Re: Suggestions solicited
Craig Daymon
I don't have any direct lathe recommendations. Your budget will certainly come into play.
With respect to tools, there are a few that I really don't think that someone starting out needs to splurge on.
1) 1/16" thin parting tool. Penn State sells one for about $17. That's less than half what the big brands will charge and it will easily do the job for a long time.
2) SPINDLE Roughing gouge. A P&N 1-1/4" Spindle Roughing gouge is a great tool, with lots of mass and a very strong tang. It's also expensive, though it should last a LONG time. Starting out, Penn State sells a 2" Spindle Roughing gouge for $49. (I swear it use to be closer to $30.) The large diameter makes it nice to use for a planing cut, similar but maybe easier to what you would do with a skew chisel. It will also work fine for roughing down spindles and the large diameter provides plenty of sharp area to use before returning to the grinder. This is a roughing gouge. Though the beef of the P&N makes it very nice to use, you are using it (aside from a planing cut) to rough down wood, so you don't need cryo powdered metal steel to get the job done.
3) I like the Packard spindle gouges. They are fairly inexpensive and nice to use. I also have a Thompson, which I use a lot, but I interchange it with the Packard often. Thompson tools are great, but they are more expensive and do require a handle to be made or the use of a handle that can exchange tools (which you can also make yourself).
4) One tool I really love and use it to shape the OUTSIDE of bowls, as well as spindle turning, is a 5/8" Thompson Spindle gouge. I use it in a Kelton handle that permits changing the tool.
5) 4 jaw chucks. I really like the Axminster chucks I've bought from Lee Valley. I have an Evolution chuck, that is really terrific and a bargain compared to the other higher end chucks, but Axminster has a number of chucks at very reasonable prices, with stainless steel bodies. All Axminster chucks can use all their jaws, which is something you don't get between a OneWay Talon and OneWay Stronghold. (Nova chucks also interchange jaws.) Axminster also offers the O'Donnell jaws and some really beefy dovetail jaws.
6) If you see a tool you want that is basically a HSS rod with the end ground a certain way, consider buying a drill blank of the right size and make your own. (Or Thompson sells a number of sizes of blanks in their steel, but they will be decidedly more expensive.) Tools in this category would be round skew chisels, 3 point tools or skewchigouges. (I have found a skewchigouge style tool useful.)
7) Similar to #6, and probably your largest tool expenditure, will be a bowl gouge. If you are thinking about an Ellsworth/Irish grind gouge, which are very useful, consider buying the same gouge in the conventional grind and grind it to that style yourself. You can save $40 by doing this. My main bowl gouge is a 5/8" gouge. (Keep in mind that there are different ways to measure gouge size, depending on where it is made. I think Europe measures the flute and the U.S. measures the steel diameter, though it may also depend on the catalog or maker, so read the descriptions.)
Always keep in mind that any tool you buy will be going to the grinding wheel, where it will be up to you to maintain the shape. So if there is a special grind that you think will be useful, check if it is more practical for you to grind a less expensive tool yourself.
9) Penn State also sells a nice 1-1/2" Round Nose Scraper thats fairly beefy at just under 3/8" thick. It's $32. The larger size also makes it nice to use shear scraping the outside of a bowl, though I will usually use my Ellsworth grind bowl gouge for this, mostly because it is frequently in hand. The thicker your scraper, the better because it is very susceptible to vibration. I have 2 Crown scrapers that are 1/2" thick, making them really nice to use.
10) Watch sales. I have several Crown Pro-PM tools that I got on sale from Hartville Tools for 50% off. I think I got the Crown scrapers from Woodcraft as part of a closeout sale. Again, about 50% off. Wish I had bought more as scrapers are useful to have extras to grind for special purposes. Could have made a Raffan point tip scraper from one.
My opinions, take them as you will. I have bought far more tools, especially hollowing, than I use on a regular basis.