Re: Steel vs cast iron. *LINK*
David Walser
John -- I generally agree with your take. A well designed and built lathe made out of steel can be very smooth. And, it's really nice to have stainless steel bed ways. Still, the smoothest lathe I've ever seen is the Serious Wood Lathe from Serious Toolworks. It's 1,500+ lbs of cast iron goodness.
Years ago, the lathe was demoed at a symposium I attended. For most of the symposium, they had a large out of balance blank spinning on the lathe. On the headstock was a tall stack of children's blocks spelling out SERIOUS. While speaking to the guy manning the booth, I laid my hand on the bed ways. I could not feel any vibration. If I did not see the blank spinning, I would have sworn the lathe was off. It was that smooth and that quiet. When I expressed my amazement that I couldn't feel the lathe turning, the rep pulled a nickel from his pocket and stood it on edge on the ways. It just stood there. I've never seen or experienced anything quite like it.
Would a 1,500 lathe made of steel be as smooth? I don't know. I do know I've never seen a lathe as smooth as the one from Serious. Another top-end lathe, like one from Robust or Oneway, might be so smooth that the additional smoothness from Serious produces no discernible benefit. I think that's most likely the case -- at least for someone with my skill. Maybe a real pro with a real steady hand might benefit.
Does this mean the lathe is in my future? Maybe. I'd need to build a larger shop, first. But, there's a lot I like about the Robust lathes, so maybe I need one of each. ("Each" meaning Robust, Oneway, Vicmark, Stubby, etc.)
Serious Wood Lathe (Don't drool!)