Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Olive wood

Posts

Olive wood

#1

Olive wood

phillip Medghalchi

I just got this beautiful blank from someone here on line and last night I went to work on it so I rough turned it to this point as you can see in the pic.,



Qsn. here is that has anyone worked with Olive wood before and would the crack, or voids hold up if I epoxied it to fill it and incorporate it as part of the design or should I turn them away which will yield in a much smaller bowl? Any help is appreciated. Also, so I need to clean it with any solvent, if I want to finish it for decorative purpose with Lacquer? or, the oil in it will not let the lacquer adhere to it.

The cracks have depth to them as you can see.




Re: Olive wood

#2

Ellis Walentine

My advice: Be cautious

Ellis Walentine

That looks like "mission olive" from California, which isn't necessarily good or bad, but the stuff I've seen and played with was generally checked and gnarly like your piece, from lying around in abandoned groves for many years. The wood is brittle and demands caution when turning it, particularly when it has deep voids. I wouldn't trust epoxy to hold it together when the walls get thinner either.

So, the bottom line for me would be to take my chances if I thought that composing with the defects was going to yield a desirable finished piece, but keep your rpms as low as possible, wear a sturdy helmet/face shield, don't take aggressive cuts, and stay out of the line of fire. I suspect a lot of people wouldn't even take the chance. (Life's too short to turn crappy wood.)

I hope I'm not being overly wary, and I hope I'm not disparaging your piece ( I could be wrong; it might be solid as a rock underneath the defects) but I'd definitely err on the side of caution with that piece. As for a finish, in my experience, lacquer will adhere fine without special treatments.

Ellis

Re: Olive wood

#3

Re: Olive wood

John Lucas

Phillip I would simply change the shape and make it smaller. The rim is all chipped and has bad places. Just do away with it. I think too often people try to use every ounce of the wood when it would make a much nicer piece if you just make it smaller and do away with a lot of the defects.

Sure it hurts to see your precious piece of wood get smaller and smaller as you cut away at the defects but in the end you end up with a lot nicer piece.

I have a friend who turns lots of wood with defects and leaves them hollow. Quite often you wonder how he turned it without it exploding. Well the answer is he's a really really good turner and has just the right touch to know what he can get away with. Less skilled turners would have the piece explode on them and it simply isn't worth it to most of us.

I've been known to cut up wood like that and use it for smaller boxes. I just don't like to take chances.

Re: Olive wood

#4

Re: My advice: Be cautious

Dale Miner

In addition to the comments from Ellis regarding rpms and caution, I would wrap several or more wraps of filament tape on the outside before starting on the inside. Frequent stops for visual inspections also.

Re: Olive wood

#5

very interesting wood

Mike Potts

Phil, from your pictures that is very interesting wood, but if we think outside the box a little, does it have to end up as a bowl or a hollow form. the picture i like the best was when you had it turned upside down. just a thought but without putting yourself or the piece of wood at risk, could it not be a base for a larger project?

Safe turnning

Mike

Re: Olive wood

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Right on so far

lyle Jamieson

I agree with the advice so far. Johns note about skill level is dead on. (No pun intended) Turners need to sneak up on this kind of turning after many years of experience. It is not worth getting hurt over.

I would turn it with the voids after extensive inspection. I would clean the outside cuts up to remove the torn out grain so the inspection would reveal any cracks. If there are cracks its firewood. The voids are a different issue. I would not fill them but leave the voids. The inspections here from the outside, before hollowing, will make sure there is a sturdy "bridge" holding the piece together once the inside is removed. The peninsula of wood you show in the photo is a good example. If it is an island of wood, it's not good. Move the axis while between centers to find the best use of the wood that will allow you to turn safely. Once the outside shape is stable the hollowing is done in small stages. Do a half inch inside clean it up. Get it perfect and DONT GO BACK to it again. Do the next half inch and DONT GO BACK. This way the hollowing is done with solid wood as you work your way down into the vessel. Did I say DONT GO BACK??

Re: Olive wood

#7

Re: Olive wood

robo hippy

Yes, this piece is an expert level/high risk type piece. The big crack on the outside of the bowl doesn't look like it goes all the way through your tenon, but if you turn that tenon off, it will get into a weak area. It does look like there are cracks on the other side of the tenon. CA glue will not hold it together. If you epoxy fill it, that will lend some strength, but still, I would not trust it. I am with Lyle on turning it down some more to see how deep the defects go. If you do mount it as is for turning out the inside, I would also most likely wrap the outside in stretch plastic film, and stand out of the line of fire at all times (I do have a video clip of that on You Tube if you type in robo hippy). Turn at no more than 500 rpm, and nibble away at it. No heavy hogging.

robo hippy

Re: Olive wood

#8

Re: Olive wood

Barry Elder

My two cents: I have purchased and turned many pieces of olive wood from old Mission orchards, never anything that large, but olive is very prone to crack and is very tight grained. Your piece does not look like anything I have seen that is called mission olive. You need to be very careful that you protect your eyes and head in general when turning olive.

Re: Olive wood

#9

Steven Antonucci

totally different thought

steven antonucci

Why not put it aside until your skills are ready? Not meant to disparage in any way, but if you have to ask the questions, you may not be ready to turn this piece?

A couple of years from now, when you know the answers to your questions, you'll probably be better suited to turn it anyhow?

Steve

Re: Olive wood

#10

Re: totally different thought

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, I didn't think you'd come up with this kind of reply, I asked because this is the first time I am turning olive wood. Therefore, I was asking about the characteristics of this kind of wood. I have worked with voids and cracks in the past and successfully incorporated it into my design. I was not sure about a naturally oily wood such as Olive wood, whether it would hold up or would be too oily to use any kind of glue to enhance the effect. I wasn't aware that my qsn.s would offend people here or irritate them. I found this site to be helpful because turners here are willing to share their experience with others. Additionally, not all woods grow in every climate or locality, so asking someone about the characteristic of a wood only helps another turner to enjoy the new experience with that wood. Like mesquite would not grow up north and as a matter of fact, as you go about 300 mile north of San Antonio, you will not find this wood. Also, I was trying to turn this wood just as a courtesy to the person who took time to send it to me. Just to show my appreciation. and, since I do not know how much he/she had access to this wood i was trying to be careful to make something out of it. If it was Mesquite, I wouldn't worry about it because I can get my hand on it any time and any day. So, I wouldn't worry if I screw it up or make mistake, but this one is something that I may not get my hands on for a long time again.

I already did some research on line to see what has been done with Mission Olive wood. I think that Ellis is right and this may be a Mission Olive wood since from my research I found out that Mission Olive wood grows in CA and it was originally brought to USA by early Spanish settlers and is common in that region. Form the pic.s available on the web it appears or at least resembles that kind of Olive wood. The other thing I found out is that the voids and those cracks are inherent to this type of Olive wood and a turner on International Association of Pen turners has posted a pic. of a bowl he did in this wood and left the crack as part of his overall design. However, he did not mentioned that if it was easy to turn it or not. I am documenting every steps to share it later on if someone likes to know about this wood.

I may have to sleep on yhis a while to figure out the way I want to go with it.

Re: Olive wood

#11

Re: Olive wood

phillip Medghalchi

John, good advise. I am going to sleep on it for a while and figure out which way i am gonna go with. But, will take your advise to heart. Thank you.

Re: Olive wood

#12

Steven Antonucci

More different thoughts...

steven antonucci

It is a picture on the internet. It's really hard to tell if the wood is all solid? It is equally difficult to see how much wood is holding on the inclusions. It is also very difficult to tell is you are cutting or scraping. A lot of variables in the equation.

If you asked me what I WOULD DO, I'd follow the advice of those recommending a smaller form. The checking in the face of the block would all get turned away, and then I would start trying to figure out what I had left. I would also pay a lot of attention to the tenon you have, as it looks like it has an inclusion running through it? It may be the reason you've got the tear out in side of the bowl now (vibration)...

Personally, not a fan of "bowls that need repair before you get them off the lathe". Once I got past the broken bits, I'd start planning...

Steve

Re: Olive wood

#13

Re: More different thoughts...

phillip Medghalchi

I used the easy wood tool square rougher. Like I said, I have to think about what I am going to do next. but, thanks for the advise. Every one is different with what they are comfortable doing on the lathe. I have to find out which way I am leaning towards.

Re: Olive wood

#14

Sleep on it ...

Geoff Whaling

Philip, I rarely comment on these sorts of bowls with large voids. I can certainly appreciate the skill & knowledge it takes to successfully complete bowls with voids (structural defects). They look spectacular, but are they worth the risk? Only you know your comfort zone, but please consider those about you, your loved ones, family & friends when making a decision to proceed.

Personally I do not like seeing turners expose themselves to hazards with such high level risk and with a very high probability of failing. Certainly take all the time it requires to make a well considered approach to completing the project. There are ways to lessen the risk & I know of turners who use support structures and support rings hot melt glued to the outside of the form to reduce risk somewhat. Still leaves high level residual risk though from easily made errors on the turners part.

You probably do have the skills required to do this successfully and I sincerely wish you well if you do and you choose to go ahead.

For any turner tenatively considering such projects a visit to Lynne Yamaguchi's blog is a must read for any wood turner taking on blanks with defects. http://www.lynneyamaguchi.com/wordpress/

Re: Olive wood

#15

... I have.

Geoff Whaling

Philip,

Your project has been weighing on my mind. Firstly I applaud you for stepping back & considering how to proceed, what are the characteristics of this particular wood, the risks and potential for other hazards you are not aware of because of your unfamiliarity with it, potential stabilization options, etc.

If only many other turners would do the same, they would be at much less risk.

The thing that bothers me most, alarms me in fact, with this blank is the poor quality of the base of the bowl & tenon pictured. The bark inclusion/cracks & lack of sufficient stable material to resist crushing by the chuck jaws will cause the tenon to fail IMO. Only a matter of time of when it does.

If you proceed with this project please remove the unstable tenon and fit a glue block before you do any other turning. The glue block should be large enough to cover the full width of the bowl base & of sufficient thickness to attach a large face plate with robust coach bolts, rather than use larger chuck jaws.

Using a face plate removes one high risk hazard - the unstable & weak tenon in this example. Far less chance of the bowl blank moving on a face plate from the constant pressure cutting or a catch. Reducing the potential for movement further reduces the potential for a catch etc. BUT we may create another hazard - what is the potential for the glue block or glue joint to fail?

By steadily working through the hazards, realizing the risks and coming up with stabilization options, then considering any new risks or the residual risks a much less hazardous method of turning can be developed.

Whether it reduces risk and potential for severe injury to a level you & your family are comfortable with are questions only you can answer.

Take your time, work through it steadily, consider the merits of any advice given, implement procedures to minimize risk, and above all stop and take a break to regularly inspect the work piece. Stay safe.