Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Tool investment value going down? (long)

Posts

Tool investment value going down? (long)

#1

Tool investment value going down? (long)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Please tell me that I have not fallen into the "good old days" tirade because of my age :-)

Closing in on 20 years of tool buying, lately I've been thinking more and more about how much less value is retained from our tool purchases... 20 years ago, one could buy a Unisaw, use it for a few years, and sell it without much loss compared to the original money outlay, partly because the market was pretty static in terms of features and performance. But competition has picked up from all corners, and now your old tool lacks features present on newer machines, and good luck getting something anywhere close to the purchase price.

Example I: I bought my Delta 22-540 planer a dozen or so years ago. Back then I paid $549, $150 off the regular price (all prices Canadian in here, use them as relative), and had I sold it a year or two later (like if I had decided to get a stationary planer) I could have got much if not all of the purchase price. Today, with improvements in technology and features I'd be lucky if I could sell that planer for $100 (including three sets of knives). I'm pretty sure that someone who bought a Unisaw in 1980 could have sold it for close to purchase price in 1992...

Example II: Around the time I bought that planer, there was no way to get a 1/2" shank router for under $300. For those who remember the "top of the line" Craftsman router (3 1/4 HP, variable speed, sold here for $450 or so for years), there was a "little brother" available (same looks, but single speed, and 12 instead of 15 amps) that sold for $379. I lucked out on a good sale and got that one for $179. Now if I decided to sell this router I'd be lucky if I could get $50 for it... Especially when a retailer here offers a fully featured 3 1/4" router for $79 (never mind the quality difference, those who are attracted by such cheap machines do not pay attention to what makes a quality machine).

Example III: in 1996 I bought a Delta 14" bandsaw, 3/4 HP, open stand, bare, no fence, nothing else, for $699, which was a terrific deal at the time. Over the years I've added "the works" to that saw, from the riser block to the 3 HP motor to quick release tension lever, etc. All in all, adding it all up, my saw has cost me close to what a brand new X5 saw would set me back, but there are so many players now in that field (including Delta, with their Chinese offering) that there would not be any remote chance to recoup more than half my investment (if I'm lucky) if I ever decided to sell that saw (fat chance, I love it...). Still...

Not that long ago one could argue that imported machinery wasn't built up to the standards of North American equipment, which justified the higher price. My impression is that this is less and less true, mainly because of competition. Steel City sells far east products that are rated as being as good or better as the established players, regardless of origin.

Even though I've never thought of my tool purchases as an investment, it's still kind of depressing to see stuff that I did fork out good money on it will never give me the resale value that good tools used to provide...

What's your take on this ?

DC

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#2

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

DB

>Look at it this way, the only time that a tool looses its value is when you do not use it. People now have more disposable income and would rather pay a little more money and get a brand new tool than a used (possibily abused) one. The tools are getting so cheap (both cost and quality) that it is hardly worth buying a used tool.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#3

Investment?

Hoa Dinh

>I never thought about resale value when buying a tool. To me tools are expenses, not investments.

To me, not only being expenses, they are hobby expenses, which I don't attempt to justify.

I often joke with my wife, a avid gardener, that growing tomatos gives her a sense of richness. Noone with normal income would buy tomatos at $10/lb ;-).

Maybe we should think about woodworking that way.

-- Hoa

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#4

Re: Other tool investment value going down? (long)

joey

>Being a photographer is similar. Since switching to digital, all my film cameras are on the shelf, not to mention the expense of the new equipment. Then there's the computer hardware and software associated with processing images, again darkroom on the shelf. Also the obsolescence and depreciation is radical in comparison. Something to be said for buying more hand tools. Joe PS What about our autos?

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#5

Re: PS - What about our autos

David Yoho

>It depends on which autos. If the recent Barrett-Jackson auction is any kind of measurement, there's proof some cars are worth much more today than when they were new.

David

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#6

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

David Yoho

>Hi Denis,

Like someone else said, I don't look at the purchase of power tools for my shop as an investment as such. I buy based on need and buy the best my budget will allow at the time. Just like many other items we buy new, eventually the price goes down for a number of reasons.

I remember when the cost of a new (at the time) state of the art VCR would set you back over $500. Only a few years ago you could get one with all the bells and whistles for under $100.

However, I hear what you're saying about what you can expect to get for a tool you pay a hefty price for new and what it will bring now if you want to sell it. I've still got my original 22-540 planer just sitting under my workbench, since replacing it with the 22-580. I know I couldn't sell it for anywhere near what it cost new. However, the way I see it, that planer afforded me the opportunity to make some pretty good money from its use and believe it owes me nothing. I'll hold on to it until either I find a need for it again or someone who wants a good entry level planer at an affordable price.

David

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#7

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>My take on money is that it does not really exist. It is just a system we have set up to make bartering easy. Time does not exist either; it is just a system we have set up to measure the speed at which we age. (This is why time travel is not possible, but that is for a later thread I guess. Time is not a fourth dimension). These two things when viewed in a true perspective I think would cause a paradigm shift in a lot of people's lives. I doubt that there will ever be a time in my life when I do not have something of value to trade to someone else to earn more money. Money is actually made to spend, not to hoard. I think it is important to invest money for the future, but by all means put it to use. Loan it to someone else so they can use it. They will pay you a little bit for it. When I was a little boy, our family had a five gallon bucket full of misc "toys"; empty thread spools, wood scraps, and a few very beat up little toy trucks, and we occasionally had a bicycle to share between the eight of us when the tires weren't flat. Now, my toys have improved vastly. I have a whole shop full of toys. I think they would not be nearly as much "fun" to play with if I was overly concerned about the speed at which my body is aging and whether I would be able to trade my toys for about what they cost me. That's my story, and I am sticking to it.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#8

Value going down? No Way.

Virgil Johnson

>Its all in how you value the item. If you know how to use the tool and actually make something with the decive then the tool is an investment that will pay for itself many times over year after year. If you buy the latest router/machine just to post about it here at WC then you are losing money. I have a Bosch 1611 plunge router that I bought new in 1990 for around 200.00. Its street value is about 50.00. Its value to me is still that of a new tool as it is in good shape and I've used it on umpteen projects and will only be replaced when it wears out.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#9

Inflation & Walmarting

bill tindal, E.TN

>One factor affecting your observations is inflation, which in the late 70's early 80's was at times over 10%/year. More recently inflation has been very low.

A second factor that has about run its course is the "Walmarting" of manufacturing. Retailing is concentrating into a few huge companies and the purchasing power of these companies can drive prices down by forcing companies to seek lower cost manufacturing (by innovation and lowering manufacturing costs).

These two factors have indeed resulted in tool deflation in the recent past.

Perhaps a third factor is the closing of many N. American furniture plants which has dumped a large quantity of used machinery on the market. I was in a used machinery store a few months back and they had dozens of used table saw fences in a rack, $50 each.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#10

Agree

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I'm kinda new at this woodworking thing. Before that, for over thirty years, I shot, collected, lived and breathed muzzleloaders.

I started cheap with an Italian import or two, but at the time burglars took me out of the hobby (lifestyle actually)just about everything in the safe was custom built or original. Because I tended to buy the high end stuff, if I wanted to sell off a few to buy something else it was hard to even recoup what I'd spent because the market was small. There is a segment that thinks the mass produced junk is top of the line and they aren't going to shell out enough to buy three off the shelf guns for just one.

It didn't bother me much because I very seldom wanted to sell anything. If they had not been stolen, several of the guns would now be worth 200% or more of what I paid for them. The one muzzleloader that was recovered (five years later and almost by accident)was one I paid $750 for in the late seventies. I sold it to a dealer at Friendship for $1000,he put $1800 on it and sold it rather quickly.

But you know what? Had they not been stolen I would probably still have them even though I could make a lot of money selling them. As such it would make no difference if the value was more or less. The value would have been what they were worth to me.

Postscript.

When the one gun was recovered it rekindled a spark of interest and I made an attempt to get back into the hobby. I bought an early style .50 flintlock which in about four years has been shot less than 100 times. The recovered gun was a really nice flintlock smoothbore. I'd sold everything it took to shoot it so I sold it and used the money to buy a .36 southern flintlock for plinking. In three years, I've NEVER shot it. Now I've decided that the shooting game is part of my past and I'm going to try to get most of my money back on the two guns by including all the "stuff" it takes to shoot them. I need the money more than the rifles....there's this lathe I want to buy.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#11

The Flip Side

Tom MacGregor

>The cash value of used hand tools and machinery does appear to have dropped over the last few years, but I use that fact to my advantage. I've learned how to fix wires, cords, brushes, bearings & etc., and how to fine tune good machines that were never set up properly. I buy almost nothing new, and only based on how the investment will impact my work - not what it will sell for later. I find restorable 40's & 50's era stuff available for salvage prices.

I've found that many buyers shy away from used equipment because they don't know how to evaluate or repair it. I don't deal professionally, but have turned over enough used equipment - that I can guarantee works - to have outfitted my shop well for pennies on the dollar. And I can resell just about anything I have for more than I have into it.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#12

Think of it as helping a beginner

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>When I got started in my own shop, I purchased a number of tools from woodworkers who were moving on to bigger and better tools. Sure, they didn't get anywhere near the price they paid for the tools. But, I came and moved the tool out (so no work for them). I also think that many people like seeing their tools (which they've spent a lot of time with) go to another woodworker who will continue to use and care for it. Any money you get is just nice.

Once we're ready to move on with new tools, it's because the old ones have served their purpose, but can not perform the job expected of them. Let those tools go to another woodworker (cheaply, or heck, donate it - makes you feel good) who will continue to use them. Really good tools may do this several times.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#13

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

Bob Dodge

>Hi DC,

This is such a broad topic, and can be seen from so many perspectives. Buying "new", selling "used", regional availability, "bench-mark" machines like a General 350, etc.

A lot of the Asian imports, may indeed be cheaper, but as far as I'm concerned, they ARE cheaper. Not only in price, but overall component quality. To many a new-comer, a saw is a saw, so "why should I pay twice as much for a General?" The guy who asks that, just doesn't know, and he'd probably not offer much for your "used" General. A knowledgeable woodworker would probably take a much closer look at your saw, and assess the value according to how well it's been taken care of. You couldn't "give" me some of the "Busy-Bee" saws (and similar so-called clones) I've looked at. If they were indeed "clones", they'd have the same quality components, not just a similar external resemblance.

I'm sure there are a lot of folks who think that by buying the cheaper "clone", they're getting the same machine at a cheaper price, and saving money. Fact is, they're often not. The duty-cycles are not even remotely close. This isn't to say that many aren't decent machines; many are totally adequate for a hobbyist. A pro, or semi-pro, would definitely consider bullet-proof reliability, ease of use (cursors/handwheels, etc) Details like mitre-track "slop", flatness of the tables, flange-faced arbors, balanced and machines pulleys, quality belts, accurate trunnions, stress-relieved cast-iron tables, top-quality bearings. In short, all the things that many new-comers will only learn about the hard way.

A General 350 today, is still a General 350. It hasn't gotten any cheaper. Sure you can look at a General International 50-260, and externally, it looks very similar to the General 350, but one look under the hood will show you it's not. What sets the G.I. apart from many of the cheaper "clones", is that they'll often use the same accessories, such as the General T-Square fence. I'd certainly pay more for the G.I. than I would for a cheaper knock-off, but, I still would have no illusions that the saw is the "same" as a 350, for less money. Where would I rank the Steel-City offering? Well, after looking at one at J.R. Normand, I see it roughly in the same category as the G.I. Much better than the cheaper clones, but no General 350 or UniSaw. Like it or not, it still has no NEMA rated electricals, nor the same quality internals. Would I buy one before a "Busy-Bee" or similar? Yes, in a heart-beat.

Quality hand-tools are in my opinion, an "investment". One look at E-Bay resale-value confirms it. It's not rare to see Lie-Nielsen hand-planes, going for more than the cost of "new", or within 90% of new. That being the case, your actual "cost" of using and owning such a wonderful tool, is actually 10% or less of the price paid (if you re-sell).

You mentioned the Delta 14" bandsaw. That Delta is far-and-away the best 14" saw ever designed in my opinion. Everybody and his brother has produced a so-called "clone", but, are they really? There are so many iterations of that saw, with so many electrical packages, that you simply cannot state that all Delta 14" saws are the same. Some guys may not give a hoot about electricals, but I certainly do. I also absolutely love the arrangement of the lower blade-guides on the Dealta, compared to the so-called "knock-offs". Virtually all of them, place the thrust-bearing under the table, and the blade-support guides below the thrust-bearing. Delta, is the only manufacturer I've seen that places the angled side support guides directly under the table-top. A much better design in my opinion. You're just not going to beat a Delta when it comes to "cutting to a line".

You mentioned the big Sears/Craftsman 3 1/4 HP router. I had one of those. Variable-speed plunge router. I dumped it. Why? Because the first time I used it, it had a dead armature. Sears wanted $70 to fix it (plus tax, and 2 trips to drop it off/pick it up) and 2 weeks repair-time. It was brand-new, never used, but just over a year old by the time I needed to use it. Guarantee had expired by days. My Porter-Cable routers, and the Makita, have never given me a lick of trouble. For me, "confidence" in a tool is a big part of my purchasing decision. Pleasure of use, also ranks right up there.

Bob

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#14

Re: Think of it as helping a beginner

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>I give this subject some thought on occasion, usually when I'm re-evaluating my shop content worth for insurance purposes. I can say that some tools can be considered investments, their worth remains the same or increases, namely some hand tools. I have some older, antique tools that can only go up in value in my opinion.

It's the machinery that is iffy. American iron will always command a higher price in my opinion, because historically it has been this way. The imported machinery is very marketplace driven, hard to say which way the pricing is going to go. Steel prices are on the rise, so all stationary machinery pricing should rise, this automatically increase the value of any machines we already have in our shops. On the other hand, competition is fierce with the imports ( China ), and every time I see a lower price I tell myself, "it can't go any lower".. but it does.

This import pricing situation will in the near future begin to stabilize , then we have a better indication of how much our machines are worth.

I don't want to wander from the topic, but what bothers me is that N. American mnfctrs. are making a beeline for China to offshore their manufacturing and subsequently generate a bigger bottom line in profits .. What happens if all of a sudden the China- N.American political situation changes ( deteriorates) and doh!! we have almost everything coming in from there. This can easily occur BTW. They are slowly on the path to becoming a superpower, and historically we are enemies with "other" superpowers.

Anyway, just a concern.

Back on topic...

Maybe we need to look at power tools/ machinery as our cars. We drive them, use them up, and replace them for the latest and greatest new model. The important part of this equation is that we use the tools for a long while.. If pureyl purchased as investments, well, this might not work any more nowadays except for some boutique hand tools.

Having said all this , I would never give up my older Delta 14 in. bandsaw ( tricked out with riser and 1HP motor) and my older Unisaw.

Norman

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#15

Investment?

John in New Mexico

>Why worry about it? Surely all the use you've had from a tool that you're ready to upgrade has some value? Get what you can, view the difference as "rent" if you have to justify it, and get back to work (with the upgraded tool).

Isn't that the point of owning these things anyway?

John

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#16

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

Jesse in New Mexico

>Interesting thread. I view good handtools as an investment, and usually make some profit when I sell them. Most modern power tools just aren't investment quality. For instance, our "lunchbox planers" take a lot of abuse and aren't made to industrial quality standards - I would be very leery of buying a used one and wouldn't expect to get close to what I paid for my used one.

But that's not really the point. Most of us are in it for the fun or utility of making furniture. When a tool is no longer useful, I sell it to free up shop space as much as for the money. When I'm pondering whether I really "need" that shiny new tool, my reckoning is that if it doesn't work out, I can probably sell it for 50-75% of what I paid for it, which minimizes the risk a little.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#17

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Don't know Dennis - the only tools I have sold have been the cheaper ones I have replaced. I sold a Grizzly 6" jointer for $100 with new blades installed. Don't recall what I paid for it 'bout 15 years ago. I gave several tools to family & friends. Craftsman router, drills, fairly new Jorgenson miter saw I no longer used etc. I have built up my shop so that the equipment is the best I can afford, in the hope of leaving it all to my youngest son who is also into woodworking. I do think there is a better percentage return on "investment" for the top quality equipment and good hand tools, but you have a lot more money invested. I would not trade my US built Unisaw for a new X5, nor my Powermatic 90 lathe for a new Asian clone. I do have clone equipment, as some just are not available in the US for even a close to reasonable amount. I bought a Grizzly 8" jointer for around a grand with segmented carbide cutterhead. I could probably get $7 or 8 hundred out of it within the next 3 years. I have several Stanley planes and some old woodies. These were bought cheap at auctions and I could sell them for more than I paid (not considering the many hours invested in tuning them). However, I know Woodworking is not a paying hobby for me. I will never produce enough furniture etc. to recoup my investment. My son sure will. I also like to fish. Can't say how much I have invested in rods, reels, line, lures, bait, travel costs etc. , but I am quite sure I could have replaced the lbs of fish we have eaten with Lobster and Caviar at 5 star restaurants and still put cash in my pocket. However, I enjoy fishing, I enjoy woodworking, and won't count the money spent as an investment. I do have some money invested in my IRA, retired last year, used some of it to buy the new jointer and MM 16 bandsaw. Life's too short to count pennies. Doubt I have many years left and can't take any with me, kids are all doing at least as well as I am financially, so I plan on enjoying what the good Lord provided.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#18

How about this...?

HC Sakman

>DeWalt 621 was $375~399 5 years ago. (just router with 2 collets) Today, it's $275 w/ edge guide that was selling for almost $100 seperately 5 years ago. Go figure!

Same thing w/ 625. It was $500, now $379!

Triton was $450 3 years ago, today is $199! All prices are Cdn.

Were they making too much money back then? Manufacturing countries are still the same. All these Dewalt routers still made in England, Italy and Switzerland. (I don't know anout Triton)

Chico...

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#19

Going used, and not worrying about "value"

wilbur

>The issue of possible resale is one reason why I decided to go with used equipment when outfitting my shop. I was able to find a Delta Milwaukee 11" drill press for $50, a Walker Turner 12" lathe with drives, faceplates, and turning tools for $300, and a Walker Turner 16" bandsaw for $350. All of these machines are way overbuilt compared to similar machines today. For example, the wheel covers on my bandsaw are made of cast iron.

I also think that the only way to recoup your initial purchase cost for power equipment is to buy used. Buying new power equipment is like buying a new car. Once you drive it off the lot, you lose a good chunk of its value.

I wouldn't sweat the issue too much, though. The "value" of anything you have only matters if you really are going to sell it. You said that "there would not be any remote chance to recoup more than half my investment (if I'm lucky) if I ever decided to sell that saw (fat chance, I love it...)." Well, if you love your saw and are never going to sell it, it doesn't matter if it's worth close to its original purchase price on the used machinery market, or only $5.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#20

Re: Investment?

Ernie Miller

>Them are cheap home grown tomatos. with land prices around here it cost me alot more than that to grow ours. I like you way of thinking. keep it up

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#21

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

Michael Wilkins

>Don't think of your purchases as investments. Anything that does not hold its value, and even loses value, cannot be considered an investment. Just ask a stock broker.

Use, depreciation, lack of features, better quality alternatives, and competition from across the oceans will all contribute to the loss of value a tool/machine suffers.

An unfortunate casualty of our global economy.

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

#22

Re: Tool investment value going down? (long)

jmohnike

>I look at it this way. Even if I paid 5 times the amount new for a tool over time the $ saved on home improvement, making and restoreing furniture the tool will pay for itself. However if you factor in the number of hours you have used the tool it comes out to "cheap" entertainment in persons book.

If you are looking at investing in tools I feel you will have to look at the old heavy metal. Two weeks ago I sold my band saw and old Yates American 36" wheels, 8' 2" tall all original equipment, nothing missing for $1,000.00 I paid $100.00 25 yrs ago and seldom used it.