turn it down when I leave the shop. I set it to about 40 degrees when not in the shop to keep things from freezing.

Units such as these aren't as efficient as modern house furnaces, but all the same I have scarcely noticed much rise in my gas bill since installing it and running it all winter.

If you go with a contractor, expect to pay $750 plus for the unit plus install (I was quoted another $750 for that, including materials). You be the judge as to if you are capable of installing it yourself.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#5

Re: Yep

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I installed the thermostat near the light switch so I can remember to turn it down when I leave the shop.

I just wrote a reminder on the wall next to the door along with one telling me to kill the power to the DC.

I have an off-brand 45,000 btu unit that I got new on ebay for around $350 that heats my 28X28 shop well although I don't think it gets to the 65 degrees I work in as quick as ten minutes. I would have liked to get a Modine but the renovation of the building went waaaaay over budget and by the time I got around to installing the heater I was cutting back on expense as much as possible. At least as important as the heater is good insulation. The attic in my shop is a lot better than the R-30 I'd planned mostly because I had never blown insulation before. About the only place that is down to R-30 is where I was starting to run out toward the end. That is the end AFTER I went back and bought seven more bags.

I haven't been out there this week in the really bitter cold because the snow is a little on the deep side. That said, working when the outside temps were in the teens with the thermostat set at 65 the heater only fired every 20 to thirty minutes.

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#6

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg... *LINK*

Rich S

>Yes, I have two of them...one is a Modine Hot Dawg 75000 and the other is a WGH (Hamilton Home Products) 75000 which is the exact same machine right down to the screws...I run both of them on LP and use one in each section of my shop which is 26x110. Both are thermostatically controlled...I can't complain about either unit at all. They have been very reliable so far in the 6 and 7 years I've had them. Mine are vented horizontally. I bought them from local dealers for about 450ish if I remember correctly. You can buy the WGH direct from Hamilton (they have great support for do it yourselfers and are real friendly too).


http://www.hamiltonhomeproducts.com/furnaces-garheaters.htm

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#7

I installed a Sterling *LINK*

Keith Weber

>I spent a little extra and got a unit that draws the intake air from the outside and vents the exhaust outside as well. The more popular Modines and similar heaters use room air for the intake. This creates a few problems.

Firstly, it creates an air displacement problem. The heater will use a lot of air and this air has to come from somewhere. In a garage, it will probably come from a leaking garage door. The cold air that comes in mixes with the air that the heater just heated (kind of counter-productive, wastes energy, and slows down the rate of heating.)

The second problem is moisture. All of that air leaking in by the garage door contains moisture, which will most likely end up condensing on your expensive tools. My garage is my metal-working shop. I have a lot of raw steel tubing in there. I hate rust, so I wanted to eliminate any moisture concerns. Drawing intake combustion air from the outside in a sealed unit completely eliminates this problem.

The third problem with using room air for combustion is when you have a very dusty room, or use explosive vapors. They are going to run through the combustion box of the heater.

For these three reasons, I bought a unit that draws its combustion air from outside and vents the flue outside as well. I bought the Sterling SF-45 unit seen in the link. It was $819 + shipping. I am very happy with my purchase and would do it over again in a heartbeat.

For those with a keen eye, I took the pic during the installation, so there is no foil tape on the elbow seams in the pic. There is now, so the flue gases are completely sealed from the garage.

Keith


img

Sterling SF Heaters

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#8

Re: I installed a Sterling

Stephen

>Any problem with rust when the shop is not heated? What about in the summer with humidity? What do you do if anything to combat these problems?

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#9

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

Ray Newman

>Hopefully your shop/garage is insulated � inc. windows & doors. If not & depending where you live, you very may well be throwing money & heat out the window.

I have a 6 year old Modine that works quite well. It�s on the back wall & vents to the outside& runs off of a LP tank. It is the large unit & I bought it during an off-season sale. I had a low temperature thermostat installed.

My shop is very tight (I left all the lights on & went around the shop @ midnight on a moonless night & found a few minor light leaks).

I�ve been in the shop for 10 hrs +/- w/ the heater cycling on/off & haven�t noticed any ill effects from oxygen deprivation, etc.

No rust problem. Maybe because the vent is short & the exhaust & moisture drains to the outside??

Since it doesn�t have an open flame, & I don�t use flammable finishes & run a cyclone DC, I�m not that too concerned about a fire starting from using the inside shop air. �Just in case� I periodically blow out the unit w/ compressed air.

I think if it was to do it all over again, I would consider a unit that draws & vent from the outside. These units are now a great deal cheaper than when I purchased the Modine.

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#10

Re: I installed a Sterling

Keith Weber

>I don't have any problems when the garage is heated because it's pretty dry in the winters here in the Midwest. The summers are definetely more humid, but no major problems to date. Last summer was my first summer with a metal shop. I've got about 1000 lbs. of square tubing in the garage that I'm using for TIG welding. I'm actually surprised that it isn't all rusted considering that it was pouring rain when it was delivered. I restacked everything, wiping down each piece to remove the water. I would call the rust that has occurred to be negligible and easy to clean up with a wire wheel.

TIG welding is very picky when it comes to needing clean metal. Any rust or scaling at all in your weld will contaminate it.

The worst heaters that you can use are the gas ones that don't vent at all to the outside. A lot of people buy them because their cheap and are very efficient because no heat is lost to the outside. The problem is that water is a byproduct of the combustion, which is why they say they are indoor safe. The Modine style units are a lot better than the indoor units, and the totally vented ones are the best in controlling humidity issues. Modine makes one similar to the Sterling SF Heaters(called HDS units, I think), but they're not cheap (over $1000.)

I guess it depends on how anal you want to be with your heater. A lot of people use the Hot Dawgs and love them. My new Snap on Tool Chest is a lot nicer than my Craftsman one -- Is it worth paying double? Maybe not? I think so, but I'm sure other's would disagree! I don't have a wife to explain my purchases to, so I can be as anal as I like with my shops/tools! My married friends think that I have it too good! Their wives think that I need a woman in my life!

Keith

Re: Anyone using a Modine Hot Dawg...

#11

Thanks All!...

durk

>Great insight & opinions. I upgraded my garage doors to raynor insulated, then insulated the garage ceilings...all that's left is to drywall the ceiling, then it's time to shop for the best price I can find on a Modine or Lennox garage system.

thanks again everyone!