Tool investment value going down? (long)
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Please tell me that I have not fallen into the "good old days" tirade because of my age :-)
Closing in on 20 years of tool buying, lately I've been thinking more and more about how much less value is retained from our tool purchases... 20 years ago, one could buy a Unisaw, use it for a few years, and sell it without much loss compared to the original money outlay, partly because the market was pretty static in terms of features and performance. But competition has picked up from all corners, and now your old tool lacks features present on newer machines, and good luck getting something anywhere close to the purchase price.
Example I: I bought my Delta 22-540 planer a dozen or so years ago. Back then I paid $549, $150 off the regular price (all prices Canadian in here, use them as relative), and had I sold it a year or two later (like if I had decided to get a stationary planer) I could have got much if not all of the purchase price. Today, with improvements in technology and features I'd be lucky if I could sell that planer for $100 (including three sets of knives). I'm pretty sure that someone who bought a Unisaw in 1980 could have sold it for close to purchase price in 1992...
Example II: Around the time I bought that planer, there was no way to get a 1/2" shank router for under $300. For those who remember the "top of the line" Craftsman router (3 1/4 HP, variable speed, sold here for $450 or so for years), there was a "little brother" available (same looks, but single speed, and 12 instead of 15 amps) that sold for $379. I lucked out on a good sale and got that one for $179. Now if I decided to sell this router I'd be lucky if I could get $50 for it... Especially when a retailer here offers a fully featured 3 1/4" router for $79 (never mind the quality difference, those who are attracted by such cheap machines do not pay attention to what makes a quality machine).
Example III: in 1996 I bought a Delta 14" bandsaw, 3/4 HP, open stand, bare, no fence, nothing else, for $699, which was a terrific deal at the time. Over the years I've added "the works" to that saw, from the riser block to the 3 HP motor to quick release tension lever, etc. All in all, adding it all up, my saw has cost me close to what a brand new X5 saw would set me back, but there are so many players now in that field (including Delta, with their Chinese offering) that there would not be any remote chance to recoup more than half my investment (if I'm lucky) if I ever decided to sell that saw (fat chance, I love it...). Still...
Not that long ago one could argue that imported machinery wasn't built up to the standards of North American equipment, which justified the higher price. My impression is that this is less and less true, mainly because of competition. Steel City sells far east products that are rated as being as good or better as the established players, regardless of origin.
Even though I've never thought of my tool purchases as an investment, it's still kind of depressing to see stuff that I did fork out good money on it will never give me the resale value that good tools used to provide...
What's your take on this ?
DC



