Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

HD TV Antana?

Posts

HD TV Antana?

#1

HD TV Antana?

Ernie Miller

>How do HD TV antanas differ from the antana I have on my house now? The kid at the box store is telling me I have to up grade my antana that I have now to recieve HD signals? is there just a differant filter I can put at the head befor the coax comes down to the house? I'm thinking that there can't be that much differance. am I way off?

Re: HD TV Antana?

#2

Re: HD TV Antana?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi Ernie.

Wish I knew the answer to your question but I don't. I'm curious to read the replies. My HDTV which does not have an antenna attached (just cable) gets a lot more channels than my previous t.v. did.

Somebody told me that it's local stations broadcasting in HD over the air and I just happen to get them even without an antenna. I find it hard to believe but I don't know how this stuff works. These are channels way up in higher numbers too.

I also get the cable provided local channels twice. Go figure. For example, I get local ABC on 3 different channels. One shows as "cable" one shows as "HDTV" then the third shows again in "HDTV" way up at channel 115-5 and it has the best picture.

I don't know how this stuff works...

Joe

Re: HD TV Antana?

#3

Re: HD TV Antana?

Ernie Miller

>get an antana and see how much better the HD TV is from an antana with out cable. THey have to squeze the band width down on cable and it isn't as good. I have both cable and an antana with a roter so I can get some air signals that the cable company dosen't cover. but I was at a friend's house and the over the air HD aws better than cable and cheaper to boot.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#4

yes, they are different

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>A regular antenna has metal combs that can accept the wiggly waves of the old analog signal. The HD antenna has a metal plate with tiny holes, instead of slats (comb), to accept the 1's and 0's of the digital signal.

Ernie, can you tell I have no earthly idea ;)

But there SHOULD be a significant difference since the cost so much more ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: HD TV Antana?

#5

Re: yes, they are different

Ernie Miller

>not true my man The best one that a friend of mine has found so far is only $8.95 at Kmart much better than the $175 from radio shack and better than the $79 one form best buy. my problem is I will have to get another splitter for the cable antana hook up that has three lines in and two out for the TV and I haven't seen one that is remote operated. you do know what that means don't you? I don't have kids so I can't slap them acrost the head and tell them to change antanas. and you know the wife isn't going to go change it. (what's wrong with watching chick show on this channel?) I don't see HD comming to may house any time soon. I just don't see how they can be that differant? Will the 90 meter beam work from the short wave?

Re: HD TV Antana?

#6

Reminds me of how I missed my fortune in '76...

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>… or thereabouts. Sometime back in the '70s the CB craze was big and the FCC decided to expand the spectrum of the CB band from 23 channels to 40 channels. I don't know how big a slice in actual kHz that amounted to, but probably less than 200. The interesting thing was they established a cutoff date as I recall, after which you had to have a 40 channel radio. You couldn't use the 23 channel units anymore. Sort of gives a clue as to where the impetus came from to increase the spectrum, doesn't it?

Anyway, I had the idea of exploiting the ignorance of so many of the CBers by buying up a whole bunch of antennas, slapping 40 channel capable labels on them and selling them for 150% of what I paid for them. I'd have made a fortune. Never did it, though. Silly me—I thought it was unethical.

Rod

Re: HD TV Antana?

#7

No difference, but...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>There is no real difference in HD antennas vs. VHF and/or UHF antennas. Why? Because HD is broadcast within the same frequency range as VHF and UHF. This is going to change sometime in the near future, as the FCC is going to reclaim the VHF frequencies (channels 2-13). Now, the HD channel your TV displays is NOT necessarily the channel being broadcast. For instance our only local TV station, TV18 broadcasts non-HD over the air on channel 18, but their HD and other digital channel (Doppler radar) are broadcast on channel 11--but these two show as 18.1 and 18.2 (or 18-1 and 18-2 depending on the TV).

Because HD is broadcast over the same frequencies, you can use pretty much all the same antennas, cable and amplifiers, but once you get to the tuner end, things change. Old, non-HD TV requires a NTSC (U.S.) or PAL/SECAM (Europe/Asia) tuner to interpret the signals over-the-air. HD requires an ATSC tuner to interpret the digital signals. To receive cable HD, you need a 256-bit QAM tuner, whether that is in your TV or your cable box. My cable co. does not transmit the HD channels in a way that I can receive them without a cable box. Some cable companies transmit them sort of as if they are off an antenna, so if your TV has a QAM tuner you can receive them.

Personally, I mainly only watch HDTV via cable, but I did pick up a $20 rabbit-ear antenna (labeled HD, of course, but it's no different than others) just for grins to see if I could pick up TV18. The cable company doesn't give us the HD version of that particular (CBS) channel, just the non-HD. For CBS HD, we only get the Indy CBS affiliate. Since I'm only about 6-7 miles as the crow flies from the TV18 tower, I don't need much antenna or amplification to pick it up. With this same antenna, I can't really pick up much from the Indy antenna farms, as they are 50ish miles away. With a better antenna, those would be no problem, and if I spent the real big bucks, I might pick up Chicago and Cincinnati (130+ miles each) stations as well.

To dig around and find out more than you ever wanted to know, go here:

www.avsforum.com

Jason

Re: HD TV Antana?

#8

Hahaha!

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>I wondered if you would weigh in...when it comes to RF Tx/Rx, frequency is frequency is frequency, whether it's digital or analog. Either way you need an acceptable SNR.

What you need to do with the signal is a whole different story.

Jason

Re: HD TV Antana?

#9

Re: HD TV Antana?

James Dillon in MD

>Ernie,

As far as I know, and I sure am no expert, if your HDTV has a built-in HDTV digital tuner (the thing that picks the HDTV stations), you can use anything from rabbit-ears to some fancy, way too expensive "HDTV" antenna. In fact, a friend of mine at Xmas got a new HDTV with the built-in digital tuner and didn't want to pay the additional expensive cable HDTV price (he already has cable TV in his house too). So, he hooked up a set of rabbit-ears and lo, the reception of HDTV is great and even better, in some cases, than his regular definition cable channels. He is at a high elevation which probably helps. I think after a certain date, all TVs will have to have the HDTV digital tuner built-in. Of coarse there is the problem of few HDTV stations and poor programming. That exhausts my knowledge of HDTV; didn't take much 8-).

Jim

Re: HD TV Antana?

#10

Re: HD TV Antana?

Tom

>I didn't have time to check all the responses, so I may be repeating people, but there is no difference. I'm using the same old antenna in our attic that I was before. The digital transmission is much stronger, so my reception is almost perfect (100% strength). No filters needed. You may want to check out http://antennaweb.org/aw/welcome.aspx to get exact measurements and suggestions for aiming and buying an antenna. Put in your address and it will tell you what kind you need (how good of a one). You may not need much less, and you will probably find the one in your attic is more than sufficient. You may have to re-aim depending on your broadcast towers.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#11

Lee Gordon

Re: HD TV Antana?

Lee Gordon

>Your experience highlights an important shopping fact: taking electronics advice from the sales associate at the box store or Radio Shack makes no more sense than taking woodworking advice from the dude at the Borg. There is a slim chance that what they tell you will be correct, but don't bet the ranch on it.

If you already have an antenna on your roof, the most sensible thing to do is try it and see if it works before investing in any equipment upgrades. There is, however, a grain of truth in what you were told. As one or two others have pointed out, the channel number you displayed on a digital TV is not necessarily the channel the station is being broadcast on. This is really only significant when a station you've been pulling in with a VHF antenna broadcasts it digital content on a UHF frequency or vice versa. If your existing antenna is capable of receiving signals from both the VHF and UHF band (and especially if it can combine the two into a single wire) then you should be all set.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#12

Lee Gordon

Re: Reminds me of how I missed my fortune in '76..

Lee Gordon

>There's another, similar cutoff date looming. Many people are already aware that two years from this Sunday (February 18, 2009) all TV broadcasts in the United States must have been switched over to digital. However, in just two weeks (March 1, 2007) it will no longer be legal to manufacture or import televisions in the US without digital tuners.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#13

Re: HD TV Antana?

Doug in Denver

>Finally a question I know the answer to! There is no difference. I use a rooftop antenna that was on my house when I bought it - it's at least from the 70s, possibly the 60s. I can guarantee you that my HD recpetion is as good as anyone's in the city. I reasearched this before I bought my TV.

Digital signals are different than analog in that you either get a channel or you don't. There are not gradations of snowiness in between. There is a threshhold at which your need to get the signal, but once you get the signal, your reception will be as good as someone who lives on top of the transmitter.

Placment of the antenna is usually important. If you are line of sight to the trasmitters, you can get away with rabbit ears, if not, you may need to put it in your attic or roof. Location is everything in getting HDTV. Go to antennaweb and you can find out exactly how far you are and at what compass heading from every digital station in your area.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#14

Re: HD TV Antana?

Bob in GB

>I got this one. I am a Radio engineer. I have performed many upgrades to peoples antennas and know how to make them work best.

There is NO difference! All the antenna does is collect the radio signals and brings them to your TV. It is a passive device and does not know whether the signal is anlalog or digital.

That being said, new antennas work better because.....they are new. The little metal contacts that allow the antenna to fold up into the box eventually oxidize and degrade performance.

Another fact to be known is that all HDTV signals are in the UHF band (higher frequecncy) and probably need a little help regardless of being anlaog or digital.

Here is what I recommend. Get a new antenna, anything under $30 will do if you live withing 50 miles of the transmitter. I get my antennas at Fleet Farm in Green Bay, WI. Weingard or Channel Master are good too ordered on the internet. The next most important thing you may want is a preamplifier (NOT a booster - that is a different thing). I like the Channel Master 7777 (about $60). Use new RG6 coaxial cable for all connections. Thats it! You will find that things work better.

Another misconception. You need cable or Satelite to get HD. Absolutely not true! The best HD quality usually comes in over the air. I know a dish service provides 1080i, but this is esentially the same quality of 720p. HD is not transmitted all the time but when you get it you know!

Enjoy!

Bob

Re: HD TV Antana?

#15

Re: Hahaha!

Charles Self

>Well, OK, I'm on satellite. No cable here. I was on an antenna for 19 years before than. I simply do not understand how an antenna is going to give me improved HDTV across the same channels that satellite brings in, when with other antennas I could get only five channels locally.

In other words, as far as I can tell, it's a nonsense. Even if it works, all you get is local news and weather and some soaps. Of course, with satellite, all you get is news and weather and some soaps, plus pitches for junk jewelry, preachers and very few sporting events.

But, maybe, I should mount the new HDTV antenna on top of the satellite dish...? :)

Re: HD TV Antana?

#16

Re: HD TV Antana?

Ron

>There is no real effective difference. If your old one is fairly good it will work fine. When I first got my HD set I used a small FM antenna to check it out.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#17

The other side of the coin

Bill Howatt

>If you live in an area like I do where off the air HD broadcasts are non-existant you might consider buying just a monitor rather than a HDTV set. Since the signals are "tuned" by the satellite or cable-box the TV tuner is useless. You can feed the signals from the box to the monitor inputs. The monitor I am referring to is a "TV" without tuner made for this purpose not necessarily a computer monitor. They are a bit cheaper.

I admit I'm a bit cynical about HDTV. I have never heard anybody say they don't watch TV because of the poor resolution - the problem is the programming so the wrong end of the problem got fixed - a bit unkind perhaps. The real reason you have HDTV was mentioned above, they want to reclaim the frequency spectrum.

The oohs and aahs over the sharper picture remind me of a scientist I once helped getting better graphics for his presentation. After the conference I asked him how is presentation went, he said it was terrible. With some intrepidation I asked him what was terrible. He replied, " At question time they only asked me how I did my great graphics, nobody seemed to care about the content of my talk!".

Bill

Re: HD TV Antana?

#18

Lee Gordon

Re: Hahaha!

Lee Gordon

>If you subscribe to satellite for HD service, the non-broadcast programming such as ESPN, ESPN2, National Geographic HD, Discovery HD Theater, etc. are beamed from the satellite to your dish, decoded by your set-top box and delivered to your television through the red-gree-blue cable. However, your local HD channels are not given a round trip to outer space. They come in directly over the air (the way ordinary TV stations used to be in the pre-cable days) and are detected by a separate HD tuner built into the same set-top box. For optimal reception of your local ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox, CW, MyTV, and PBS stations in HD, you need to have an antenna connected to the box.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#19

Re: The other side of the coin

Ernie Miller

>I'm not in the market It all started as a argument at the office. it seems that I am the office Idot that don't know S%#T. but allways seems to be right most of the time.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#20

I don't know

Ernie Miller

>I don't know it that is completely true? I think the only differance would be with localy produced programing. The national showes are down loaded from satelite by the local stations just the same as he is with his dish. I know I'm the Office Idiot but tell me how I am wrong? I guess dish size and equipment could make a differance but I doubt it.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#21

Re: The other side of the coin

Dan Donaldson

>How about an easier (and cheaper) way? I just got rid of TV reception completely. Got tired ot the thing going all of the time, so we just cancelled the cable. Sure makes the house quieter ;-) I still have the high speed internet cable, but no TV. Don't miss it at all.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#22

Lee Gordon

Re: I don't know

Lee Gordon

>You are correct that the TV stations receive their network programming from a satellite, but I am talking about how the end user (i.e. you or me) gets the programs in his home. There are 3 basic methods of obtaining television programming in your home: over the air (referred to as OTA), cable, and satellite.

Getting your TV signal over the air is just as it has always been. TV stations transmit their signals from a tall tower and you pick them up with some sort of antenna, generally either rabbit ears or something mounted on the roof. That signal goes into the tuner that's built in to the TV set and you watch the result on the screen. Even high definition sets can work this way to receive local OTA hi-def stations. The only difference is there's an HD tuner built into the set in addition to the standard def tuner. And, of course, this gets you only the stations that broadcast over the air. To get things like ESPN, HGTV, DIY, etc., you still need either cable or satellite service.

Cable subscribers get everything (local stations and non-broadcast channels like ESPN) through the same "pipeline." The cable company receives all its programming at a central location (called the headend). Generally it gets non-broadcast programming from satellites and local stations fed to it directly from the stations via microwave links, although the cable companies sometimes pick up the local station OTA with an antenna. In either case, they send all the channels from the headend through the cable and into the box on top of your TV. Then the signal from that box goes through another cable into your TV and you can watch whatever channels your cable company provides, including all the HD programming if you have the appropriate equipment and cable subscription.

Satellite works a little differently. All the non-broadcast channels such as ESPN and Discovery (both standard definition and HD) are beamed from their headend up to the satellite and then beamed back down to the dish at your home, where they are converted into a signal that your TV can display. (Again, to receive HD you need the appropriate equipment and service agreement.) In most cases, local standard definition stations are also beamed from the satellite provider up to their satellites in space and then back down to you. They have sophisticated software to keep track what local stations their customers are entitled to receive so, for example, people in the Boston area get the local Boston stations, not ones from San Francisco. In the TV markets that are too small to justify the expense of equipment for uplinking and downlinking local channels, the customers get their ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox, etc. programming from network affiliated stations "imported" from various larger stations.

The way the satellite providers treat the digital versions of local stations (where the HD comes from) is a little different. In addition to the normal decoding equipment built into their set-top boxes, there is also an over-the-air hi-def tuner whose sole purpose is to receive the local digital stations. The set-top box combines the output of that tuner with all the programming being beamed from space and sends it all, seamlessly, to the TV. So, in order to receive, say, NUMB3RS in HD from your local CBS station (a program that the local station picked up from a the network via a separate satellite and sent, along with all the local commercials, etc. to its transmitter to be broadcast over the air), a satellite customer would have to get it directly off the air via the satellite box's built-in HD tuner.

I trust you are now more confused than before.

Re: HD TV Antana?

#23

Re: I don't know That did me in.

Ernie Miller

>

Re: HD TV Antana?

#24

Yabbut...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>...once you watch the Indy Colts in HD, you'll never go back. At least for me. Also, with these eyes I have, I like the much better resolution--easier to watch, especially when I'm tired. The only downside is that Fox News Channel isn't in HD. You also get Digital 5.1 Sound with HD (if the station is transmitting it), and a 16:9 picture, which I think looks better with our binocular vision (it seems more proportional to our FOV).

Jason