Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Posts

OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#1

OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi all.

Any home security experts here? Tell me how dumb I am. Last night, I signed up for ADT.

I'm getting a motion detector (100# rating because I have two Golden Retrievers), 3 door sensors (I have 3 entry doors to the house), smoke detector, and key fob thingy. All this hardware and installation are free. Just the monthly charge which seems to be the same as everyone else I've asked except they didn't get the hardware and installation for free.

Years ago our little suburb used to be one of the "nice" Cleveland suburbs. Not anymore. Locking doors at night used to be unheard of. The West Side of Cleveland is moving into our little burb and it's eroding sorry to say. Last week, two houses on my street were broken into and robbed! One of which a 15 year old girl (same age as my daughter and son) was home in her bed room! How scary is that! Even the big houses on the lake (Lake Erie) are getting robbed.

I decided it was time to get something. I have to stay in this town until my two kids graduate from high school. Lakewood H.S. is still one of the best in the state as far as the AP program goes and that is the only reason we don't put the house up for sale.

Other than providing some peace of mind, are these ADT systems supposed to be good? They sure seem popular. Of course that doesn't mean they're any good.

Any police here? What do they have to say about these?

Thanks,

Joe

sorry to be so wordy

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#2

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

jeff

>Joe

The first thing to do is talk to your local police.

Find out how much they hear from ADT in your are, how fast they can respond, and their policies in regards to alarms.

Some police take an alarm call and respond asap, some put them on the list below cat in tree calls.

If the response is slow, then get the loudest and baddest alarm you can, to scare the thief.

If a fast response, then get a silent alarm to catch the thief.

I don't know your area where you live, so can't guide you there.

Any alarm installed in a home is pretty worthless unless it can do the job it is intended to do.

If you must know, ADT spends more money on advertizing then on their alarm monitoring. Their response to calls is slow and poor. The quality of the equipment is worth about what you payed for it.

What ADT wants is the continued revenue of the monitoring fees, and the salesman (if he's any good) will try to get you to pay for upgrades and improvements (and service).

Email me direct if you want more.

Jeff

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#3

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Joe,

First of all, I am not a security expert (but I slept at a Holiday Inn Express last night). Sorry, just had to throw that in.

I think most experts and non-experts would agree that any system is better than not system. In many cases all it takes to deter a burglar is a sign in the front yard. Burglars see the signs as making the house a "harder" target and will generally move on to a "softer" target, which may be next door or down the street.

That being said, make your house as hard of a target as possible. Use the locks on the doors. Use the alarm system if you have one. Make sure windows get locked, even on the second floor. At night, make sure you have plenty of light around the house. All of these things will help deter a break-in. Will they prevent it 100%? No, but they will help.

Also prepare yourself in case you are burglarized. Make sure you have a backup of everything on your computer. There are programs that will allow you to do a "bare metal" restore of a computer in under an hour. Make sure you have a safe with all important papers in it, and make sure the sage is BOLTED TO THE FLOOR. Make sure everyhing is in a safe place. Do all you can to protect yourself.

A good show to check out, if you have cable, is "It Takes a Thief" on the Discovery Channel. They have been running daily episodes at 6:00 P.M. eastern time. Here is the web site for the show:

http://dsc.discovery.com/fansites/ittakesathief/ittakesathief.html

I have gleaned a lot of advice from this show. Do I currently implement it all? NO, but I am trying hard to get properly protected.

Sorry this was so long, it is just that I believe people should do all they can to protect their property and family. There are really simple things to do, and an alarm system is one of them. You have taken a huge first step. When it gets installed, don't forget to use it.

Rob Hix

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#4

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Ernie Miller

>I have had them for 15 years? they are OK I think there response time could be better as I have had a couple false alarms and it took 10-15 minutes to get a response. Last time was better as they had my wife's cell phone #. The good thing it the alarm inside the house is quite loud and the neighbors do hear it go off so the secondary Remmention system will kick in. It's good living where you have retired and 3rd shift workers close by. Another back up option is to put some CC TV cameras on the outside of the house. $23 at HF and hook them up up and old computer in a closet or some place out of site I can get pretty much all four sides of our house with three cameras and both streets (we live on a corner) The rsolution on them is realy quite good for the price. They are small on unnoticable under the eves of the house. I would get the ADT or some other system no matter where I live.

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#5

Ernie...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>can you tell us/me more about your cc cameras? Are they constantly recording to a drive or something.

I wondered about some kind of wireless cameras or something. I could easily set up an old pc, write a quick app, and have access to it from the web to look around the house so to speak. That's probably already done though.

Hmmm. That'd be cool. Then I could spy on the dogs. The kids. The wife. Oh. No. Wait. Maybe not... :) Just kidding.

Joe

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#6

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

J D Thomas

>When I bought my current house about 5 1/2 years ago, it had an ADT wireless system already installed. So I bit and signed up. Not one year, not two, but they required a three year contract which hacked me initially. But I did it anyway since my wife felt good about the whole idea. They didn't have an expense with me initially since the system was already in place. I figured the least they could do was come out and put new batteries in everything as a new customer goodwill gesture. But no. They just want your continued monthiy monitoring income. Beyond that, they don't give a rat's ass. I had problems with sensors going off in the middle of the night, often due to a low battery. When turning the system off when returning home one day, I pressed a button a bit too hard and broken one of the keys on the keypad. Cheap piece of garbage. They charged me $110 to replace it. They will nickel and dime you to death after the initial installation. The monitoring service is mediocre at best. I fired them about 2 years ago. I've never regretted it.

Fortunately for me, the city I live in has an extremely low crime rate. So I still sleep fine at night. So far.

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#7

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Paul in NJ

>You have two of the best alarm systems going, you're dogs! Put up a couple of 'Beware of Dog' signs. Burglars hate noisy dogs even if they are small. If yours don't bark, get one that does. They don't call them 'Man's best friend' for nothing!

Paul Dzioba

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#8

JL

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

JL

>We've had ADT at this house and our previous town house. The initial cost was not cheap.

This house has 2 glass break detectors, 1 motion sensor (in the shop), 2 smoke detectors and all of the downstairs windows and doors are on detectors.

The current monitoring runs me about $75/quarter. The response time is reasonable (1-2 minutes for the first phone call and 10-15 minutes for the police).

I don't plan on having them out in the sticks when I move. I'll be home most of the time with my ferocious attack cats :) (and my friends Glock and Remington).

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#9

Re: Ernie...

Ernie Miller

>try the neighbor kids sneeking into the pool why you are at work. Or ice skating on it

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#10

What about window sensors?

Paul Dwight

>When we built my freestanding workshop a couple of years ago I had an alarm system installed there and in the house. Every door has a sensor, plus we have a couple of motion detectors and glass breakage sensors. And every window in both buildings has a sensor.

Personally, I wouldn't have much confidence in an alarm system that has no window sensors. Maybe you could get by with glass break sensors in every room, but I feel better with window sensors.

Retrofitting window sensors in the house was on the expensive side but for our one-story ranch house with attic, it wasn't outrageous. The installers cut very little drywall and did an acceptable job patching before they left. I had to touch up the paint, which took a couple of hours (would have been less if I hadn't had to search and hunt for the right paint cans among the jumble in the new shop.) I suspect two-story buildings wouldn't be bad, either, as long as they have access to each floor from the basement or attic.

We got a quote from ADT but ended up going with a local company, instead. We chose the company mostly because the salesman seemed to be spending more time designing a system for our particular needs, rather than selling what he always sells. The ADT salesman seemed to be using a cookie-cutter approach -- every one is the same. We are happy with the installation and with the monitoring service.

Whatever you do, get quotes from a couple of companies before you settle on one.

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#11

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Ernie Miller

>now that you mention it. We pay an extra $2 a month for free service if any thing breaks or needs replaced. The battery needed replacing a couple years ago and when they came out to replace it they said that they no longer replaced them for free with the service plan the stoped a couple years ago. I said what?? but look here I have a contract that says you will? Don't replace it and please leave I will call and council my service and file in small claims court. he went out to his truck and talked to some one and after about 5 minutes was knocking on the door I'm sorry I thought you just recently purchased the service I have been authorized to replace it for free. My wife hates to go out in public with me when somthing go's wrong. I just won't walk away with out telling them I won't put up with crap.

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#12

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>1. Do not just put signs in the yard or stickers on the windows and think that the crooks are not smart enough to figure that one out.

2. There is no evidence in the academic/DOJ literature that CCTV acts as a deterrant to crime, especially violent crime, despite what urban legend may state. The UK is the most camerafied country in the world with approx. one government-owned camera per 14 citizens. This does not include private businesses, etc. Most cameras are installed so poorly they have no evidentiary value.

3. Find out if your city has a verified response ordinance, if you need an alarm license, what they charge per false alarm (mine is $100 each for the first four then you're on non-response and the police are not comming) and, if the alarm company has a two-call policy.

4. Police response to false alarms nationwide constitute about 20% of all police calls for service. So, take one of every five pieces of furniture you make and burn it in the fireplace. Most jurisdictions put responding to residential audible alarms the lowest priority.

5. Do not use a silent alarm unless you want to be a hostage in your own home with the bad guy when the SWAT team arrives.

6. Put a horn inside the house that is about 120 db so the thief may take a thing or two but, unless they brought hearing protection, they won't be staying long.

7. Lastly, watch It Takes a Thief and have most of your assumptions about what works and what does not totally destroyed.

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#13

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

Robert Hutchins

>Howdy Joe,

You have some good advice so far. I've never used ADT, but have used other monitoring services. I shopped them carefully with friends, neighbors and the local police department. There is much variability in the quality of services from different vendors.

The only advice I would add, is to consider a panic button. We once had a neighbor followed from the supermarket by would be strong-arm thieves. He had a panic button alarm on his key ring and used it. His worked as a silent alarm. Somehow, the panic button alerted the monitoring firm that he was actually under duress. Police arrived with guns drawn and neighboring streets covered. They took the thieves down and arrested them.

Now another episode. When we moved to Clearwater FL, the house we bought did not have an alarm system. We were advised by everyone we encountered that we should have one. There were no sensors or alarms in the house. After about 4 or 5 months, one of the alarm salesmen who showed more knowledge and diligence than the others came back with a reduced cost selling a master control unit that was being replaced by newer technology and heavily discounted. We bought and paid for sensor installation, but we insisted that all windows and doors be sensor-wired. We even paid a little extra to get window screen fabric sensors - lots of time in FL for having the house open to the breezes.

We had to pay a nominal annual license fee to the city. They allowed 2 false alarms per year then a $150 (IIRC) response fee was charged. We had every type of alarm in the system - motion, glass breakage, trip, smoke, fire (heat rise). We had 2 false alarms while we were away from the house. One was from strong winds rattling large glass walls that retracted to open up the house to the lanai. The other was due to our dachshund barking at just the right frequency (though we never learned what set him off). Police responded promptly both times.

At 2:30 one morning, the horn went off. I checked the control panel and noted that the zone was my daughter's bedroom window screen fabric. Her bedroom was on the opposite side of an H floor plan from ours. She was 10 or 11 yo at the time. There was no wind or other reason to set off the alarm; so I took my 357 revolver, went out a door on the other side and went around the house with a high candlepower flashlight. I saw no one then realized that I was standing there in my skivvies holding a 357 while a burglar alarm was going off and we were letting the police respond. I hurriedly retraced my steps getting back in the house about the same time the police arrived - less than 5 minutes after the alarm. After resetting the panel, I went with the police to inspect the property around the house. We found footprints in the sandy soil below DD's window and a screwdriver on the ground. That one alarm more than paid for all the costs of installation and monitoring in perpetuity, IMO. The officers told me that break-ins were common and that thieves were known to carefully case neighborhoods and target unmonitored homes.

HTH you with your decision.

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#14

What is a good service?

DP

>Everyone's experience with ADT has convinced me that they are not a good option for an alarm service. Anyone have any recommendations for someone that is good?

Re: OT - Home Security. ADT - long

#15

Re: What is a good service?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>Please excuse the somewhat passionate response.

One option is to call your local police department and talk to the crime prevention officer. Face-to-face contact is the preferred method. The crime prevention officer can ask the department's dispatch/communications center what alarm company they have the best/worst response from. Since all it takes is a phone line or internet connection, your alarm system may be monitored from halfway around the world by people who have no idea what is going on in your neighborhood, let alone where your neighborhood is. Just like everything else, the locally owned businesses seem to be going the way of the local hardwood lumber yard.

Though most departments discourage their officers making business recommendations, a crime prevention professional should be able to offer specific advice for your application. Unfortunately, most folks just buy whatever the alarm company offers then discover it does not meet their needs or fit their lifestyle and they quit using it.

An alarm system is just one part of your overall physical security protection system. Good first starts are landscape management keeping ground cover to below three feet and prune mature trees limb's up eight feet creating a "window" to enhance the ability to see and be seen. Read the October 2005 edition of Consumers Reports on door locks. Go to www.lockpicking101.com and view the video on lock bumping to see why you need a decent lock installed to the Uniform Building Security Code (ICBO) standard. Kicking in the front door accounts for about 75% of residential burglary forced entries. Add lighting along the exterior perimiter with lower wattage bulbs to create a soft,even distribution of lighting to a minimum of 0.5 fc. The 150 watt motion sensor bulbs create glare and shadow providing thieves a place to hide.

The City of SeaTac, Washington has municipal code (Chapter 17) that mandates a number of things I have mentioned. Ping me off-line if you have further questions.