Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Band Saws blades and straight cuts

Posts

Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#1

Band Saws blades and straight cuts

bill tindal, E.TN

>Read the article in March Woodshop News on band saw blades and what is important and what is not. Summary, most everything you ever heard about running a band saw is irrelevant except the set in the teeth. The article probably explains why Timber Wolf blades work as they do. Also, flat cuts are vastly more important than smooth cuts, and quests for smooth cuts may lead to less than flat cuts. Again, tooth set is the single most determinant factor in flat(straight) cuts.

The article points to a web site with a high speed video of a band saw cutting and one presumes that it was through data acquired from video data that the conclusions were drawn.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#2

Learned that when I had my bandsaw mill.

Don Henthorn

>The guy who built it for me was upset because he had done countless measurements and adjustments to make certain every thing was lined up perfectly. He brought it to me and set it up and showed me how to use it and then left. I got wavy cuts. He couldn't understand it. Brought his tools and did the whole procedure again. Things were absolutely true. Still got wavy cuts. Of course I was new at it and he was a metal worker, not a woodworker so neither of us suspected the blade. Come to fing out it was the same blade he had used during the construction to test things and the teeth were not what they should be. I ordered a new blade and it cut straight as an arrow. When it started cutting wavy again I simply sharpened the blade and it cut like new again. If the teeth are correctly configured and sharp the band saw is going to cut straight. At least that is the way it works for me.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#3

Re: Learned that when I had my bandsaw mill.

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I think it was in Duginski's bandsaw book, that said that most any bandsaw blade will cut a circle, but it takes a sharp blade to cuts straight.

Mark

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#4

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>In the February, 2007, issues of Woodworkers Journal, Duginski and Gesicki have an article entitled Blade Tension (p 66). The most important points, to me, were 1, don't over tighten the tension as that will damage the bearings because there is no more shock absorbing left. Furthermore, probably the original springs are still good. And 2, that straight cuts depend largely on centering the blade on the tires.

I have tried this and found it actually does work! I carefully centered the blade, did a test for the fence, ran a cut. I then shut everything down, de-tensioned the blade and started over. The cuts still was straight. Since then I have made several actual cuts over a number of days. EVereything works just fine. Oh yes, I used a 1/2" 4tpi hook Oleson (sp?) blade.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#5

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

Falberg saw Co

>You missed the point. It's the *set angle* that's important. Woodshop News neglected to print the formula for calculating it so I'll post it here. The term *tooth set* is meningless outside the context of the blade's other attributes; such as width, thickness, and pitch.

My discoveries were based on seven years of custom-building hand-held bandsaws to cut Oak and Doug Fir timbers up to 21" thick.

What the article is trying to teach is that *resaw blade* is meaningless also, outside the context of what is being cut; and how thick it is.


img

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#6

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

Paul Waddle

>Hey,enjoyed your formula but pose a new question: Do the mfg'ers always make the angles same on each side? If so,why do some pull to one side and some do not(asumming everything else-tension tracking ctr etc is same)? thks pw.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#7

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

Falberg saw Co

>Thanks. You're posing two very interesting questions.

The first presumes all blades are made the same way, using the same machine tools, and following the same sequence in the manufacturing process. For instance: are the teeth sharpened BEFORE or AFTER the teeth are set? If before, the footprint would look like my drawing. If it's done after, the cross section would have a perpendicular profile across the leading edge. Which would work best I really don't know - but I mean to find out.

The second question involves too many variables: i.e., individual blade, blade type, blade brand? It could be a machine dynamic, OR a blade dynamic question.

For all the tons of literature available on the old-style cast iron band saws, there is very little information given about the blades and how they're made. Maybe they think we're too stupid to understand. Most blade manufacturers don't even publish a complete description of a blade's dimensions, much less the cuts for which it was designed. They seem to prefer that you just stick with the "Brand" without understanding WHY theirs is better than brand X.

I suspect it's because there's less competition in the blade market than there is in the band saw market. I bet you all know who the band saw experts are. Can you name a single expert on blades? (Clue: it ain't me.)

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#8

Thankyou

bill tindal, E.TN

>The text referred to something l assumed was this formula and keep looking for where it was.

My first band saw blades would not cut flat. I thought it was the saw. then I got another batch of blades from different supplier and they cut straight and flat. Thanks again for the formula and informative article.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#9

I didn't miss the point, your turn......

bill tindal, E.TN

>I didn't miss the point from your article, but I didn't explain it either in the above post, using instead "set" as an approximation of this critical parameter. I was trying to avoid a detailed technical summary of your article. But, I'll give it a try and you can improve on my effort. Most of these readers will not be able to see your article in Wood Shop News.

What is important is that during sawing the back of the blade not be constrained by the width of the kerf. As the blade cuts it wobbles/fluttters/flexes slightly in response to localized variance in the wood being engaged by the tooth tips. If during one of these flutters the back of the blade becomes constrained by the width of the kerf the blade will deflect and track away from a straight path. If the blade is not constrained by the width of the kerf these fluttters/ flexes are self correcting and the blade cuts straight, yielding flat boards/veneer. While not stated explicitly in the article it seems this same argument will apply to the guides. They should not constrain this micro flutter during cutting.

What determines whether the blade can micro flex/flutter freely, without kerf constraint, during cutting is the angle formed by the tip of the tooth and the back of the blade, as described in the formula. This angle is dependent on set, blade width and thickness. If one wishes to get the approximate concept across in a sentence one might say the blade needs sufficient set, because set is the only variable once the blade width and thickness is specified. However, it follows that a wider-thicker blade will need more set than a narrow one.

A table of minimum set vs blade width/thickness to achieve the critical set angle would be very handy to have at hand. We all can easily measure set.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#10

Re: I didn't miss the point, your turn......

Falberg saw Co

>Bingo! Very good, Bill. And you're also right-on about generating a table to cross-reference the various blades according to their set angle. It's an on-going project here at Falberg Laboratories (I use that term loosely) Doing so means somebody (and I guess that's me)has to buy a whole biggabuncha band saw blades, at great expense, since you need at least two of each to do it right. I ordered WoodSlicers a couple months ago and still have not received them so they're either really slow or they don't want Falberg Saw Co. to test their blades. If anyone here can get 110" blades from them, please do so; I'll be happy to re-imburse you. My competitors in the portable band saw business won't tell me where they get their blades either ( here again, any help is welcome) so I'm obviously rattling some cages.

"And that's a good thing"

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#11

Another thing that affects blade cutting angle

Don Henthorn

>as Falberg Saw has pointed out is how the teeth were cut. On some less expensive blades they are punched out on a press and this results in a ragged edge on the side the teeth were punched toward. This causes the blade to lead toward that side. If the teeth are cut, depending upon the method of cutting, they may still lead but not as much. If they were cut and ground they will not be as likely to lead. At least that is what I have been told.

Re: Band Saws blades and straight cuts

#12

Re: Another thing that affects blade cutting angle

Falberg saw Co

>That sounds real likely. If that was the case, I wonder if you could remove the burr with a "Maroon" polishing wheel. Just a light once-over, so as not to dull it. I don't use cheap blades like that and haven't seen burrs on any of my own blades, but I suppose they're out there. Probably the ones you see for $6.95 .

Can anyone confirm this?