Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Now for something completely different

Posts

Now for something completely different

#1

Now for something completely different

Dick Coers

Our community art group is having the annual member show starting in about 12 days. All I need is a clear coat and will be ready. This is a standing piece, 3"x10"x24", with the bottom angle cut so that it leans over. It could be wall mounting with appropriately strong fastener. Silver maple, 3 center turning, chainsaw texture, dyed black, then heavy sanding to knock down the chainsaw texture peaks, then red dye.

I'm so far out of my comfort range, it's crazy. I use this yearly member show to do something REALLY different.

I would really appreciate critique and comments.


Re: Now for something completely different

#2

Re: Now for something completely different

Cyril Griesbach

Dick, I really like it. The tilted angle keeps it from being ordinary yet the three partial curves on the bottom give that angle purpose. I like the deep texture but would have preferred the bowl like parts without the black color which would give them a more distinct look and popped out of the piece. Well done. I hope you enjoyed your leap from your comfort zone.

Re: Now for something completely different

#3

Re: Now for something completely different

john lucas

Dick very interesting to see your expanding your horizons. I like the concept. It might be the photography but the center circles just look blurred and not well defined in the photo. they seem like they would be focal points but it's hard to look at them and my eye goes to all the black chainsaw marks and the two curved lines at the bottom. I do like the tilt and overall shape. Perhaps some small detail lines at the top of the center circles would have pulled your eye in better. not sure. Anyway it's an interesting piece and I like the direction your going with it. I find pieces like this extremely hard to do because your eye needs a place to go and then needs some direction to flow around the piece. I tried for years to do things like this in photography where mostly what you see is texture and line and it's really really hard to pull off successfully. Keep at it.

Re: Now for something completely different

#4

Re: Now for something completely different

Hal Taylor

Dick, I really, really like this piece, and it's good to sometimes get out of our comfort zones. I looked at it upside down and think I, IMHO, prefer the curved elements at the top. Also, I'd hang it more verticlly making the top and bottom askew.

Re: Now for something completely different

#5

Re: Now for something completely different

Dick Coers

Thanks Cyril and John. There were a lot of challenges with this piece. First was the fear during the turning. It was grossly out of balance, so kept the speed at 200 rpm. Then I fought the simple/too much detail battle in my mind. Finally, the color turned it into a completely different turning. It had a simple look, even with just the black. But when I sanded and applied the red, it visually exploded! I had no perception of the size of the texture marks till that moment. The photo is horrible. When it gets installed in the gallery, I'll get a better picture. One thing for sure, if they focus a light over it, no one will miss seeing it. Both your comments are greatly appreciated. I'm confused about what I did here, and what to do to improve. It feels like some professional art education would help just about, NOW!

Re: Now for something completely different

#6

Different pic 3/4 view and oiled

Dick Coers

Completely finished now. It's very odd that I am ready early for a show. The curator will be pleased that it doesn't smell like finish for a change! Took a picture with a little of the side showing. Not a great photo, but you might get a better idea about the depth. The 3 dished areas still seem to get lost. I think I'll add a bead or V-groove on the rims next time. Worried about the intersections of the beads though. Silver maple turning at 200 rpm gets really fuzzy! I'm going to make a 36" diameter mdf faceplate with counterweights for the next one though. No more out of balance propellers for me, thank you very much!


Re: Now for something completely different

#7

Re: Different pic 3/4 view and oiled

john lucas

stands out much better in that photo. Yea not sure about a bead on the rim because of the carving but possibly a step 1/4" below the rim just to give a shadow line. Still pretty nice as is.

Re: Now for something completely different

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Now for something completely different

Keith Tompkins

HI Dick, Love it!!! No more comfort zone for you! :)

Re: Now for something completely different

#9

Re: Different pic 3/4 view and oiled

David Walser

I think it would be nice if the natural maple color showed through in the "bowl" sections. The contrast in colors would draw your eye and I think it would accentuate the contrast in surfaces. The smooth, sanded surface of the bowls with the rough surface of the rest of the piece is a nice contrast. Coloring the rough "unfinished" section and leaving the "finished" bowls their natural color is the opposite of what one might expect and would, I think, enhance the contrast.

Of course, if you were to have done as I suggested, I might think I prefer what you done did do. That's the fun thing about art pieces -- particularly those made from natural materials -- we never know for sure which of the many choices were optimal.

Regardless, what you did is outstanding. You should be justifiably proud of the piece.

Re: Now for something completely different

#10

Re: Now for something completely different

Don in Central Illinois

Dick, I really like this. I have had a couple of 'architectural' pieces that are still sitting in the shop. Gives me hope I can move out of bowls and hollow forms. Great job.

Re: Now for something completely different

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Different pic 3/4 view and oiled

Brad Vietje

Well, the best way to be sure is to make another one! This is a great start for a new series -- see where it takes you, and have fun.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Now for something completely different

#12

Steven Antonucci

Nitpicky, but...

steven antonucci

all of the chainsaw marks radiate from the turned circles, except for the upper left corner. If you look at the work of Christophe Nancey, you can see the unity of those lines radiating and the overall effect.

Other than that, I think it is pretty cool.

Steve

Re: Now for something completely different

#13

Yeah, I noticed that too, after I was done!

Dick Coers

I put some target marks on the stock to aim for, but somehow while I walked around the bench with a bouncing chainsaw ......... actually, no idea how that happened. I do know that it is not a relaxing procedure, controlling where the bar contacts (my bar has a long arc so longer marks needed a rocking motion during the cut), watching depth, and then the most challenging procedure of trying to achieve a controlled random pattern. A real contradiction! On the next one, I think I will put a light coat of black acrylic paint on before the chainsaw massacre. I will be able to see the pattern better compared to roughing up raw wood, and should sand off pretty easily before applying the dye. Who knows, it may just come out looking worse! Another thing I find humorous, I have about 5 tons of wood around here, but hardly any 3" thick, 2'+ long stock. I need more wood like I need....................That pattern change just gave me an idea, so expect something different again!