Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

couple of boxes

Posts

couple of boxes

#1

couple of boxes

kruizen

Same story with these made a couple month ago, I had the glue ups on the shelf for about a year and finally got around to turning them. They are oak and walnut, I like using watco oil and buffing out with the beall buffer but I always seem to get seem to get white diamond residue in the grain. I there some way to avoid this with out using a building finish? The photos don't show on the lower resolution.


Re: couple of boxes

#2

Re: couple of boxes

John Lucas

Excellent boxes and great glue ups. Just don't use the white diamond. Go from the tripoli right to the wax. When I buff really light porous woods I skip the tripoli and go straight to the white diamond.

Re: couple of boxes

#3

Re: couple of boxes

DKWalser

Two comment: Watco oil is a film type finish. It just takes a lot of coats to build. (It's a thinned down lacquer/varnish.)

Second, fill the wood pores with a few coats of sanding sealer. (I use a 50/50 blend if Deft lacquer and thinner.) Sand down to bare wood and your oil will still pop the grain. If you've filled the pores with sealer, the white diamond will no longer accumulate in the pores when you buff.

HTH

Re: couple of boxes

#4

There is no lacquer in Watco Danish oil DKW

Dick Coers

Watco oil is a film type finish. It just takes a lot of coats to build. (It's a thinned down lacquer/varnish.)

Mineral spirits is the solvent for Watco. Mineral spirits will not reduce lacquer. MSDS sheet for natural Watco Danish oil lists;

Mineral Spirits

Aromatic Petroleum Distillates

Raw Linseed

Oil Vegetable

Oil Resin

If it had lacquer in it, we would see xylene, toluene, methyl ethyl ketone, cellulose acetate butyrate, plus others.

Re: couple of boxes

#5

Re: There is no lacquer in Watco Danish oil DKW

DKWalser

Dick - I apologize to you (and the entire universe) for my (ever so slightly) inaccurate post. My only excuse is that I was at the doctor's office and posting from my cell phone and called into my appointment in the midst of posting.

You are correct, Watco Danish Oil doesn't contain lacquer. It contains varnish. From Rustoleum's website: "WATCO® Danish Oil is a unique blend of penetrating oil & varnish hardens in the wood, not on the wood." Instead of saying Watco Danish Oil contains "lacquer/varnish", I should have simply said "varnish".

I wrote what I did because I couldn't remember which product was part of the Watco Danish Oil formula. I didn't bother to look it up because I'm lazy and also because I didn't think it made a difference to my larger point: Watco Danish Oil is a film finish. So, please forgive me and thanks for the very public correction of one of my many faults.

Re: couple of boxes

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: There is no lacquer in Watco Danish oil DKW

Lyle Jamieson

You sound pretty hard on yourself. For a screw up...that was a pretty small version.

For a real screw up see my next newsletter where I HAD to apologize to some folks that got my new bowl gouge.

Re: couple of boxes

#7

I strongly disagree

GaryG in MD

Watco Danish is not a thinned down varnish. It is made up mostly of oils.

The reason it takes so many coats is that the main components are oils (and a little bit of resin) that soak into the wood and have very little "build". If you put on many coats, eventually the resin load builds up enough to block further entry, and then it starts to dry on the surface. But to say it is a "surface finish" (like lacquer or acrylic or poly) I believe is completely incorrect. ...GG

Re: couple of boxes

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: couple of boxes

Keith Tompkins

Well Done! :)

Re: couple of boxes

#10

Re: I strongly disagree

DKWalser

Gary - I don't intend to be disagreeable. I think we're just coming from slightly different perspectives and may be intending the same thing. When I worked in a furniture mill in the early 1980's, we used lots of Watco Danish Oil. We used it on our hardwood furniture to mimic the soft finish that was popular on Scandinavian furniture. Our pine furniture was finished with several coats of high-gloss lacquer. I never understood either design decision, but I digress.

So, why did I call Watco's Danish Oil a "film finish"? Because chemically it is. Its a mixture of linseed oil (I believe), thinners, hardeners, and varnish. It's designed to penetrate the wood and, if you wipe it off, it won't form a film -- but the same is true of the thinned lacquer I use as a sanding sealer. It penetrates and doesn't form a film, yet I don't think anyone would argue that my 50/50 mix of lacquer and thinner isn't a "film finish" merely because I wipe it off the surface. It is the method of application that prevents the formation of a film, not the nature of the finish itself.

Watco's "true nature" may be of only academic interest. It is a fine finish. It provides more protection than most true oil finishes. Watco sells it in a wide variety of shades and tints. It builds faster and dries more quickly than would a pure linseed oil. I don't use it as much as I used to, but it's part of my arsenal.

'Nuff said? More than enough, probably.

Re: couple of boxes

#11

yeah, ...

GaryG in MD

We agree on the details, so it's a matter of terminology.

Good enough. Thanks for clarifying. ...GG