Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

MDF question

Posts

MDF question

#1

MDF question

Mark Kuzee

>Well..my wife just found out this past weeekned that we have a bathroom that needs some spruce up. She suggested I make some new drawer fronts and doors for the sink cabinet. She will be painting them so I suggested MDF. I asked if she needed any edging done to ease the corners and she said no that she is looking for a real clean look.

I have little experience with MDF and I am wondering if it will be prone to chipping along the corners. I would think just a small chamfer would do the trick.

Can you provide some advice?

Mark

Re: MDF question

#2

Re: MDF question

RobV

>MDF won�t hold up around water/moisture.

Re: MDF question

#3

Re: MDF question

Charles Sharp

>You might want to consider and exterior version of MDF such as MED-X. If you put a radius on all the edges & outside corners you shouldn't have much of a problem with chipping. I would still wrap the door edges in solid wood and profile it, but that's just me.

Re: MDF question

#4

Re: MDF question

J. Zimmerman

>Your assumption relative to MDF is correct...Like most materials given sufficient negative reinforcement it will show the stress with dents/fractures/chip-0uts. However; when I made cabinets for the shop which were painted, I used spackle on the edges, applied a the proper primer all over, and used Hammerite as a finish coat. I know that finish may not be appropriate for your use, but it has been remarkably durable in the shop.

JZ

Re: MDF question

#5

Re: MDF question

J. Robison

>I would think that without some edge treatment, it would be prone to losing a chunk at some point if it gets hit right, especially on a vanity.

I made a slab door out of MDF for a small closet in my bathroom. It's primed and painted on all sides. I've never sensed any problem related to humidity.

Re: MDF question

#6

Re: MDF question

Bill Howatt

>Even though MDF and water don't mix I think if you seal all 6 surfaces with paint you won't have a problem in your application.

I would never leave a sharp corner on anything because it is too easy for a bump to make a noticeable indentation even if nothing chips off. Even the smallest radius on an edge is much, much more robust than a sharp edge. Also, it is possible to get an edge on MDF that will cut skin.

Bill

Re: MDF question

#7

Don't do it.

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>MDF on its own is not the right material for this job.

Spackle and paint can give a good looking edge but it still won't be durable enough to use in a bathroom. The drawers or doors will inevitably get a chip somewhere (most likely an edge) and then you will discover how badly MDF reacts to moisture.

Yes a small chamfer will help, but that's kinda contrary to the clean look your wife wants.

MDF edges are easily damaged and you really do need to put on some sort of edging strip.

Put a "sizing coat" of thinned yellow glue on the edge of the MDF, let it dry, then glue wood strips on the edge.

If you're planning to paint the doors, you don't need to fuss with miteres on the corners. Either handplane the edge strips to size before gluing or trim flush with a router after gluing. Because you're going to paint, you can even cheat and use a bit of filler for any minor imperfections.

The usual precautions and advice about MDF apply:

* - use the best possible dust protection.

* - it soaks up finish, so use a good oil-based primer/undercoat.

* - the edges soak up glue, so use thinned glue as a size.

* - edges damage easily, so handle with care in the shop.

regards

Angus Barclay.

Re: MDF question

#8

Not all mdf is equal

Alister

>I found this out as the stuff made in Canada machines better and I was surprised to see that scraps of mdf from home depot swelled to twice their normal size and the Canadian stuff remained unchanged when sitting in the bottom of the dumpster after a rain storm.

I get the Canadian stuff from Russel plywood my sheet goods supplier.

Re: MDF question

#9

moisture experiment

Yonak

>The fragility of MDF aside, I did a moisture experiment for a customer of mine. I put pieces of 1/2" ultralight MDF (from a Canadian source) into a bucket of water, one for 3 hours and one for 7 hours. When I took them out and dried them, I didn't see any difference between them and unsubjected MDF.

Re: MDF question

#10

Look who's talking...!

HC Sakman

>How are you Alister!?

Long time no see.

Chico...

Re: MDF question

#11

Re: moisture experiment

Jay St. Peter - Southern MD

>I did a similar experiment, only more in line with what happens over time. I took a piece of regular borg MDF and left it outside in my shop stairwell. I put it out in April. After a few months (with plenty of rain) it looked fine. By fall, it was getting a little ragged around the edges and was measurably thicker than the piece it was cut off of for the first time. During the winter it got buried in a snow bank and blew up to about double thickness. It did warp pretty easily, but my opinion is that there's more paranoia than reality about it. It won't swell to 3x it's thickness with minor humidity changes. It clearly isn't weather resistant, but I think it is fine for indoor use pretty much anywhere.

Jay St. Peter

Re: MDF question

#12

laminate it!

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>go to any DIY place. most of the stuff is particle board with a laminate.

you could use popular if you want paint.

Exposed MDF in a high moister area is not a good idea. unless you are trying to incubate mold.

Re: MDF question

#13

Re: MDF question

Doug in Denver

>If you are unfamiliar with MDF, consider not using it for other reasons than those stated. If your power tools are in your basement, or any other place where you don't want MDF dust forever, forget about it and use solid wood. I don't care how good your dust collection is, MDF dust is about like talcum powder, and goes everywhere. And don't even think about using it without a really good dust mask. Not only is is it dusty, but it has nasty chemicals in it. Finally, depending on what MDF you use, it is hard on cutting edges - even carbide ones. Plus MDF is really heavy, doesn't hold screws well, etc. I hardly ever use it. Hate the stuff (in case you couldn't tell).