Re: I strongly disagree
DKWalser
Gary - I don't intend to be disagreeable. I think we're just coming from slightly different perspectives and may be intending the same thing. When I worked in a furniture mill in the early 1980's, we used lots of Watco Danish Oil. We used it on our hardwood furniture to mimic the soft finish that was popular on Scandinavian furniture. Our pine furniture was finished with several coats of high-gloss lacquer. I never understood either design decision, but I digress.
So, why did I call Watco's Danish Oil a "film finish"? Because chemically it is. Its a mixture of linseed oil (I believe), thinners, hardeners, and varnish. It's designed to penetrate the wood and, if you wipe it off, it won't form a film -- but the same is true of the thinned lacquer I use as a sanding sealer. It penetrates and doesn't form a film, yet I don't think anyone would argue that my 50/50 mix of lacquer and thinner isn't a "film finish" merely because I wipe it off the surface. It is the method of application that prevents the formation of a film, not the nature of the finish itself.
Watco's "true nature" may be of only academic interest. It is a fine finish. It provides more protection than most true oil finishes. Watco sells it in a wide variety of shades and tints. It builds faster and dries more quickly than would a pure linseed oil. I don't use it as much as I used to, but it's part of my arsenal.
'Nuff said? More than enough, probably.