Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

Posts

Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#1

Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

John Lucas

>I wish I had some tools to actually compare the Kryo tools to others but I don't. I did find this article interesting.


http://www.metal-wear.com/More%20Detail.htm#What%20Does%20Cryogenic%20Processing%20Do?

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#2

you don't need to try this myth

bill tindal, E.TN

>If the steel is properly heat treated to begin with there is no scientific evidence to show that this treatment provides any benefit. My information comes from the technical metalurgical staff at Crucible Steel Products, a major US supplier of tool steels, as well as Lee Valley, supplier of wood workng cutters.

There is an element of the population that chooses to believe in things that are not supported by scientific evidence and they will keep this and many other myths alive. For the rest of us, this myth is busted.

Cryogenic treatment can provide some benefit to some improperly heat treated steels, for example A2. But reliable heat treaters have found it cheaper to do it right to begin with.

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

Is there any evidence to the contrary?

steve antonucci

>I know that in the knife making world, it's an absolute assumption that it works. I've make a knife that was treated, and for what it's worth, it stays sharper longer than my untreated knives (subjectively). It's 440C stainless.

Rather than being a naysayer, send out a tool that you're familiar with and see if it makes a difference.

Steve

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#4

Re: Is there any evidence to the contrary?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>http://www.metalscience.com/techinfo_ASM.php

http://www.300below.com/site/advantage.html

http://www.cryogenic-tempering.net/

http://www.finishing.com/340/78.shtml

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#5

JL

Re:Ya'll want some liquid nitrogen to try it :)?

JL

>

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

FWIW- I'm a believer

steve antonucci

>Not sure if it came across that way, but I have all of the evidence I need on my belt loop every hiking trip I take.

Steve

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#7

Kindly Disagree Bill.

Brian in Brighton

>I have found that when heat treating particularly nasty parts, cryo is more stable than even vacuum chambers. Do these parts apply to woodworking, no. But I have had parts with sharp inside corners develop cracks during use until we have them cryo treated.

As far as tool blades and such, not worth the extra expense.

Just my 2 cents.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#8

Myth, Magic, or Science???

Greg Deavers

>Not mythic at all... Just a little hard for the PhD's to explain, and actually it's just NOT completely understood. All metal structures produce different micro (crystallin) structures in various heat treating, tempering, anealing, vacuum, no - gravity, and cryo environments.

Various tools (alloyed steels) that have been cryogenically treated are known to significantly out perform the non cryo-treated versions. For instance, oilfield drill bits, competition rifle barrels, and various blades as mentioned in the previous post all demonstrate a higher resistance to wear, and in some cases (I use the term loosely) "toughness" where maybe I should say "tempering".

Toughness is a function of Modulous of Elasticity. Heat treating does not Change the Modulous, and therefore does not make a metal "tougher". It makes metal harder or softer.

CRYO is just the "Low Heat" treating end of the Heat Treating world. Hope this sheds SOME light on a very deep and NOT YET understood subject.

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#9

Re: Also disagree that there is no advantage

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I was a manufacturing Engineer for about 40 years. From what I have seen Cryogenic treatments do have some effects on "properly" treated metals. We did purchase some steel from Crucible. We heat treated some materials in plant and sent some out. Our heat treaters had the latest vacuum kilns and equipment. The Cryogenic treatment serves as a stress reliever and makes the tool more stable. In my plant we did use this as a follow up to vacuum heat treat for certain mold and punch press die parts. It was statistically proven that the tooling had a longer life in our application. Our company would not spend the money without proof. It does appear certain steels, A2 is a good example, become more stable - hold an edge longer - after they "age" in normal use. This is attributed by many specialists (we had a gentleman in our organization with a doctorate in metallurgy) to the temperature fluctuations and shock introduced to the tool in use over a period of time relieving stresses in the material. Cryogenic treatment emulates this "aging". I have seen scientific data that validates cryogenic treatment of gun barrels. The improvement in target repeatability was quite significant. Is it worth the money to treat chisels? Doubtful, but certainly doesn't cause any harm. The tool and gage supplier I used just prior to my retirement also found that very precise gages were more stable during finish grinding after cryogenic treatment. He used it on select parts. We often worked in tolerances of +/-.0001 and occasionally to +/-.00005. Woodworking tools are not subjected to the same stresses that industrial tooling suffers, nor are the tolerances or other characteristics as critical, so the cryogenic treatment may not even have any noticable effect - But there is an effect.

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#10

Re: you don't need to try this myth

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Cryogenics will not "provide some benefit to some improperly heat treated steels, for example A2." If the steel is improperly heat treated nothing will save it.

Why do you temper steel in the first place... to make it less brittle.

Cryogenics works like a tempering process to transform the retained austinite that is brittle to martensite that is hard. When the transformation happens a carbide is formed. Cryogenics creates a very fine carbide call "eta carbides"

Crucible agrees that IF you are going to use a cryogenic treatment do it early in the tempering process. I have control over my process and use a cryogentic treatment between the first and second temper. There is more retained austinite in the steel then after the third temper.

Cryogenics will not replace tempering with heat, it only adds to the process.

Cryogenics doesn't work on all steels, you need the right alloys in the steel for it to work.

Back to the "dark side" messageboard

Doug

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#11

Relevant Data

bill tindal, E.TN

>Lee Valley saw no difference in performance in properly heat treated vs cryo treated plane irons. This conclusion supported by tech staff of a supplier of tool steel when I asked if it was worth the $$ to cryo treat the tools we were making. They did allow that it could compensate for poor control in heat treating on some steels.

Proper heat treating requires precise control of temperature at over 1000 degrees for tool steels, which requires very expensive equipment as well as precise timing.

The heat treating facility recommended by Crucible Products does not do cryo treating. Bos, the company that heat treats many custom knife makers material, does. Cryo is undeniably good marketing.

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#12

CrucibleExplanation

Greg Deavers

>Hi Bill,

Just a personal interest thing, as I have "followed" cryo, asked many questions to those "in the know", and tried to learn as much as I could.

I would be very interested in Crucibles explanation, and or how they would describe the "effect" of cryo treating alloys in terms of what it does to the steels micro-structure. I don't know that sharpening is or is not a good application - Maybe it is not??? I purchase Cryo plane blades, and have done no personal testing, although, I find it easier to get and keep a fine edge "longer" in the HARD (Curly Maple, Purple Heart, Mesquite) woods that I work. This may not really be a "wear resistance" application as much as a alloying/hardness micro structure issue.

However, I do know that it increases wear resistance characteristics through treating the items I mentioned earlier.

There is too much data to be found where wear resistance applied cryo treatments work, but I have yet to find someone to explain in scientific/technical terms HOW it works. Not enough time on this site to go through it all. Just a personal interest.

Your thoughts?

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#13

Re: Relevant Data

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Bill, please double check your information. Cryogenics will not compensate for a mistake in the heat treating process. It needs to be done right start to finish, heating and cooling temperatures need to be controled. Hardening steel is slow process that will reach 2,000 degrees with tempering temp's around 1,000. Induction heating requires timing to be done right.

Re: Cryongenic hardening *LINK*

#14

clarification

bill tindal, E.TN

>Well, I am finding that one needs to be precise in one's wording in raising controversial issues on this forum. Most of this discussion has been irrelevant to woodworking.

1. My discussion relates to woodworking tools, not dies, gun barrels and the like, nor the effect on steels not used for woodworking tools. Thought that would be obvious. So we are talking about O-1, A-2 M-2, plane irons and chisels and maybe jointer knives. Lee Valley did the testing on plane irons and could not see an effect. End of story as far as I am concerned. The cryo process is very cheap, costing a fraction of a dollar per tool. If it yielded an obvious benefit there would be no controversy and everyone would use it.

2. Allow me change "improper" to "less than optimum". As I recall the conversations with Crucible and others, some steels like A2 must be quenched precisely to get the optimum hardened structure or the tempering step will not yield an optimum material. A less than optimum quenching can be corrected more or less by cryo treatment. It follows that cryo could improve products from less than optimum/precise heat treating operations. On the other hand, CPM-3V, a steel we have intensively evaluated, is nearly impossible to not quench optimally, and one would never expect a cryo-benefit with this steel.

In the grand scheme of things if you want to make your fortune selling the best plane iron ever made would you improve upon an optimally heat treated O-1 plane iron by changing alloy, going to particle steels or cryo treating? Pick only 2 for the biggest effect. I would pick the first two and they could yield a 2X improvement in edge life according to actually planing data generated by Elliot.