I have read and witnessed heated discussions regarding who first turned a wooden hat. Well, it appears from this article published in 1883 suggests that turned wooden hats were around long before any of those folks arguing that they invented the process.
Wow that's cool. Yea it's kind of like me saying I invented the turned mirror or Ellsworth making the first hollow vessel. No shouldn't even put my name in the same sentence as David. What I mean to say is it's hard to claim something as common as a hat, hollow vessel or hand mirror.
Exactly! -- The key point in the article is “I moved the central point, and then turned as it suited me." Certainly sounds like multi-axis, not bending.
I've sometimes chastised people going into business making very close knock-off's of a Michelsen Range Rider hat, a Peter Bloch lampshade, etc..., but certainly these people didn't invent these forms. In truth, even if someone studies with a master turner, and tries to sell against them, there is still a master and a beginner.
I can make very nice hollow forms, for example, but I'm not David Ellsworth or John Jordan, and a real collector knows the difference. Someone who collects one of mine is almost certainly not going to collect the real deal from one of the great masters of the form, and the reverse is true, as well. My signature is just not worth the same, and likely never will be! It becomes truly criminal if anyone attempts an actual forgery, or tries to pass of their work as that of someone else. As long as we all sell our work under our own names, I think all is well.
Good to know that turned wooden hats go back 100 years earlier than we may have thought. I've only attempted one of them, and I don't think Hannes felt threatened at all